Why bother?
Just when I thought I might be able to compartmentalize my feelings about politics away from my day-to-day existence, the sheer horror of what’s happening has forced me back into an obsessive Twitter habit, screaming into the void.
It’s not that I thought I was done talking about politics. As a good friend of mine pointed out after I wrote recently, I stated my intention to avoid politics, and also totally ended up talking about politics — all within a single essay. It’s who I am. I can’t help it, and what I’m working on recognizing is that there are plenty of occasions when I shouldn’t curb it. This moment feels like one of those.
But it’s hard, and I see that it’s hard for all of us. We have all been screaming into various voids for years now and things are only getting worse.
For a long time after the 2016 election, I looked back at a lot of my social media activity with disdain, and embarrassment. Why had I been so engaged? Why had I spent hours upon hours constructing my worldview in a way that attempted to account for the churning anger all around me, the rapidly expanding anger within me, and the depressing events that were unfolding on the national stage? Trump had won, so what had I gained by trying to pull together an understanding of reality that was anything better than the worst? I’d only lifted myself to a higher place to fall from.
There is an obvious futility in social media engagement. And I’ve tried to translate the energy that fuels me to type out angry missives online into an energy that propels me to call my representatives, to go out into the streets to protest, and to orient my career around these values and aspirations that I hold dear.
More often than not, none of it feels like enough. For the past two years I have been working on a single documentary about voter suppression in the US, and while I am grateful and lucky to be doing something I care about, I frequently feel despondent at how little I am accomplishing, how small the changes I can effect truly are. This job requires compromise, and humility. It requires me to hold my tongue more often than I’d prefer, and to accept things I don’t personally believe. The person I’ve become on Twitter since Trump’s inauguration doesn’t fit in a job like the one I have. On Twitter stridency is my default; at work I have to choose my moments to speak up, I have to decide what hills are worth dying on, and concede the arguments I can’t win.
And as with anything we pursue, I find myself looking around at the people who I see as making real change — people who are doing more with less — and I feel spoiled and phony. Like a privileged snowflake playing pretend.
I started using Twitter regularly right after Trump entered office, because the pace of the news seemed to necessitate a blistering newsfeed in order to keep up. It became an addiction, and I quickly started building out my list of follows to ensure that at any moment I could reload the page and see new infuriating hot-takes. My anger with myself for ever believing in American institutions or the American people’s capacity to do the right thing pushed me to follow angrier and angrier voices, people who I would have been bothered by only a year prior. I knew they had been more right than me before, their doomsday predictions more accurate than my rosier ones, and I wanted to prepare myself for the worst that was to come.
In the heat of the election, I saw the rising tide of cynicism and hopelessness as a dangerous trap for the country. I worried about my friends who hated Hillary, who hated the status quo, and would disengage rather than endure the pain of our genuinely broken system. Now I find myself frequently counted among them; I recognize that Trump’s America is not a new country, but the one I have lived in my whole life — finally exposed for the farce that it is. I had never lied to myself or others about America’s evil imperialist history, but I really had let Obama and his cohort convince me that we were turning a new page, and that there is a version of our country’s story that follows the powerless and the oppressed as they pushed back against the moneyed and privileged powers that be.
But of course, no true story is so simple, and there have always been two stories of America — the story of the country as it truly is, and the story of the country we aspire to be. Reconciling those stories is a constant battle, an impossible task that I spent years in history classes wrestling with.
Get Alex Ostroff’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Earlier this week, the Supreme Court upheld the Muslim ban that Trump had promised in his campaign and delivered on in his first week in office. That first week of his presidency felt insane; it seemed impossible things could keep up at the same pace with the same level of disarray, and we all worried that our capacity for protest and outrage was a limited resource. We had gone to the march, we had shown up at airports with signs, but how long could we last? And how much could we do, really?
After the ruling came down this week, I decided I’d go to a protest. I have friends who are dedicated activists, who I learn about events from and look to for guidance in doing this kind of work. These are the people who have not let up, who went to the airports that first week as Muslim immigrants were being turned away, and returned to those same airports this past week as young immigrant children were shuttled across the country in the dead of night.
It would be trite and inaccurate to describe the activists I’ve seen at events like this as tireless. By definition they are people who care deeply about what is happening, who care perhaps more than is good for their own sanity. So of course, they are tired. And yet they still show up. Why?
I like going to protests, but it’s a complicated “like.” In the same way I question the efficacy of everything else I am doing with my life, I can’t help but ask myself what I accomplish by showing up. I am woefully uneducated about activist theory, so I am speaking as a very ignorant bystander here. But I think the changes I imagine might be possible through activism will soon require the innocent bystanders to get their hands dirtier than they ever expected to, so it seems worthwhile to ask myself these questions.
