The potential of African Identity in Advertising
Why look West for inspiration?
This starts in Oslo in 2003. While working there as a creative director I gave a presentation to the Norwegian ad’ industry about the potential of Nordic identity in advertising. It came about because I was intrigued by the quirks of their culture. One of the things that drew me to Norway — besides a Nordic wife and the endless variety of ski slopes — was their advertising.
Effects of globalisation
But while I was there I saw their ethos give way to the effects of globalisation with a shift towards emulating the styles of the West. Nordic work had always been a breath of fresh air to me, a respite from the sameness one sees on the international awards circuit. Their strange (to westerners) sense of humour and unique character used to help them pull international awards and my aim with the presentation, as a foreigner reflecting their own identity back at them, was to show them an unbiased and objective appreciation of it. To back it up, I highlighted the success of the Indian identity that was on the rise in advertising at the time, something even the West was emulating.
In 2011 I gave a similar presentation to the Red & Yellow School of Logic & Magic, an Advertising college in Cape Town, South Africa. The focus of the presentation was the potential of our own African identity with inspiration garnered from travels and research I had done on the continent.
Judges on awards panels
Because of the variety of judges on international advertising award panels, the greater percentage of them being European and American, the South African work entered tends to be Western in style in order to appeal to the tastes of the jury and communicate clearly to the broader spectrum.
There is no disputing that some of our favourite South African ads would not be understood there, but there is an opportunity we are missing. There is potential to leverage our own ethos. After all, there is a taste for it overseas; and we can start by looking at music videos. Beyonce’s video, “Girls (Who Run the World)”, is one. The dance style is derivative of our own Pantsula. The casting, environment and styling are African to the core.
Photographer Pieter Hugo’s powerful series, “The Hyena & Other Men”, is the inspiration for one of the most impressive scenes. In fact, much of Hugo’s “Nollywood” series is directly emulated in another powerful music video: Nick Cave and Grinderman’s “Heathen Child”.
Gnarls Barkley’s video, “Going On”, Is a wonderful expose of contemporary African fashion. The thing that grabs the viewer is the juxtaposition of styles — traditional African adornment mixed with western styles — outfits that our own Smarteez would wear.
Films and books
Beyond music videos, the West is looking at contemporary SA culture with a keener eye. Look at the success of Neill Blomkamp’s “District 9" and Lauren Beukes’ internationally acclaimed novel, Zoo City. Both give science fiction —a typically Western theme — a contemporary South African slant. This is undoubtedly a huge part of their success.Yet we do have stories that are true, distinctly African and important to tell to the international audience. “Hotel Rwanda” shone a light on the greatest African tragedy of modern times. It opened the West’s eyes to something overshadowed in the media at the time, ironically by the genocidal war of Yugoslavia and, beyond that, the OJ Simpson trial.
“Blood Diamond” was another. Although fictional, it brought attention to the important issue of illegal diamond trade. Then there is the recent “Bang Bang Club” that traces a pivotal time in our history, and no one can deny the success of Academy Award winning “Tsotsi” to expose the darker and paradoxically humane part of South African society.
Little positive about Africa
Sadly, if we look at international film exposure, there is little about Africa that seems positive. To be simplistic about it, Africans — white or black — often play the bad guy. Think of Arnold Vosloo, the mercenary leader in Blood Diamond.
Get anton crone’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
The truth is our characters are often singularly inspirational because they are African. There’s William Kamkwamba, the Malawian youth who made a wind generator from scrap to power his home and eventually his village. Kwame Nkrumah-Acheampong, aka The Snow Leopard, who was the first Ghanaian to compete in the downhill skiing at the Winter Olympics. The late Wangari Maathai, whose tireless devotion to the environmental issues of Africa won her the Nobel Peace Prize — the first African woman to do so. Then there is N’gan’ga Maruge, an ex Mau Mau freedom fighter who, in his old age, fought for the right to attend primary school so he could learn to read and write. This is the subject of a touching film, “First Grader”.
Advertising
We have amazing stories and characters and I am piqued when South African advertisers dig up Louis Gossett Jnr. to sell beer and Jamie Fox to sell brandy. The Allan Gray “Beautiful” ad is wonderful and I understand it is a universal theme, but why use Latin American characters when African characters could have been just as good, and certainly more relevant.
There are few winners at South Africa’s Advertising “Loerie” awards that are truly African. But we are surrounded by incredible stories, people and art. Our advertising industry is full of talented, intelligent individuals who only need to close the International Print Bible, Luerzers Archive, and the Cannes Lions website and look around them to find inspiration.
And if we believe “Africanism” won’t resonate with international advertising judges, we might be wrong. One example that proved this as far back as the late ‘90s was created by the Swedish directors, Traktor: They tapped into our own South African quirks with their ad for Miller Lite, “I can’t control my arm”. It cleaned up at the international awards shows.
Another winning example back then was Diesel’s “Le Look le Plus Cool” campaign. More recently, Sean Metelerkamp’s music video for Die Antwoord, “Zef Side”, was the only SA film to pick up a Yellow Pencil at the British D&AD in 2011. Who would have thought something so typically South African, so strange to foreigners, could resonate? But it does.
Lack of understanding
There is no question that we have a responsibility to marketers who focus on the buying public in SA with “Western” aspirations. But this does not rule out tapping into the idiosyncrasies that make that market uniquely South African. When we do try, sadly, we often resort to character clichés. This probably stems from a lack of understanding and appreciation of our own culture.
Our marketers rely heavily on research but I believe most research groups only touch the surface. Their findings are often skewed by subjects who tell the researchers what they think they want to hear or play up their own tastes and ideals, therefore not speaking for the broader market. Most critically, I also believe we underestimate the intelligence of the lower income markets and we exploit their sense of aspiration.
Sadly, our marketing and creative backbone is made up of people who hardly venture across the cultural and economic barriers, and they rely too heavily on the findings of research. This is especially true of the growing markets north of our border, such as Nigeria and Kenya where, at best, we play the part of tourists.
You took the time to get to know me
One of the few Afrocentric pieces awarded at the 2011 Loeries was by a very talented young student, Lubabalo Mtati. I was lucky enough to meet him before he had won anything. I didn’t know his work at all and I chatted with him for a while. He was such a humble guy and the most inspirational person I spoke to that evening.
In contacting Mtati to congratulate him a few days later, he said this very important thing to me:
“You took the time to get to know me before I had won anything, and I really appreciate that.”
Too often, as marketers and creatives, we wait for some justification of talent, some confirmation of a sure-fire winner, and most often we look to the West for inspiration; for a formula. All we need to do is look around us. After all, the West is already looking to Africa for inspiration.
Returning from trips beyond our South African border, too often people ask me:
“How was your trip to Africa?”
Yet here we are.









