Widening the gap
The other day I went to the gym with a friend, and afterwards we stopped by the Alessi store downtown. The apex of Italian craftsmanship, it was exactly as we expected: immaculate teapots and stainless steel utensils arranged on tiered shelves, all polished to a silvery luster.
Get Peter Liu’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
But something felt amiss. To me, there are two distinct kinds of products: first there are the mundane workhorses that we use daily, but disdain for their plainness or lack of imagination. And then there are the “designer” pieces: more refined, expensive, but not for actual use.
Even though Alessi (putatively) designs for function, something told me that they weren’t meant to be used. Spotlights aimed precisely to show off the reflective surfaces, one per cubbyhole. I was afraid to touch them, for fear of marring the mirror finish with my vulgar hands. The objects were presented in an… otherworldly aura that discouraged you from sullying the polished perfection with the scuffles of everyday life. I felt that instead bringing design to the “real world,” Alessi made it feel more distant for the rest of us.
Therein lies the designer’s conceit, I think. Instead of using design to serve a greater good, these products reverse the roles and force the tangible world to fetishize a virtual, idealized one. And without helping us make peace with the fact, they subtly condescend that our lives can never be as clean, perfect, or sleek.





