Sitemap
Alyssa Kwon

Alyssa Kwon

Powers

16 min readMar 12, 2025

--

Alyssa Kwon

Week 6/7: Design+Power Cards Progress

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

We began to discuss what sorts of topics we would want to focus on for our game and began with thinking about the different concepts we learned in class and also different card games that we could try and incorporate into the concepts. Some concepts we talked about was: the impact of power in design, social power & hierarchical power in SOD, the intertwinement of technology and class + labor, and much more. As we talked, we all noticed that we were really leaning towards the class we learned about metaphors. Ultimately, we honed in on the concept of combining the class of metaphors with a game similar to Cards Against Humanity/telephones.

The majority of the class was spent discussing and trying to fine-tune our ideas so that for the next class, we could come in with a couple of rough prototypes of how we were visualizing how our game would look.

Personal Prototype/Brainstorming

Concept

  • Metaphor Cards (black): Each card features a common metaphor used in media, politics, or everyday speech.
    - Reframe Cards (white): These are abstract concepts, tones, or thematic styles players must use to reimagine the metaphor.
    - *maybe* another color of cards: offers different topics or prompts for the players with the white cards to change the metaphor given in the black card
    ex. “Now make it dystopian”
    “Turn it into a slogan”
    “Reframe it with humor.”
    “Make it hopeful”

How to Play

  1. The round starts with a player drawing one Metaphor Card and reading it aloud.
  2. Each player draws one Reframe Card (also maybe a topic card).
  3. Using their Reframe Card as a prompt, each player has 1 minute to come up with a new metaphor that reframes the original.
  4. Players present their new metaphors out loud (bonus: explain the thinking if you want).
  5. The round judge → the person who picks the metaphor card (rotates each turn) picks the most insightful, surprising, or creative reframing.
  6. Winner gets the Metaphor Card; player with the most metaphor cards at the end wins.

purpose: Challenge players to reframe dominant/common metaphors in surprising or empowering ways — and spark conversations about how language shapes perception and power.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Original Ideation

When we met as a group, shared our ideas, and started to focus on one specific concept to progress on. As we were brainstorming the topic, emotion, and phrase cards → Kelsey and Alisha pointed out that a lot of our emotion cards were quite negative. It made us think about how it tends to be easier to create metaphors and such with a negative connotation more than something positive. Also the fact that we added more negative emotions than positive subconsiously. Kelsey brought up this emotion wheel which was pretty helpful for coming up with more variety of emotions.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
updated
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Design Planning

Reflection:

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

Document and summarize your final outcome, contributions, and collaborations. In your final Medium post, tell us about the game your team created:

  • What issue did you explore, and how is power built into the game?
  • What kind of interaction or mindset shift were you aiming for?
  • What happened during gameplay? What insights or surprises came up?
  • Shout out another group’s game you enjoyed. What made it fun or thought-provoking?

Include visuals (cards, sketches, gameplay moments) to help bring your story to life.

Overview: Our team designed a metaphor-reframing card game inspired by concepts we’ve learned during class around metaphors in design and social power. We took inspiration from games like Cards Against Humanity and focused on creating a collaborative and reflective game that challenges players to rethink common narratives through metaphor.

As we played the game, I noticed that it took some time for people to fully understand the concept of the game. However, with some more in-depth explanation, people got the idea of the game. The other group that we played the game with told us that they liked the game because it took more thinking to come up with a whole phrase, because it wasn’t just putting words together. Instead, we have the players actively try to reframe the metaphors with key cards that give different prompts and emotional themes. Something else we noticed while playing the game was that often times players would just try and make the most outrageous metaphors (that still fit into the theme) but still kind of strayed from the goal of the game being that students should be thinking deeper into how metaphors can be reframed in a more insightful way.

Something I enjoyed about the other game was that they incorporated more of the headline concept into their game. Theirs was pretty similar to ours in the sense that they also took inspiration from cards against humanities but it was interesting to see how differently things panned out with having multiple judges instead of one.

