‘The Fault…’ was okay
Was asked to write this review late last year for my newspaper but it never did get published. With the whole world’s appreciation of John Green’s book (now a movie) I’m not complaining…
(I didn't really enjoy TFIOS. It was okay, but its characters and their quirks felt very contrived to me. And highly passive angsty. Still, I was a big fan of John Green’s history series on YouTube and I was determined to not be unwarrantedly harsh. So I wrote this review.)
Hazel Grace Lancaster says it herself — “…it’s not a cancer book, because cancer books suck.” Except that here, Hazel, the protagonist of John Green’s The Fault in our Stars, is talking about her favourite novel ‘An Imperial Affliction’.
In a number of ways, you get the feeling that the fictitious AIA is everything author Green wants TFIOS to be — quirky, profound, humorous and tragic — and, in many ways, is successful.
First released in 2012, TFIOS became such a rage among young adults, its target audience, that there’s even a movie based on it coming out this year. The genre of young adult fiction is a tricky one to venture into because of its tendency to be branded frivolous or melodramatic, but barring some rawness, TFIOS has most of the makings of good reading material for its demographic.
Get breadfruit’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
It is the unlikely love story of sixteen-year-old Hazel, a thyroid cancer patient, and Augustus Waters, a seventeen-year-old who has lost a leg to osteosarcoma, a form of bone cancer. They meet at a cancer support group and hit it off almost instantly. The quietly dry-witted and intelligent Hazel is surprised to find a lot in common with seventeen-year-old Gus, who with his more obvious good looks, flamboyant charm and videogame addiction seems rather different from her at first.
The plot mostly revolves around the pair’s efforts to reach out to Peter van Houten, the reclusive author of An Imperial Affliction, to find out what really happens to the characters of his intriguingly-ending novel. In their pursuit, Hazel and Gus end up living life like they never imagined they would be able to. They also end up falling in love.
What stands out the most in TFIOS is Green’s deliberate attempt to not make the cancer a cause for sympathy. Hazel and Gus have very casual attitudes about their mortality. For example, you may think it a tad unnatural for a teenager, who was in the throes of basketball stardom when cancer struck to be so mature, to have attained so much closure from his amputation, so as to be able to refer to his prosthetic leg as ‘old Prosty’.
Novels for young adults too often take advantage of the fact that teenagers generally like feeling sorry for themselves. TFIOS stands in stark contrast. Its protagonists definitely have more reason to indulge in self-pity than, say, Bella from Twilight, who loses the will to live because she can never be with her vampire boyfriend, but Hazel and Gus almost never do. This could be one of the reasons TFIOS is such a hit with its readers, most of whom have been fed with a disproportionate supply of angst.
John Green succeeds in creating a pair of role models, even if they occasionally seem a bit too ‘zen’ to be true. His language is as simple as his story is, his characters endearing even if some seem unintentionally caricatural (Hazel’s showy friend Kaitlin who speaks with an inexplicable British accent and the eccentric and verbose Peter van Houten), and most of the time he does a fairly decent job of a thirty-something man writing from the point of view of a sixteen-year-old girl.
The Fault in our Stars may not be a literary masterpiece, but it definitely belongs to that rare breed of young adult novels that will not make you cringe.






