Sitemap

Story #4

3 min readSep 11, 2015

--

Auteur vs. Metteur-en-scene, Stanley Kubrick vs. Michael Bay.

Kubrick is obviously an auteur, inspired by the chess games that he played as a child, all of his movies are well-thought out and are open to multiple interpretations. His mis-en-scene is often extremely detailed and spectacular, he uses a lot of symbolism as well. Kubrick was also fascinated by lighting, he used lighting everywhere (even in places that did not make sense). His movies also often had sexual themes, Clockwork Orange, Lolita, 2001 (phallic symbols anyone?)…

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Everything in 2001 Space Odyssey was very symmetrical and intricately detailed, invoking a suspension of reality.

The lighting also creates an illusion of infinite space, as seen in the above picture.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
The Shining by Kubrick.

Unlike, Kubrick, Michael Bay is a metteur-en-scene. His transformers movies, though enjoyable, are merely monuments to violence. From the 1st movie to the 3rd, the amount of violence greatly increased, as well as the number of explosions (that's a given), the auto-bots themselves also became much more grotesque and surly. As by the third movie they all have leaks, and slobber, and ooze blood-like liquids whenever they get hurt. Even Optimus Prime, the great leader of the Autobots shouts “We will kill them all” in the most recent film — my childhood is ruined.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Isn’t that more of a Decepticon sort of thing…

Another vulgar thing in Bay’s films is his objectification of women… okay, we get it. Megan Fox is hot — yay! The little bit of plot that can actually be interpreted from the films is half, robots are fighting other robots because expansionism (is this supposed to be some political commentary ?— idk), and look at this girl’s butt as she suggestively leans over a car. There is nothing in depth to his films, there are no themes. The only constants are over-sexualization and violence, but even those are done well or consistently. He even got rid of Fox because she ‘wasn’t sexy enough’… yeah… okay…

Really, Bay? At least just say that Megan is a rude and mean person and that's why you got rid of her, because both these women are very ‘sexy’.

Also, unlike Kubrick, Bay really does not have any aesthetic or deeper meaning to his films. Bay lacks that extra-level that takes a director from okay to auteur, whether he could get there by improving his creativity, I’m not sure… but he could definitely improve overall by just having a darn plot!

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Is this Tree of Life? Dinosaur robots, really?

Some food for though: Would Jackie Chan be considered an Auteur or a Metteur en scene?

Get Caitlyn Bishop’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

I think that Jackie Chan’s ability to take any role (even those in semi-serious action films) and make them comedic with over-dramatic facial expressions, good acting, and awesome one-liners really demonstrates his ability to make films his own. His comedy is also a theme in his acting, and his drama is an aesthetic… so technically couldn’t he be an auteur?

--

--