Why Is It Hard To Debate Creationists?
Since the controversial acceptance by noted Science Guy Bill Nye of noted moron Ken Ham’s invitation to debate the merits of evolution in a forum known for saddled dinosaurs, the sane have been tormented by the resurgence of an old question: why is it so hard to win an argument when you’re right?
In the case of creationism, the problem is that Darwin’s defenders insist on letting the faithful frame the debate as one between creationism and evolution. That’s not what it is.
The debate played out between Nye and Ham wasn’t one between competing theories; it was between reason and devotion.
Nye, representing the alarmingly small portion of Americans who generally weigh ideas on their merits, failed to realize that. Ham, representing the alarmingly significant portion of Americans who let Jesus take the wheel of their critical thinking process, had no intention of defending the “science” of young Earth creationism or even intelligent design (both of which I refuse to dignify by capitalizing them).
Ham just did what he does best: finding different ways to articulate the phrase “’Cause God says so” until the balance was tipped even further in Evangelism’s favor by triggering the worldwide wave of aneurysms that deprive the Earth of a few more of its rational people whenever this sort of thing happens.
In HBO’s recent documentary Questioning Darwin (also featuring Ham), one creationist says the only thing anyone ever needs to know about evolution’s deniers:
“If somewhere in the Bible I were to find a passage that says two plus two equals five, I wouldn’t question what I’m reading in the Bible. I would believe it—accept it as true and then do my best to work it out and to understand it.”
That quote is the kind of thing evolution’s defenders can point to when they argue the futility of even engaging creationists. Many have criticized Nye for doing just that: validating creationism by condescending to address it.
Get Conor O'Grady’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
The quote’s true value, however is in demonstrating that while creationism can’t actually be argued against, senselessness can — and should be.
Engagement is critical if we’re to have any hope of stemming the ark-worthy tide of stupid that even now floods the halls of power with creationist, climate-change-denying, vaccine-refusing idiocy that’s rooted less in the Good Book and more in a general disdain for logic.
While arguing against creationism is futile, arguing against creationists is not. Instead of trying to compare the apples and imaginary oranges of evolution and creationism, respectively, men like Bill Nye and anyone else willing to step up and defend reason need to do just that: defend reason, not evolution.
For example, when confronted with samples of the myriad overwhelming evidence in favor of evolution, Ham retreated again and again to the same argument- that since no human witnessed the beginning of the world, no man can claim to know anything about it. Therefore, the word of God is the only thing we can trust.
Fair enough, if you’re a Biblical literalist. After the 7th or 8th time Ham swatted Nye’s volleys away with that, the Science Guy could and should have gone to the heart of the matter: the notion that no free-thinking person is obliged to accept the Bible as the word of God, or accept anything whatsoever that claims divine self-evidence.
That idea — that no claim can be thought of as objective that rests on supernatural or religious dogma — is at the heart of all modern reason. It drove the Enlightenment and the American Revolution that so many social conservatives fetishize. It’s the first thing mentioned in the Bill of Rights. It’s the notion that forced the Christian right to retreat to the thin veil of “intelligent design” pseudo-science in its attack on public school science curricula, once it was clear that they couldn’t overtly force the Almighty into secular education.
No need for transitional species, no need for the fossil record or tree rings or sediment layers, no need for the remnants of whale legs or the uselessness of the male nipple. It’s all moot once we suggest that no one can be reasonably expected to accept anyone else’s mythology, however much we respect anyone’s right to their mythology.
As the creators of Questioning Darwin did, defenders of science need only to let the creationists do the talking and let the cold light of day do the rest. The premise of young Earth creationism will quickly disprove itself in the mind of anyone who would look at the hypothetical “2+2=5" passage of (presumably) Numbers and cry bullshit without fear of being smote, or whatever God does in that situation.
It won’t matter what Ham’s followers think of that; they’ve settled on “5.” We can’t help those who insist on pushing on the door that opens outward because they’ve mistaken the janitor for the omnipotent Creator of All Things, and mistaken the “PUSH” sign for His infallible word.
But the rest of America, the majority of casual believers who are theistic but not immune to common sense, won’t be taken in by the greatest lie of our times, even greater than the lie of brontosaurus rides: that creationism and evolution are two equally valid approaches to an unanswerable question.






