Sitemap
Calum Watson

Calum Watson

Shortbread Economics — A Parody on Scottish Independence

4 min readSep 9, 2014

--

CRUMBLING ECONOMY

One evening a rotund Scottish politician, having just finished his dinner of haggis and shortbread washed down with Irn Bru, turned to his his wife and says ‘Gosh, dear, these Scottish products are excellent. Wouldn’t it be nice if one day they could be ours and ours alone?’ His wife looked at him and mumbled ‘Well yes, but the fact is – ‘ ‘Ahh my dear, facts mean nothing here. The people who buy shortbread are the Scots and the tourists – lots of them, in fact – my, you cross the border and nobody has these things at all. They don’t value us past Hadrian’s Wall like they should. I’ve had enough of such things!’

The next day, this politician, called Mr Salmond, started telling people of his plans for his shortbread economy. ‘Scotland has more than enough shortbread to survive on its own without the help of the English, who despise it, along with Irn Bru and Haggis, which I have now capitalised to make it seem more important!’ His adviser, a wise man, turned to him and remarked, ‘But Mr Salmond, shortbread is available in England. Gosh, they love it in fact. So they help you there. There’s even Irn Bru in London, a place that helps you a great deal in financial support. It’s full of wealth there. Scotland may need English support with things like these, you know.’

But Mr Salmond was not listening any more. ‘I do not need help from a bigger, more proseperous neighbour. We do not need their support in such economic matters. I have a degree in Economics from St Andrews – ‘ ‘Yes, Mr Salmond, but you get a 2:2 and everyone knows St Andrews is a rotten University anyway supported only by English money.’ ‘Nonsense! We will keep everything we want to keep, and discard what we do not want. That shall be the basis for my shortbread economy.’

Get Calum Watson’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Naturally, the English people laughed at such an idea. ‘You’ll never survive on your own – what if you run out of Irn Bru for instance? What will you do then?’ Mr Salmond thought for a minute. ‘Simple – every glass bottle of Irn Bru contributes an extra 30p when you take it back to the shop. If there is a shortage, all these 30ps will be rounded up and used by the government to fund important things.’ There was uproar. ‘You won’t have pence if you’re independent , you can’t use the pound!’ ‘Ahh, but it’s ours!’ ‘Nope.’ ‘Mmm, we’ll track our McShillings to the pound – Zimbabwe, said a Londoner – very well, we’ll join the Euro – Greece, said another – fine then, we’ll make our own currency – that won’t work either. Ahh, well… whatever we do, you’ll still help us out if it goes wrong.’ Amidst the laughter, Mr Salmond convinced himself the pound could still be his.

He began his campaigning on such exotic political measures. He produced tables that were shot down silently by Nobel prize winners, and continued to trick the Scots with his cunning verbal repertoire of romantic, shortbread tin rhetoric. The currency would be what he wanted, backed up by the Ginger Bottle as Lender of Last Resort if times were hard. It soon dawned on the Prime Minister that this was in fact a serious campaign that was becoming more popular by the day. ‘Alex, you can still have all these things and be British too. Here, we’ll give you more powers now. That’s what you want, isn’t it?’ Mr Salmond put the phone down. His nation would show him the way.

The night of the election proved to be victorious for Mr Salmond. He celebrated long into the night, overjoyed to have had his wish come true. The following morning, however, he awoke to disaster. There was an outbreak of incurable disease amongst sheep, rendering haggis extremely dangerous. ‘I must save us by producing extra shortbread!’ he concluded. No sooner had he thought this than his phone rang: ‘Mr Salmond, there has been extensive damage to the shortbread factories caused by No Voters! We’ll need to produce more haggis to survive.’ ‘But the sheep are all diseased!’ He considered his options. ‘Ah! To the Ginger Bottles!’ In the end, however, despite having rounded up as many 30ps as he could, he realised he did not have enough to fight the disease, the fires or to build new factories. Desperate, he phoned David Cameron. He received no answer. It was only when he decided to drive across the border to London that he had to stop at a giant wall just on the other side of Scotland. There was a huge sign on the front of the wall. Aghast, he read it slowly and carefully and sank to his knees:

“United, or alone – not both.”



--

--