That Box of Broken Dreams
Why you’re going to leave those angry “I’m leaving NYC, here’s why” articles alone
There have been a lot of angry pieces about New York City of late, hateful rants that disparage this city you have fought so hard to call your own. You’re tempted to respond, to tell your story, to call out these people trying to glamorize their failures, to expose them for the quitters and wimps that they are. But you won’t.
Instead, you’ll read this.
In L.A., there’s a phenomenon we call the box of broken dreams. This box, which will no doubt sound familiar to you — as to anyone who lives in a city where, every single day, people come by the thousands to make something of themselves — sits on any one of the glittering sidewalks of this bright and guilty city, full of things that make sense to none one but its owner, departed that morning or afternoon in a U-Haul too full of stuff, heartache, resentment and despair to accommodate its lonely dimensions.
Get A.V. Flox’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
When an Angeleno drives by one of these boxes, invariably a moment of silence descends in the car as they reflect on their own trajectory. No matter how broken-down the car, how desperate their own situation, they count their blessings because they’re still there, sitting in a tight grid of smog knowing they have one more day than the person who just departed.
We don’t see those who leave as quitters, as weak, as less than ourselves because they are ourselves. It takes talent and work to succeed but it takes access and luck, too — the right idea at the right time, the right person at the right party, the right amount of trust in the right connection, and so on and on and on. And so we sit there, breathing that bittersweet air that’s more likely to kill us than any number of calamities we worry about while shopping for organic and gluten-free groceries at Whole Foods, grateful that we’ll see one more sunset, feel one more earthquake, read of one more fire blazing down the Malibu corridors, and — if we’re really lucky — once more experience the coming of the Santa Ana blowing tattered copies of the LA Weekly across one more choked boulevard, making our skin crawl and reminding us, as Raymond Chandler once wrote, that on nights like those, anything can happen.
We know that feeling — that nervous, hopeful feeling — that anything can happen. We’ve seen it. It’s why we’re still here. Dreams are fragile things but those boxes remind us that ours, no matter how beat down by choice and circumstance, are still there, with us, at least for now.
Sometimes we’ll take a day in Venice and get served dinner by someone that’s forty, even fifty, or go to a post office and exchange a joke with a postal worker who remembers that in the seventies it snowed downtown and we’ll marvel at how unwilling they are to give up on this place even long after the dreams give way to the realities of life. We know these are the exceptions, not the rule — and we know that because we, too, came like outsiders with nothing but the clothes on our backs and pockets full of hope and dreams, hearts full of youth and spines full of vigor.
Those boxes are a reminder that this city that feasts on that youth and those dreams still has a plan for us. So we reflect for a moment in our cars, separated from one another, competitors and brothers-in-arms all at once, and we feel a little grateful.
Those who leave find their own ways to deal with their grief — some of them in harsh tones reserved for the city that cast them out and the people who remain. But that’s how they heal. The city moves on and every day, more people arrive to make something of themselves, not knowing that fortune has its own plans no matter how determined and willing they are.
We let those whose dreams have met their shattering deaths go — to nurse their wounds, to forge new ones in another place.
And we drive on.








