Dugong
The animal I chose was the Dugong, which is a marine mammal that lives in the warm coastal waters of the Indian and west Pacific Oceans. I did some preliminary research on their habits, history, and reason for being endangered, and found that they behave pretty similar to manatees in that they are docile and friendly. While Dugong are not technically endangered as a species, their populations in the Indian coast, my assigned habitat, are very much endangered, with only a scant 250 individuals left. Dugong have been hunted for a millennia, but have only faced dangers of extinction because of commercial hunting by European traders, and more recently fishing accidents and habitat destruction.
Keeping this background knowledge in mind, I started delving into the physical attributes of the Dugong:
I didn’t focus too much on getting the exact form and anatomy of the Dugong correct, as I felt that their forms are generally pretty forgiving, and I will have to simplify them in the later stages of this project anyways. I focused instead on getting the key characteristics down, such as their dolphin-like tail and U-shaped mouth.
1/23 update:
Here are the three compositions I made:
I knew that I wanted to play with more exaggerated and unrealistic colors, since combining extremely realistic and extremely stylized aspects of a piece will seem very jarring. I do think that the green I chose for the initial two compositions might be too unrealistic, and read more as a pond than the ocean. I like the placement of the text in the first one the most, since it uses the margins and natural starting point of the text very well. I do like the composition in the last one the most, but I think that I still need to work on text placement since it seems off-balance right now. I did add in a fishing net which alludes to the reason that Dugongs are dying out in many parts of the world, but I’m not sure if that comes across very clearly. I thought about adding a boat in the middle piece, but I’m not sure where exactly it would make sense.
After Tuesday’s critique, I had a pretty good idea of where I wanted to go next. I think the main thing everyone pointed out was that the ripples in the water didn’t come across very clearly so it seemed more like a feature than a detail in the background. I definitely need to revisit some reference images and focus on getting the detail to look correct, since it’s one of the only assets I have that is giving information for the background. Another thing I need to address is the net, which Daphne mentioned looked like was in motion, and very distracting. This wasn’t what I intended, since I wanted the net to just lay on top of the water and suggest possible danger, but not pose an active threat to the Dugong. I think that would be the most effective way of showing their endangerment, though I am still open to showing a boat for the middle composition where the viewer is looking up at the Dugong.
Here are my revised compositions:
Overall, for every composition I rounded out the edges of the form of the Dugong to give it a more organic appearance. I adjusted the ripples to be very light and utilize a pattern, to blend it further into the background. I adjusted the placement of the text so that it doesn’t take up an incredible amount of space, while also being one fo the first things the viewer sees.
I spent the most time on the first one, since I was really messing around with the assets to get something I liked.
Get Caleb Sun’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Here’s a quick overview of the significant versions:
I took Helen’s suggestion of making the Dugong breach the water to add depth and movement, and I used the highlight as an opportunity to define the Dugong’s blowholes. I also messed around with the placement of the sea foam so that it read less as a border attached to the net and more as something that has gathered there. I also messed around with the placement of the shadows, so that the depth reads more clearly. Finally, I played with color. All three of my revised compositions use a more dulled-out color scheme, since I found that the initial colors I chose printed extremely saturated. I had to go back and adjust them so that they read as saturated on paper, but not overwhelmingly so.
I played around a little with colors too, and got this color scheme that I thought was cute though I don’t think I’ll end up using it because it reads as very cold, whereas Dugongs are found in very warm tropical waters.
Regardless, it was fun to mess around with colors and see what I could come up with.
Further versions and reflection:
My final version went through a lot of small iterative adjustments that kind of veered on the side of arbitrary, but I didn’t change too much from the version seen above. Here is my final:
And the final text:
Cousins of the manatee and inhabitants of the warm waters of the Indian Ocean, the Dugong have captured the imaginations of peoples in the area for millennia. With their dolphin-like tails and playful personality, these sea-grass grazers are thought to be the original inspiration to the mermaids of legend. Once hunted for their meat and blubber, threatened Dugong populations are now protected in many parts of the world. Still, their slim numbers are dwindling due to the loss of their habitats, and accidents with fishing nets.
I wanted to capture the history and legend of these animals, since that’s something that really captivated me when I first started doing research. I had never heard of Dugong before, but I learned that they are extremely significant to South Asian, Middle Eastern, and West African cultures. I felt that glossing over their history would be a disservice, and even with my already large paragraph I found myself wanting to cram more words in. I do think I could’ve condensed the text a little more, but I’m overall happy with where it ended up.
I adjusted quite a bit from the previous version, but the overall composition didn’t change much. I think the most significant change I made was to the net. Something that people mentioned a lot was that the net seemed like it was in motion, even after the adjustment I made from the first to the second iteration. I went back and did some research on the kinds of nets that Dugong run into, and found that they’re more often than not floating nets that are held up to the surface of the water with white or orange buoys. I felt that capturing that kind of net would be much more accurate and negate the use of sea-foam to break up the ocean, which people mentioned felt very distracting. I really struggled getting from the point I was last check-in and the final, since I wanted to capture a very specific kind of net, and it had to match both the general style of the rest of the poster, as well as being in the same perspective as the Dugong.
I figured that messing around with blend modes would help a lot with maintaining the geometry of the net, so the first picture above was my first attempt. I felt that it did capture the general structure, but was very clunky to work with and hard for viewers to understand. I opted for a much more simplified shape, which only uses vertical lines. I felt that this would make the form read much better, while also conveying the same concept and maintaining the simple style I chose. From there, I used clipping masks to create a subtle gradient, conveying the net being deeper in the water:
And finally, I offset the shadow to suggest the presence of distance between where the net hits the ocean floor and where the shadow is cast:
Another subtle change I made was to the shadows, which Helen pointed out would be distorted in the water. I just used a simple roughen effect to achieve that. I also returned to the base form of the Dugong, adjusting subtle things to convey their shape better.
Another more significant thing I changed was the text. I think that before, my text felt very disconnected, with the title being extremely large. Q’s last comments to me were mostly focused on how to balance the text in the composition better, and Daphne had warned me about setting all the text against the right-side. I made a few small adjustments there, and feel that the final text fits much more naturally with the rest of the composition.
Overall, I’m pretty happy with how this project turned out. I learned a lot about Illustrator, and it was fun to incorporate what I learned in Vis and Studio last semester with a very graphic-design-ey project that was like the stuff I used to do in high school. I think this project challenged me in ways I wasn’t initially anticipating, but I felt that I slowly chipped away at it and ended up with something I’m proud of.








