Sitemap

Fukushima Radiation is Not “Frying” the West Coast.

5 min readJan 15, 2014

--

Over the past couple of months, you may have noticed headlines like this one lurking in your social feeds: Supposed litanies of evidence that Fukushima radiation has reached American shores in lethal amounts, killing wildlife, contaminating fish and rendering the California coast a lifeless “dead zone”—at least in the words of one Infowars report, which amounted to one writer’s observation that a county beach was “unnaturally clean”. Accompanying is a map from the Nuclear Emergency Tracking Center, an uncredentialed website that sells radiation tracking kits. The original “28 Signs” article was published on the website of a DC author, Michael T. Snyder, whose book The Beginning of the End is advertised adjacent to the piece, along with silver and gold coins, survival supplies and an array of suspiciously empty sublinks.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
some important information from Michael Snyder

If that alone isn’t enough to discredit such alarmist litanies, consider this report released by the California Department of Public Health earlier this month. The report details results from a two-year study of sea water, sea life, soil, vegetation, and milk samples. Among all the various types of samples collected,

very low levels of radioactivity were detected in milk during the Fukushima accident, which were well below any level of health concern. Low levels of radioactive Potassium-40 (K-40, NORM) were detected. -CDPH, 1/2014

Further, data from federal agencies, other state agencies and the Department’s own tests concluded that there are no health or safety concerns for California residents.

No one is denying outright that Fukushima radiation has reached the United States, however. Daniel Hirsch, Nuclear Policy Lecturer at UC Santa Cruz, explained to me that “in the first few months of the Fukushima accident, there was elevated radioactive iodine that fell on the United States — not just the West Coast — in rain. That iodine (131) was at levels substantially above the EPA’s safe drinking water levels. But iodine 131 has an 8-day half-life, so all of that is gone by now.

“cesium and strontium may have reached the United States, but in quite small concentrations…we’re talking about minuscule additional risk for individuals.”

Get Annie Gaus’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

What about that Youtube video that you saw with the random guy with the Geiger counter measuring radiation along the Pacific Coast? The frantic beeping is dramatic, but Hirsch points out that this decontextualized reading is extremely misleading: “A Geiger counter measures just the gross radioactivity. It can’t tell you whether you’re getting that from radium, which might be there from nature, or whether you’re getting it from cesium.”

That viral video, as noted in an annotation at the beginning of the clip, was shot by someone named “Dave” and first posted to the website Rense.com, which is a sort of a Drudge-style news aggregate containing headlines like “Jew-Bought Congress Kills Iran Deal” and “It’s Beginning to Look A Lot Like Saturnalia”.

Rense.com’s proprietor, Jeff Rense, talk radio host and self-proclaimed “American treasure”. Did not star in Wayne’s World.

And the video, titled Fukushima radiation hits San Francisco? (Dec 2013), is quite plainly packaged with the intent to imply that the radiation originates in Fukushima. But despite its defenders’ insistence that the Geiger reading amounts to unimpeachable scientific fact, a Geiger reading by definition cannot identify the source of radiation.

“The video has caused an unnecessary panic,” Hirsch says.

Still feeling skeptical that naturally-occurring radium would result in “Dave’s” high Geiger reading? You have reason to be. The Bay Area has hosted unnaturally-occurring radioactivity since at least the 1940s, originating with the U.S. Navy at the Hunter’s Point Naval Shipyard. In 1946, the Navy established the Naval Radiological Defense Laboratory (NRDL), which conducted research around ship shielding, deep-sea disposal of radioactive waste, animal research and radiation-detection instrumentation for several years prior to the establishment of a permit process by the Atomic Energy Commission, now the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. NRDL operated until 1969, was deactivated in 1974, and was designated as a priority site for cleanup in 1989. As of October 2012, the EPA estimates that the cleanup operation is 30% completed. You can read more of the current status of the Hunter’s Point site here.

Where did all that radioactive waste go? A public 1980 report from the EPA tells us that “from 1946 to 1970, the United States disposed of these radioactive waste materials either by shallow land burial at government-owned sites, or by ocean dumping at AEC-approved sites”. Those sites included the Farrallon Islands, located approximately 30 miles off the coast of San Francisco, which received “approximately 99 percent of the radioactivity dumped into the Pacific”.

So yes, of course there’s a possibility that high Geiger reading isn’t natural. Maybe radioactive material has been so long present on Bay Area beaches that we’ve come to concede its existence as part of the “natural” world. But to accept as fact that a high reading is Fukushima-induced is to ignore far immediate sources of good old home-grown American radioactivity. And to willfully spread the Fukushima panic in California is to promulgate both scientific and historical ignorance.

Why has this panic caught on now, if this online content sharing is any indication? Because, undeniably, the Fukushima accident is a catastrophe that is almost too awful for us to contemplate. We should be extremely concerned for the people of Japan. And perhaps, on a strange subconscious level, imaginings of nuclear fallout reaching our shores is some backwards expression of that concern. But much likelier, it’s an opportunity for end-times profiteers to expel more fear into the ecosystem, which in America is far more pervasive — and arguably lethal—than Fukushima radiation ever will be.

--

--

Annie Gaus
Annie Gaus

Written by Annie Gaus

I am a reporter and producer in San Francisco, CA.