Some of the reasons I like going to protests are selfish, but I’m beginning to think that’s ok. Again, we need more people to show up to these things, and all of us are hard-wired to act selfishly, even when we are doing unequivocally good things. Selfishness is a poor choice of words perhaps, because I don’t mean to even ascribe a negative value judgment here — sometimes what’s good for ourselves is good for others, and those are some of the best things we can do. Altruism is hard to find and not all it’s cracked up to be.
Oftentimes what is happening in this country makes me want to scream. It feels good to scream out loud, instead of online. It feels good to see a mass of other people, screaming in unison along with you. In New York especially, the crowd you find at a protest like this is fairly diverse, and a reminder of some of the reasons I choose to stay and fight for this country — why I bother to care. There is a signaling involved in just showing up, which can feel gross to realize but is a reality nonetheless. I don’t just want to care, I want other people to know I care, I want strangers to know that I care. I saw little kids at this protest, holding bullhorns and leading the rest of us in chants. I want to be a part of the memory they have of this moment, to be a part of what they think of as the good this country might one day have to offer. I want us to be good, even if we maybe never can be.
Those are some of the reasons I chose to go to that protest, and why I will choose to go to a Families Belong Together march this Saturday. And yet as I left the march, not because it had ended but because I had become tired and the weight of it all overwhelmed the hope, I did not feel like I had done anything of import. There is no measurable impact a single person’s presence can be tied to, no deliverable to send up to management to show my work. I had gone, it maybe had been more for me than for anyone else, I had left earlier than I could have, earlier than I should have, and now it was over. The bad things were still bad and the good things still far away and imagined.
Then, a few hours later, I saw something on my Twitter timeline I hadn’t seen in a very long time. People were getting excited, people who I had grown to know as nihilists and fatalists were letting themselves hope for change again.
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez had won the NY-14 primary, for a seat in the US House of Representatives. She had campaigned for Bernie and been inspired, and she decided to go up against the Democratic political machine in a race that almost no one predicted she would win. But she won. She won due to her innate talents and brilliance, and the grassroots network she was able to build and tap into. She won because she knew her district and knew what the people around her needed, and knew how to communicate to them in a way that was beautifully, plainly, moving. Watching any video of Ocasio-Cortez is enough to immediately understand how she has accomplished so much at the age of 28, and to understand that this is only an early chapter in what is going to be an incredible life.
I had been aware of Alexandria before she won, but I had protected myself from paying close attention. I let the words of the pundits and the cynics convince me that to believe in this long shot was foolish, and that I’d be better off continuing to build an increasingly dark vision of the world as it is, and not the possible world it could be. I wish I had paid more attention. I wish I had followed her more closely on this journey, even though the reasons I wish that are still largely self-centered. I miss how it feels to hope for the long shot and be rewarded, how it feels to let yourself dream and see those dreams come true. I wish I had cared enough to share videos, to campaign for her, to tell people I knew to pay attention to her because she was going to do big things. It wouldn’t have made a difference, but it would have felt better. It would have complicated my understanding of this moment. And it would have been a good thing to do even if she had lost her race. We aren’t going to win every fight, but we really do have to keep fighting.
The very next morning after Ocasio-Cortez won, Kennedy announced he was stepping down from the Supreme Court. In the blink of an eye, the horror of it all rushed back in, and the world seemed destined for worthlessness again, forever. But the sweetness of Alexandria’s victory still lingered, and it was enough for me to know that this is one more fight worth having, one more place we will be glad we did every single thing that we could do. Roe v. Wade is on the line, every person with a uterus could be in jeopardy, and admittedly very few avenues are left to try and stop it all from happening. But of course we have to try everything that we can. Because it will feel better to say that we did the absolute maximum amount that we could do, but also because maybe this is one of the times we can win. It probably isn’t. But who are we protecting by convincing ourselves it’s not worth it to try? And who are the people who need our protection the most?
I want to embrace the selfishness of doing more, to avoid the selfishness of giving up. Humans are egotistical — not because we are inherently awful, but because all any of us have ever known is how it is to be inside these bodies, and these brains.
We will get tired, we will want to give up, and many of us already have. That’s ok. But it’s a long life, history is even longer, and the moment we are in is not forever. When you’re sick, it feels impossible to remember what it felt like to be healthy. But we still take medicine. And sometimes even the placebos can be pretty fucking effective.









