Sitemap

When do you stop believing?

Testing tolerability

10 min readNov 10, 2013

--

The patience of libertarians is being tested. The question is when do they stop tolerating the system. When they stop; what do they do?

Types of belief

People believe for different reasons; or more accurately,people subscribe to certain epistemological justifications to support their beliefs. In such cases, their beliefs are either supported by:

  1. Intellectual efficacy
  2. Practical outcomes

We all want to find some deeper reason for doing something. Today, I heard that a libertarian was giving up the virtue of a ‘libertarian society’ because of the lack of support. Not because people were not interested in libertarian ideas, or that those ideas did not make sense. In fact, he retains his libertarian beliefs. Instead, he substituted a ‘coherent ideological’ belief for a ‘practical belief’. From henceforth, his actions would be directed by what was practical. Perhaps he always subscribed to these beliefs. Perhaps he had just reached a ‘turning point’ where he concluded, I don’t want to throw out what I’ve learned, but I need to find a new way of teaching people.

His argument is that he will not stop fighting for libertarianism. In fact, his argument is that he will be far more effective in the ‘mainstream’ National Party than he will be as a lone individual attempting to enlist people into an organisation that cannot be sustained. I personally think he has a very superficial notion of his values.Or perhaps better stated; I think he is attempting to impose his ideas on others, and that his idea of ‘progress’ is a political system, not all the steps that are required to attain that system. Now, in his defence, if you are to educate people, you have to start with a platform. Agreed. But how is one served by sanctioning a platform that does not attempt to convince or educate people, but rather, seeks to impose or compel people to accept their values. Their moral sanction comes from:

  1. Not rationality, but popularity
  2. Not moral clarity, but ambivalent acquiescence
  3. Not persuasion, but isolation or intimidation

When you take that path, don’t you stop being an educator. Isn’t it our discretion to be poor at education, to fail at our task, that makes us a better educator. Well, true presumably if we:

  1. Don’t blame the people we are trying to educate — they are 100% responsible for themselves — not our results
  2. Don’t keep making the same mistakes

What however if the system was sabotaging us? This is where I actually have some sympathy for my friend. There are a great many people getting rich, and some of them are even libertarians. It only takes one to make a difference; to identify the idea that will make a difference to the way we relate as humans. The problem is not that people don’t believe. The problem is that there are no believers with the financial resources to challenge the legitimacy of the system. There are conservatives like the Koch Bros who spend a great deal of money, not to change the system, but to ‘defend the economic relativist’ aspects of the system they treasure. In the meantime, there is:

  1. Growing wealth and income disparity — not that these are necessarily bad things, but they inevitably are when people’s security are undermined. People are not going to grasp or respect important moral and conceptual knowledge when they are destitute. There is a reason wealthy people develop businesses. Its not just the money; its the values and optimistic sense of life that demand only the patience to achieve. Destitute people, the poor, the drug addicts, are tragically grabbing to the now, whether its the government’s welfare cheque or the last hit. Call it indulgence if you like, or a lack of self-discipline or personal aspiration, but its origin really lies in tragic experiences. The only difference between equally disengaged liberals and conservatives, is the fact the conservatives have never really had a bad life experience to change their values.
  2. Declining education — Growing illiteracy and inability to think conceptually. The answer is not ‘more resources for schools’; the answer is aspirational values for teachers and principals.
  3. Intergenerational tragedy — People raised in tragic values are going to struggle to break away from those values. This is a particular concern when you have people being raised in ‘tragic ghettos’ where people have no role models.

Libertarianism today is mistakenly considered a ‘philosophy’. It is not that. It is really a political movement with multiple philosophical ‘factions’. The problem is that:

  1. They seldom give identification to those different schools
  2. They are dominated by ‘conservatives for smaller government’, rather than true libertarians who want to end the coercive state. i.e. The initiation of force.

The implication is that people are directing their energies in support of libertarian ‘politics’, whether its the Libertarian Party in the USA, the Liberal Democratic Party in Australia (now with first libertarian senator), the ACT Party in New Zealand, without acknowledging that these are not libertarian parties at all. They are really ‘coercive’ conservative parties which want the ‘balance of power’ that would give them all the wrong type of influence. How do you sanction non-coercive government by seeking coercive power.