Week 5: Deconstructing Metaphors

Since I wasn’t able to do this activity with a group, I did my best to work on the activity by myself and decided to choose the Mental Health topic.

As I researched, I found that there were different metaphors based on the focus it was being used it. For example, in political/news articles, mental health was often phrased as a “battle” or a barrier in a sense.

more examples

  • “rebuild mental health”
  • “wave/surge in mental illness”
  • “battling demons”

Using these types of terms highlights mental health as some sort of threat or can imply that it requires the need to “fix” someone. Referring to mental health with these sorts of metaphors can often obscure the lived experience of individuals and can mask the personal struggle that some people may face with their mental health. Using these types of metaphors might social media outlets who might use these phrases to build reliability, or news outlets might use them to create a sense of urgency. However, it can also give people the idea that mental illness is a personal journey without support to help overcome it.

Get Alyssa Kwon’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

I decided to look deeper into the metaphor “battling mental illness”. This phrase can often imply that mental illness is something that needs to be fought and gives a sense of win or lose. Especially when referring to more severe cases of mental illness. It might also frame mental illness as an enemy and make people feel like they “failed” if they cannot overcome a mental struggle. An alternative metaphor might be replacing the word “battling” with “navigating” mental health. This gets rid of the negative connotation and suggests more of the idea of persistence. It allows people to feel a sense of direction, and it's not so linear like win or lose because navigation can happen in many different ways with different turns and ups and downs. Also, replacing “illness” with “health” also provides a more neutral connotation since illness is often correlated with more negative thoughts, while health can waver both ways. By linking mental health to navigation, it can encourage exploration and learning for people to find support and define their own direction toward well-being.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
navigating mental heath

A design intervention that this metaphor can be applied to is creating a personalized digital map that users can use to journal their mental health journey. This could potentially allow them to set wellness goals and gain access to helpful resources. Having it in the form of a map can help the users see their progress as a whole, but also the smaller specific situations.

Week 4: Looking, Seeing, and Thinking

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Power web based on the different technologies and effect on skills/knowledge

At first, we started by sharing our ideas and discussing how we felt that technology was affecting existing knowledge and skill sets. As we started mapping out our thoughts, we focused a lot on the AI aspect and how it can affect knowledge and skills in various ways. One way is how things such as text/image generation, chatgpt, or extensions like Grammarly can lead to people “relying on the unreliable”. While AI can feel convenient and more efficient at times, there is no denying that it is not always 100% accurate. However, with its frequent use, people can start to rely on it to the point where it can become dependent. We also focused on the effects in digital form/internet, and also more production-based thoughts like mechanical automation. We also created a graph based on the early adopters concept we learned in the last mini to analyze the correlation between basic skills and different age groups. Our kind of end conclusion to this activity was the thoughts of how different age groups are losing out on basic skills due to the constant increase of technological use.

The diagramming helped me think more about how critical existing skill sets and knowledge are to have, and it began to grow my concern about how younger generations are losing more and more of it. I thought a lot about how the older generations have been able to maintain the skills that they learned and continue to apply them in their daily lives today, and the clear answer was that they didn’t grow up with technology. Even though advanced technology might exist today, it was developed at a point where these important skill sets and different knowledge were more ingrained into something that couldn't really be lost. As for my generation, I realized that we are kind of in between the older generations and the younger generations because we technically grew up learning different skillsets, but are on the process of losing them because we are adapting more to the technological advancements, shortcuts, and AI that is becoming more and more prominent in our daily lives. This made me think more about how worried I am about losing these skills, but also worried about how the younger generations might not even be learning these skills to begin with, because they are growing up at a time where the basic skills they learn are the shortcuts given through technological advancements.

