Cannibalising your business
Because there’s fun to be had
I’ve been dwelling on an article I read about the demise of iconic camera and analog film company Kodak, which filed for bankruptcy in 2012. In 1975, Kodak engineer Steve Sasson created the world’s first digital camera, yet the company waited until 1995 to introduce it to market.
Although they had the first mover advantage, their heavy involvement with film and analog photography meant digital would cannibalise their own business.
Missing the first opportunity
As I don’t need to tell you, others quickly filled the niche, the opportunity passed, and king Kodak was sliding towards bankruptcy, its primary asset being the many patents and intellectual property which powers the digital photography leaders of today.
Not only did they misunderstand the new ways people were using photography, but they hesitated to hasten the demise of their core business. That’s understandable. Yet they were still in the digital market, launching the EasyShare line of point-and-shoot cameras in 2001, and they weren’t taking advantage of the resurrection of analog. (The cult following of Man Men’s The Carousel scene, featuring Kodak’s slide projector, would have been a great launch pad for a new ad campaign and business focus).
Kodak repeatedly missed opportunities because they were scared of cannibalising their business — they weren’t bold in changing the focus on their core business, they weren’t committed to the new digital revolution, and their lack of clarity was pivotal to their downfall.
The times they are a changin’
Sometimes the writing is on the wall. Technology is changing the way we interact, cook, play with our children, socialise, find information, jobs and perform these jobs. Give people what they want — and how they want it too.
When business is ailing, tough decisions need to be made, including whether you’re still enthusiastic about what you’re doing. After all, changing direction requires far more than enthusiasm — we need temerity, single-mindedness, and vision.
The counter-revolutionaries
If you are absolutely certain that doing things differently from dominant trends is best, then you’ll need to be a pro at explaining why to your clients — not in terms of what everybody else isn’t doing well, but how what you do differently is exactly what they need.
And, crucially, you need to find more clients who agree with you.
As our society moves every faster and shallower, there are more counter-revolutionaries — evidenced in the rise of ‘slow food’, homeschooling, homesteading, and the revival of slow hobbies such as crafting, analog photography, and single-speed bicycling.
You can be a counter-revolutionary and go against the trend, but you need to commit. Don’t hesitate and oscillate like Kodak did, making moves but, ultimately, standing still. Recognise when it’s time to pack up shop or change direction, then be clear on what you offer, and don’t be afraid to show your true self, in all its eccentricities and idiosyncrasies.
Are you ready to teach?
The common route to business cannibalism is becoming the teacher or trainer. It’s a slippery slope because it normally starts fairly innocuously — someone admires what you’ve done and asks you to teach them. You’re flattered. You’ve mastered something and you think there’s no harm in passing it on.
Get Brook McCarthy’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
And there’s no harm, really, if you want to be a teacher. But — and you knew this was coming — do you really want to be a teacher? Would you be a good one? Are you patient, kind, open-minded and flexible in approach? Can you explain it simply? Can you help your grandmother do it?
Building the pyramid
The next step after teaching, for the tenacious entrepreneur, is to train other teachers. Hey presto! You have a franchise. Or a pyramid. Or a license. You have students, followers, minions. You are officially building your empire.
Hats off. Take a holiday.
Welcoming the rip-off merchants
The other keen thing that happens to teachers is they attract rip-off merchants. Many poor lazy sods follow anyone who looks talented and charismatic — who looks like they’re going places.
For the cost of one of your (most reasonably-priced) courses, you’ve effectively handed over all your IP. Engage an editor at $45 an hour and, lo! Original material, sleekly repositioned and ready to go.
That’s the risk inherent in being public.
Many years ago, I was privvy to a loud altercation at a Saigon bar at four in the morning. It’s drama and colourful language provoked me to open my notepad and jot down choice phrases, seeing as how I fancied myself as a Jacqueline Kerouac at the time. The fight fizzled out. One guy left and the other joined me, seeking moral support.
Upon seeing my faithfully rendered notes, he became upset. “It didn’t go like that! I said it differently!”
Alas. The nature of sharing space with other humans means that, at any time, some earnest soul could be stealing snippets of your life and times, while you blithely carry on.
What’s a poor man to do?
So you’ve got a few options — carry on, zealously guarding your processes, procedures, products and profile. Fearfully marching into the night, unaware and out of time.
You can join the growing ranks of counter-revolutionaries, colloquially known as “hipsters”. Your olde worlde approach becomes your value and point-of-difference. You make a good and proper argument why going against the tide makes the most sense.
You can build your empire — training trainers, franchising, licensing and feathering your nest with more teachers and trainers.
You can recognise that you will be ripped off. Others will take your best ideas and implement them. They may be better connected, with more funding and support. They could be inspired to put a different spin on your gem. They could (and will) hang out with your tribe, so lovingly and slowly cultivated, and pick them off, one at a time.
And what can you do? Bury your head in the sand? Or keep innovating?
The biggest risk in business
The biggest risk is not being ripped off. It’s not building an empty empire where your minions deliver a half-rate version of the first-rate experience of you. It’s not the bottom feeders picking off the most impressionable and vulnerable of your tribe.
The biggest risk in business is staying still. The biggest risk is letting the fear-mongering get to you. The biggest risk is to fiercely hold onto every good idea you have lest it fizzle away, without realising that good ideas need all the oxygen they can get, and more. And that good ideas are breed from good ideas.