Get Andrew Sheldon’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

The solution for libertarians is not to seek this type of power. The solution is to amass a sufficiently large number of ‘non-coercive’ supporters and simply define one’s own identity. Now, this give rise to a cynical derision for ‘utopias’, and we can all agree. We don’t want to sacrifice what is good about contemporary society by ‘starting over’. This however is not the issue. The issue is how to be effective in one’s influence. There are several important issues:

  1. Vulnerable minority — Libertarians are weakened by their individualism in the midst of others who lack it. Their individualism is a source of contempt by others. We make others feel bad. We make them reproach their actions and the outcomes of their society. We make them think when they don’t want to think. They attack us from the cowardly position of the mob sanction. They cannot intellectually sustain a challenge against us. They don’t have to. They have the support of enough liberal and conservative voters to control the police and the military.
  2. Sustained destruction — They shape the political system and the anti-intellectual discourse that drives it. They control the religious and public education systems, and they are ‘growing their number of people’ faster than we can impact our immediate family. We are made to feel vulnerable because we don’t live by extortion.

How to be effective

The question of how to be effective is not an easy one when you are illegitimate under contemporary systems. It is hard to identify as a victim when you don’t identify as one. We are however ‘physically’ weak, whilst they are intellectually weak. That is why they would never advocate or permit a ‘rational system’. This is why we are left with an extortionary ‘representative’ system as a sanction for political discourse. Their justification comes down to:

  1. Practicality — Its not practical to convince everyone. People need to be compelled to act morally. Stronghold of the conservative. They are the custodians of aspiration and prudence….not the rational type; but rather the ‘reticent type’.
  2. Human nature — People are inherently bad, so they need to be regulated.
  3. Social sanction — The good of society is more important than the good of any individual. Stronghold of the liberal socialist; their ‘progressive’ programs basically reduce to rationalisations to steal, whether its phony climatic predictions, scientific rationalisations to sanction animal rights, or simply emotional appeals lacking any pretence of rationality.

It ought to be apparent that the debate in mainstream political society for liberals and conservatives is really not to convince you that they are right; but to convince you that there is no point in you thinking anything. The reason why their system is unsustainable is that ‘humans don’t have instincts’. We have to learn to make food; we need self-esteem to aspire for things. We don’t aspire to live in a gutter. And more critically, we know what is possible. So on some level, whilst we can blind ourselves to the awareness that society is gradually deteriorating; there is plenty of evidence to the contrary. There is evidence in the form of:

  1. Acts of generosity — There is still scope for an optimistic sense of life in the world; mostly for conservatives.
  2. Wealth creation — nevermind that its mostly extorted these days from others and making us vulnerable to social upheaval of the ‘coercive’ type.

Whilst we cannot consider conservatism as a defence of liberty; perhaps we can measure the ‘backwardation’ of society in terms of the sanction for conservatives. So long as ‘conservatism’ prospers, we don’t prosper, but at least we don’t go backwards. The reason I say this is because I don’t think Russia succumbed to communist ‘backwardation’ because it had no smart or educated people. I would suggest it was because the vast majority of people were uneducated, collectivists, who were mobilised by some educated ‘middlemen’ who attempted to capture power. This is no different that labor parties in the West appealing to the ‘lowest common denominator’ to win votes. The distinction is simply the desperation imposed or accepted by people as a ‘way of life’, that allows tragic values to dominate the healthy aspirational values. It doesn’t even matter whether a society is just or not; at issue is whether they have an objective conception of justice. The problem is that in ‘mainstream’ society, people are not looking. They think society will be ok…is only people vote for the conservatives. The problem is that we are heading for financial oblivion (that’s to Alan Greenspan & those who enabled him, including foreign heads of state), so we can expect those tragic values to prevail, as they did in the wake of the Great Depression. This is ultimately what gave rise to Hitler and the Spanish Civil War.

