Looking away
The first time there’s shock, then indignation, then the sense of injustice. The second time, the cycle goes on again, except slightly fast; surprises moves into anger into a much smoother motion, and then you see the slap on the wrist, the statement about a made up condition, the comfortable exile abroad as a daring sexual curiosity. The third time there’s nothing but tiredness.
Every woman knows a harasser; if they managed to escape encountering one directly, then they have grown up hearing about them; men like that are on the tip of every mother’s tongue, in the form of advice or reprimands or concerns. Later, in adulthood, their childhood warnings become real; nobody lives with their early-life horrors in the way that women do. Every woman knows a man who groped their friend, a man who forced himself to girls half their age, a man who ruined a girl’s life.
The Weinstein revelations are meant to be a turning point; like magic, suddenly men beloved and respected are revealed to have been monsters all along. So brutal is the change that it begins to resemble an apocalyptical infection; it crosses the seas, it destabilizes the government. Yet there’s nothing new about this disease; it’s so old that you could have diagnosed it fifty years ago: we live in world that was made for men, and men protect their own.
This might sound heavy written down, the power of word making it sound like a curse rather than a statement of fact. However, it’s true is undeniable. There was no divine determination that decided men would feel entitled to the bodies of those under their power. Nature did not create the social circumstance that permits it. If Weinsteins exist it’s because they stand on the shoulders of much nicer, much better men.
Get Julia, from twitter’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Everyone knows by now about not all men phenomena; by now it’s such a tired punchline that you are not even bothered to tell the joke anymore. But that belief has some relevance when we start to question how could these case go on for so long. If every woman knows a harasser, then cold logic demands that every man must know them too. Nice men, men who wouldn’t touch you, men who feel sickened at the thought of ever doing something like that themselves. All of them end in the same place: looking at you with big stunned eyes, are you sure?
This question “are you sure?” exists because the existence of a trauma of that nature is disturbing; it makes the universe twist into something wrong. It should happen to someone else, caused by a shady figure in alleyways. Of course, men hear about the rumors, but they tell themselves they are just rumors. Men know about the girls whose lives have been ruined, but there is always an excuse. She misunderstood him. He should be reprimanded, but not suffer extreme consequences like losing his job. This shouldn’t turn into a witch hunt. It was an earnest mistake. If you try hard enough, you can spend your whole life looking away. You can build institutional blindfolds.
Some of the men looking away are women, even: the Theresas and the Margarets and the much more mundane, less powerful ones, the mothers who tolerate their sons’ troubling behaviours and wives who tell their husbands they are hopeless. These women have some share of the blame, but the burden of it is not on them — they are trying to get first place in a system that’s been rigged against them. Women can wish to be respected above their gender, but they can never truly escape it; sooner or later they face harassment for being too desirable or not desirable enough.
Privilege is a deeper bond than love. Coming to terms to with that is a heavy thing. It makes us doubt those closest to our hearts; our fathers, our brothers, our best friends. All of them communicate in that language of privilege: she could have been making it up, she could have been exaggerating, she was always a bit off. It’s not the monsters that let harassment go on; it’s the humanity of good men that makes them falter, ignore, fool themselves. Men see harassers as people; they fail to see the humanity in women.
Politics is built in loyalty. This is not only party politics; there is also a political project that counts on men’s loyalty to each other and their silence on certain issues. Leftist men, right leaning men, authoritarians, liberals, centrists; over any label or identity, there is a common power shared by all. Addressing that dark heart is desperately difficult. We all want to help victims in abstract, because nobody likes to think of themselves as a bad person. When the time comes, though, old habits make it easy to do otherwise. If we are going to change, it’s not just institutions that must do better (though they desperately must do better); it’s men who must open their eyes.