Week 3: Cycles, Patterns, and Shifts

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

I think some values that I want to carry forward that I thought about for my miro board are my past and present connection to being a Korean American who technically lives in both the US and Korea. I was born in the US and basically raised here until the end of middle school so in a sense I feel more American. However, moving to Korea has led me to reflect more on my Korean culture and also learn to appreciate it more. But one thing I realized is that even thought I have been living in Korea for almost 5–6 years now, my brain doesn't really adjust to that fact. For me, it feels like it's only been many 2 years since I moved, and I fully expect my family to move back to the US one day, even though that isn’t something that has been decided or really discussed much. I feel like, as basic as it may sound, the battle of figuring out how to balance my “Korean” and my “American” is something that I figure out day by day. I often find myself trying to decide if I want to be perceived as a “white-washed” Korean one day and someone who is more representative of being Korean the next.

This “battle” is something that can also be seen influencing the way I design as well. When I design pieces that I am able to incorporate more personal aspects into, I find myself trying to figure out how to explore my identity more and taking influence from more traditional Korean aesthetics and a more “bold” American style.

Aside from the cultural influence, something else I dove deeper into with this exercise was figuring out my personal design style. Since highschool, a lot of my work incorporated either pastel colors or my work was just very colorful in general. I also took a lot of influence from digital media and the concept of social media in a lot of my work. There were a lot of personal reasons why I resonated with so many aspects of social media, from the damage it can do to people to also the benefits its gives. I used this aspect along with my personal experiences to produce work that reflected my journey in my high school portfolio. In a sense, it was my way to reclaim the impact social media had for me because I was able to challenge the struggles I faced from, such as online hate and bullying, but also reflect and appreciate the beauty of it, like the significance of having a space to keep special memories in a little album or on a platform to remember significant moments from my life.

Week 2: Power Web

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Our Group Power Web

Step 4: Document and Reflect
Document your Power Web and reflect on the activity. Write a reflection on key insights and takeaways. This should take the form of a short visual essay; 1–3 paragraphs and 5–7 captioned images.

Consider the following prompts to guide your reflection:

  • Where is power concentrated?
  • Who benefits from the current structure? Who is excluded?
  • What forces (design, activism, policy) could shift power dynamics?
  • Where does design intersect or influence this structure?

Our group decided to focus on the CMU School of Design as our central power. We thought about different internal and external aspects. Some of the main internal powers we thought of were: design students (c,p, and e), design faculty, SOD admissions faculty, and studio spaces. Some external factors we considered were the demand for design jobs, the overall cmu school, parent’s contributions/expectations, academic platforms (canvas, adobe software, figma, etc.) and the local governement and scholarships/financial aid. We also considered some power systems that kind of fell in between internal and external such as cmu clubs and SOD alumni. Some thing that we considered heavily was how different people are affected by different power dynamics. For example, those students who attend the cmu precollege program might have a slight advantage when applying to the school of design for cmu because they’ve been able to get to know some of the professors that are a part of the admissions process and have been able to show their work ethic and skills. Some other factors for getting admitted to the school of design might be the factor of needing financial aid or receiving a scholarship. We also considered some of the power dynamics once being a part of the SOD. Because the community is very close knit, having close connections to professors might be something that benefits design students when it comes to later on when they are looking for a potential job opportunity or other external opportunities that might not be as accessible without the connections. We also thought about how social media platforms might affect the reputation of the SOD and how they are viewed by people who don’t have close of a connection to the program and might not have as much intel.

I personally placed myself in a position in between the school of design communications track and the tepper school of business becuase I am also looking to get a business minor. When I thought about how this power web affects me, I realized that sometimes it is more difficult to find resources that interest me more as a student who wants to pursue marketing design after college. While the Tepper school of business provides different business courses, there aren’t as wide of a range that focuses on different marketing aspects or more specifically marketing design courses. This makes it kind of difficult to expand on my interest because a lot of the time I need to turn to external resources and work alone to figure out how I can expand my skills in these aspects.

