Sitemap

Are music digital downloads really dead?

2 min readOct 29, 2014

The world seems to be preparing for the demise of the music album. “All hail streaming!” can be heard with declarations that streaming is the future of music.

First of all, we need to understand how music royalties work to generate money for artistes and labels. There are basically 3 types of royalties when it comes to downloads and streaming— sound recording royalties, mechanical royalties, and performance royalties.

Get BenLooi’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

When a download is sold, royalties from that sale comes in the form of sound recording royalties and mechanical royalties. Usually the performer or the label gets the sound recording royalties, while the songwriters and composers get the mechanical royalties. Industry rates are roughly 90%/10% for sound recording/mechanical split.

When music is streamed or played live, it gets performance royalties, which goes to the songwriters/composers. Collection agencies will ask for a lump sum license annually, or like streaming services, pay a fraction of a cent for each stream. The money comes from the business or platform’s other revenue streams, not directly from the sale of music. Hence, radio stations have to sell advertisements, bars have to sell beer and food, and platforms have to sell subscription services and ads to pay for performance royalties.

If streaming is the future of music, then the future is bleak. Music will be an operating cost for such businesses, and artistes and musicians will be poorly paid.

The download model is the sustainable way for musicians to make a living, so it cannot die. What we need to do is to tweak the model and make consumers WANT to download instead of stream. Instead of making it cheap, why not make it profitable for consumers by sharing revenue with them? Give consumers a percentage from each sale that they recommend, but first, they have to buy a copy of the music before they qualify for such a reward. In fact, give them another percentage from subsequent sales to encourage them to buy and help share. Musicians and artistes earn much more in terms of sound recording and mechanical royalties than performance royalties.

I would advise labels and musicians to strategize — use streaming as a marketing means to increase your probability to get discovered, but build your business and revenue streams from digital downloads, merchandise, and concerts. There are only 2 ways to make money in the world- sell time, or sell a product. Streaming is neither — it is a cost.