What is repeal day? or…Look out St Patrick’s day, there’s a new holiday for idiots!
Devout Christians get on their soapboxes at this time of year, they talk about the true meaning of the holiday season and sometimes get angry because most people don’t understand their passion & beliefs. I am not pious enough to have this burden; I make my living off of selling alcohol. I do however have the same issues about misunderstanding the point of a different December holiday: Repeal Day. Sure, every religious holiday is more important than Repeal Day, but this is my culture so I’m going to ruin this potentially fun holiday for you by bumming you out with knowledge!
December 5th is actually the only true drinking holiday. -Jamie Boudreau
With the 21st amendment, on December 5, 1933, the prohibition of alcohol in the United States of America was repealed.
Each year when this date comes along, I see many people dressed up like gangsters, flappers and true idiots to “celebrate.” I am for these parties, but prohibition has a lot of meaning to me because of my chosen profession. What is the meaning of this holiday? Here are a few things to meditate on before donning a fedora or a string of pearls and hitting the town to swill gin.
The temperance movement in America began in earnest in the 1830s. This is indeed peculiar because it wasn’t until 1806 that America even understood what a cocktail was. The temperance movement gained ground because of the bad behavior of drunks. Drunk people slept in late, didn’t go to work, got fired, couldn’t provide for their families, got angry, got in fights, beat their family, repeat. The repeat portion mainly came from America’s growing economy needed lots of (under-paid) labor and need more labor than their were workers and from the fact that it was legal to beat one’s family with impunity. It is not surprising that these neglected, battered, or broken women would begin to organize and fight the “demon” alcohol. Bereft of the right to vote and with no political constituency, women had to fight the intangible concept of alcohol abuse.
It took them 100 years to succeed.
Bartenders & historians alike will make fun of Carrie Nation. You may have seen pictures of her in a history textbook, she looks like axe murderer version Whistler’s mother. She is known for taking said hatchet into bars and destroying bottles, bar tops, and the private property of the pub owner. I have heard her be called a terrorist. This is not very accurate because while she committed all of these acts of violence, vandalism and terror she did so in illegal bars. Carrie nation destroyed bars in Kansas that were all ready illegal before prohibition. Though she was jailed on multiple occasions for this vandalism she was never successfully charge because in doing so police judges and political officials would have to have admitted they were turning a blind eye to the law.
Get Andrew Bohrer’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
The Women’s Christian Temperance Union however had a different two-pronged approach, both of which you will have learned about in history class before and have always proven very successful. Though the chance of having a brick thrown at you is very high, nonviolent protest has always worked, eventually. The WCTU used prayer and nonviolent demonstration to prove their points. Those who threw beer, water and stones at them clearly became the assholes. Their other weapon was the religious extremism and untrue propaganda about alcohol. They sponsored schools to teach these lies to children. They indoctrinated a tiny “dry” generation to fear alcohol. This may have been the only point in history where drunk people were more honest than sober people.
By 1920 many states and municipalities already had banned alcohol (many still do today).
The 18th constitutional amendment became the first part of the Constitution to limit rather then expand the rights of the American people.
Let that scary thought sink in for a bit.
Other historians will tell you of the raucous parties, amazing bootlegging adventures and the complete abuse of alcohol during Prohibition. It was an utter failure. While those stories are fun, countless Americans died smuggling alcohol, drinking tainted alcohol and being casualties of an all out war on alcohol. Fortunately now the ATF, and the FDA do what they can (though not always perfect) to make what we put in our bodies safe.
13 years later America change their minds.
By 1933, America was ready for a drink again and alcohol was really re-legalized with the 21st amendment.
And while I am not a constitutional scholar, generally speaking the 21st amendment boils down to a simple idea “the federal government won’t legislate morality,” but, “states can.” The drought of a dry America helped cause worldwide economic depression. Sure, you could say that the stock market crash helped with that too, but every American distillery and brewery along with most Irish distilleries closed because of lack of demand during America’s dry spell. The American whiskey industry began again in earnest after Prohibition but got shut down again by World War II and bourbon production didn’t begin consistently again until the 60s. America went from hundreds of breweries pre-prohibition to just a handful after. Even until the year 2000, there were only about eight whiskey distillery’s in America and four in Ireland.
80 years later Americans still have the right to drink but we rarely consider why we lost the right to drink.
I could never say that America didn’t have a drinking problem, empirically, we drank more in the times before and in some cases during prohibition. But what America really had a problem with, was women’s rights, unsafe alcohol use and even less safe alcohol abuse. We had a propaganda machine lying to us about our personal health and no educated people to stand up against it. We had 13 shitty years that in many ways we’re still getting over.