I think design can play a big role in shaping and influencing the power dynamics withim the SOD because it can serve as a method of interaction and determine how internal and external powers connect and communicate within the structure. One main aspect that comes to might are the influence of studio spaces and design culture. The physical design of the studios allow for students to interact with each other and influence collaboration. These spaces also mainly provide a functional aspect but also can create opportunities for networking. Social media is also a very obvious example of how design shapes power dynamics because it features visual branding that can attract future students and keep alumni updated on what is going on in the SOD.

Week 1: Design, Politics, and Protest

Power is everywhere — sometimes visible, sometimes hidden. This week, you will begin looking to map power and design through visual and written reflection on Medium.

  • One example where design has been used as a tool for power (e.g. propaganda, policy design, media control, etc…).
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Posts from the offical White House Instagram account

When I was thinking about which example I would want to use, the first thing that came to mind were some of the posts on the White House Instagram Account, especially these two posts. For an account that holds so much power and influence, it was so shocking to even learn that this was content that was ever posted for the public to see. These posts are super dehumanizing to immigrants and extremely provocative by mocking deportation and immigration policies. Some design aspects that I noticed for the Valentine's Day post is that they use “humor” in the content with the rhyme and also the overall design of the head cutouts and Valentine's theme design. The video uses an ASMR-style video which uses a common social media trend on the serious issue of deportation. The fact that there is a public comment section definitely does not help either, especially with other right-wing influencers like Elon Musk commenting “Oh wow” egg the content on. This can increase fear within the immigrant community and also normalize hateful posts on social media because it is coming from such a powerful and well-known profile. I think that social media will always be a scary place when content consisting of messages are getting publicized for almost anyone to see. I remember when I first saw these posts and couldn’t believe for the longest time that someone literally thought it was okay to post something like this on the White House Instagram account. I initially thought it was another meme or prank that someone had made but to learn that this is getting approved by the White House really puts the power of social media into perspective.

  • One example where design has been used as a tool for resistance (e.g. activist design, counter-surveillance, protest graphics, etc…).
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Geurilla Girls Work

I feel like the Guerilla Girls are a really great example of how they use design as a tool for resistance. They often use very bold and bright designs in their work through posters, billboards, and street art. To go more in-depth, they often use bold type or all-cap text and bright colors like pink and yellow to create high contrast and make their messages easily readable and stand out. This can be seen in all 3 of the images above. They often use impactful design with statistics and important information to get their messages across. For example, the middle image uses the bright pink color to highlight significant information such as “38% woman artists in the curated group shows” and there are also statistics in the “do women have to be naked to get into the Met Museum” that makes the message more readable and easy to digest. I think the fact they also often paste their work in unconventional places like city walls makes their work stand out even more. I could go on and on about the different tactics that the Guerilla Girls use in their work to make them stand out and memorable but TLDR I really admire the work that they do and the way they make their content visually and contextually appealing to make an impact on challenging sexism and racism.

My Visual Representation of Power

Press enter or click to view image in full size
passport

I chose the passport as my visual representation of power because it holds a lot of national and political power and influence. This thought came from a past conversation I had with my friends when we started discussing our different passports and questioned their rankings in power. I find it so interesting that certain passports hold more power which allows them to travel freely to more countries while others have more restrictions. It was also quite shocking to figure out how far down on the rank the US passport was in comparison to what I assumed it would be.

Group Discussion → similarities and differences noticed

  • political influence
  • physical strength/appearance
  • organic vs man-made

Reflection

I thought Melissa’s comment about her thought of power based on the book Fahrenheit 451 “censoring something gives it more power and draws more attention to it” was insightful. I began to reflect on the fact that this was something that I could recognize if I thought about it but wouldn't have noticed in day-to-day life. I find it really interesting that power can be found in so many different forms and ways and can hold such various connotations. I think this discussion has expanded my understanding of power and it is also allowing me to view different scenarios with more consideration and trying to figure out if there is power within it.

--