What to do when tolerance is unsustainable

There will come a time when there is a sufficient number of libertarians to make a difference. Whether they decide to:

  1. Stop paying tax and risk going to prison. The prison system is full of drug pushers, users, and there is of course room for libertarians. The ultimate challenge then is to amass a sufficiently large number of people that governments cannot place you in prison. What then?
  2. Seeking some form of utopia — Whether going to hinterlands, SE Asia or joining some community like the members of Utoia, Ohio.
  3. Keep tolerating — Staying on track to amass wealth and just direct one’s energy towards materialism.

Not paying tax is destined to attract the wrong type of attention from liberals and conservatives. Moreover you don’t have a fair foundation to defend yourself when:

  1. The rhetoric of people is unaccountable. i.e. Statements like ‘everyone has to comply with the rule of law’. Now, I’m not an anarchist. I happen to think laws are good, hierarchy is natural, and abuses of it are questions for philosophy (morality) in the first instance, then law having established one’s philosophy. The problem is that we have inherited a ‘law of practicality’. It was not shaped by values. That’s why contemporary law is a ‘fumbled’ mess of multiple legal traditions. People never cared about integrity; they wanted results. The people in power only cared that it served them. That’s not to say that it always does. This illegitimate law is however not considered a reason to challenge it. Instead, it is argued we must renounce our personal happiness to the ‘rule of law’, irrespective of our values, or the legitimacy of our claims. We have to wait for the grace of the liberals and conservatives to shine upon us with generosity; never mind their dispensation to profit at the expense of others, and for ‘those others’ to think this extortion-based system will satisfy their grievances (after 100 years of failing to do so). People are not ‘below the law’; they are in fact above it, but not unconditionally so. The law is to serve humanity. Not in a utilitarian fashion; but in the tradition of common law. Not a perfect framework, but a reasonable ‘historic attempt’ at a body of law, that required ‘nurturing’; and not being swept aside by arbitrary, extortion-based statutory law.
  2. The smears will allow witch-hunts: The system would allow libertarians to be ‘hunted’ or persecuted. Not just physical brutality, but the legal resources of society being directed ‘by process of law’. i.e. Their intent will in the first instance be to gain legitimacy.
  3. The playing field is not fair, i.e. The media will not give you a fair platform to challenge your opponents. Their criticisms will go unanswered. The court system will not offer you fair justice. On the contrary, the system is designed and controlled by liberals and conservatives who will want to ‘make an example of you’.

The government has no legitimacy

The reason why ‘stability’ is celebrated is because its ‘a tragic story’ of ‘not losing’. We have allowed liberals and conservatives to develop and politicise an entirely life-negating narrative. Its occurred by default — because neither of these groups can articulate a life-affirming value system. This results in:

  1. Liberals mobilising the thuggish labourers to steal or to threaten violence to take what they want to ‘believe’ is rightfully theirs
  2. Conservatives ‘reacting’ to defensively appease them. We remain in this sanction only because Conservatives, as privileged gentry adopted this ‘voting system’.

The liberals understandably wanted membership to this exclusive club, and we’ve since invited by formalising ‘representative democracy’ as a franchise in extortion, to participate in the ‘modern legislature’. Nevermind that the rules and procedures of these institutions are so backward to beg belief.

Defiance of this system is not a crime; its an act of moral righteousness. Whether you are right or not becomes irrelevant in an immoral system. Importantly, eventually, good ideas do prevail…at least as long as there are a majority of aspirational people, i.e. conservatives. The problem is that conservatives have presided over the financial system, and they are just about to plunge us into a catastrophic state of ‘tragic destitution’, which will embolden and aid liberals to extort greater concessions at everyone’s expense. The Conservatives are dangerous because they drive us away from healthy values by positing as ‘market advocates’. They are not; they are advocates of extortion. The only sustainable ‘aspirations’ can be served by libertarianism, i.e. A philosophy of life, not a philosophy for defence.

Andrew Sheldon: ‘Conservatism is the marshal arts of the mind. Its not a growth strategy’.

Read more at www.sheldonthinks.com or talk to me on Facebook.

--

--

Andrew Sheldon
Andrew Sheldon

Written by Andrew Sheldon

Philosopher, writer, critical thinker, consummate researcher. Founder of SheldonThinks Publications http://t.co/SC00JeJs