The Internet as a Public Sphere
Why the web should be central to the life of academics, artists, writers, and intellectuals—despite the lolcatz.
Let me say first that I have nothing personal against lolcats, memes, Reddit trolls, or any of the internet’s usual poster-children. I’ve spent many a lonely night on Tumblr, spit out coffee at one or two deft GIF uses, and, like all of us, I am psychologically addicted to Facebook (and perhaps Twitter). I’m certain that one, if not a few, of my college grades have suffered for it.
However, despite recent social science research about the perils of internet use, social networks have the potential to become powerful tools in academia, giving the life of the mind some much-needed lifeblood, as long as we build the right ones. (User-driven sites like Medium, Thought Catalog, and The Coeus House are a good start).
The Ugly
In the last few years, social science research has begun to confirm the fears of distracted college students and young professionals alike: there is copious evidence that using social networking sites—particularly the blue giant, Facebook—frequently, is not psychologically healthy, and may cause depression. Even worse, childhood and adult obesity also correlate strongly with internet use, for the simple reason that effortless, sedentary social contact is easier than getting up and going somewhere. The internet causes anxiety and social isolation. It makes us envious and scornful, more accustomed to—and tacitly approving of—gut reactions. As any political-status-commenter knows, it makes us ruder.
Some, like Shimi Cohen, think that the internet also permanently damages the potential for meaning and authenticity in our world. In a viral animated video, Cohen argues that the internet, assisted by Western consumerism, careerism, and self-aggrandizement, has replaced the importance of community with the importance of the individual. Sociological research shows that humans cannot form intimate relationships with more than 150 people, he says—yet in using social networking sites, “we are collecting friends like stamps, not distinguishing quantity or quality, and converting the deep meaning of friendship to exchanging photos and chat conversations.”
Overuse of the internet and social networks can be dangerous. Nevertheless, academia and broader educational institutions have embraced the internet as an essential part of secondary, post-secondary, and primary education, for obvious reasons.
Get joegruenbaum’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
However, these high-schools and colleges, run by administrators from a generation still slowly adjusting to Instagram, Twitter, and Pinterest, are more weary of integrating social networks into the academic equation—but should they be?
The Bad
Part of the reason for the taboo against using social networking as a tool on campuses across the country comes from a bastion of print-and-paper purists, with whom I sometimes identify. The argument, supported by neurological research, is that writing by hand, reading from dusty, old volumes in a massive library, having the physical, visceral form of printed pages with you is not only purer and more virtuous, an irreplaceable academic experience, but better for learning. Conversation and debate, too, is better done face-to-face, they argue; it engages the mind, and helps public speaking.
Another attack on the internet’s place in academia is to question the efficacy of the so called “democracy of the internet” or “wisdom of the crowds.” Most of what is written on blogs, Facebook debates, and personal websites, the argument goes, is uninformed drivel, useless for academic purposes or legitimate intellectual inquiry. We have peer review for a reason, and the speed at which a Twitter spat or Facebook debate occurs decreases the likelihood of the participants thinking critically, or conducting even a minimum amount of research.
These arguments, however, miss some of what is happening already at the edges of the fourth estate and the academic realm. Many academics now have blogs, and use them to give informed, timely commentary on developments in their field and show how their research is relevant to culture. International Relations scholar Dan Drezner, for example, has become a Twitter mini-celebrity as a result of his blog, hosted by Foreign Policy. The Washington Post recently picked up The Monkey Cage, an award winning political science group blog. Social networking, though, is not quite there yet.
The Good
Blogs may be proliferating, but what has to happen for social networks to become a central feature of secondary and post-secondary education? Simply put, someone has to build a social network that is up to the task.An interdisciplinary intellectual social network—built on stimulating collaboration and debate—would assuage the needs of college students disenfranchised by careerism and consumerism, provide a forum for academics around the world, and introduce high school students to the life of the mind.
The doubters will reiterate the above concerns. And though I agree with the print-and-paper-purists in their love of the physical form of books, conducting intellectual debate online does not prevent face-to-face contact, nor does it prevent the use of print resources. In fact, it can encourage both. An intellectual social network would provide resources to help “the democracy of the internet” become better informed, including face-to-face meetings in coffee-shops and homes.
Most of history’s greatest thinkers, artists, writers, and musicians innovated most profoundly when surrounded by an interdisciplinary community of challenging colleagues—think of Paris of the 20's, Vienna of the 1890's, even the writer’s Brooklyn of today. Is it too much to ask that social networking bring millions of curious souls together in the same way?








