“Mother Wishes Son Had Been Killed”
One of the few mug shots I own that isn’t from New Castle, Pennsylvania.
Norman Garfield, Hung at Woodstock, June 1921, For murder of Ben Johnson
Ben Johnson was the owner of a restaurant in a small town in Ontario; Norman Garfield was a stick-up man who’d spent most of his life in reformatory and prison. They both died as a result of their meeting one night in January, 1921.
The full story of Garfield’s crime, capture, trial, escape and execution is in the clippings below. There’s a lot of reading, but there are some interesting and colourful details in there, if you like that sort of thing.
BANDITS AT WOODSTOCK
Woodstock, Ont, Jan 21 — Bandits who went into the restaurant of Ben Johnston shortly after midnight shot the proprietor through the head and then made a quick get-away without securing a cent for their trouble. Johnston will recover.
Lethbridge Herald, January 21, 1921
Is Victim of Hold-Up Men
Woodstock Restaurant Man Dead — Brothers Arrested at London
Woodstock, Ont, Jan 22 — Ben Johnston, the restaurant keeper, who was shot by holdup men late Thursday night, died here last night.
Two Arrests Made
Shortly before midnight last night detectives arrested Norman Garfield, aged 24, and his brother, Benton, aged 20, of Toronto, as suspects in the murder at Woodstock Thursday night, of Ben Johnston, shot by holdup men in his restaurant.
Lethbridge Herald, January 22, 1921
CLAIM TO IDENTIFY TWO GARFIELDS AS WOODSTOCK BANDITS
London, Ont, Jan 23 — Norman Garfield, aged 24, and Denton Garfield, his brother, aged 20, both of Toronto, arrested here at 54 Dundas street in a raid at 11 o’clock Friday night on suspicion of being implicated in recent robberies, have been charged with the murder of Ben Johnston, Woodstock, proprietor of a confectionery store, who was held up and shot there Thursday night, Jan 20, at 11 o’clock.
The charge has been laid by R N Ball, crown attorney at Woodstock. It followed identification of the prisoners by three men who were in the store at the time of the hold-up and who came to the city Saturday afternoon. As a result of further identifications, Crown Attorney J B McKillop declared today that there will also be charges of committing robbery with violence against Vincent Perry and of theft from the store of Louis Haddad, fruit merchant, 768 Dundas street. The accused will appear before Magistrate A H M Graydon in police court tomorrow, Mr McKillop stated.
The Woodstock case will be given the preference. Whether or not the local end is settled tomorrow, the Garfields will be taken to Woodstock to stand trial. If it so happens the case here is not disposed of and the charge at Woodstock falls, then the men will be brought here to stand trial.
T Underhill, R Franklin and E Utting are the three Woodstock men who were here Saturday. They were first asked to describe the revolvers used when Johnston was held up and this description tallied with the description of the two loaded revolvers found in the rooms at 54 Dundas street at the time of the raid. The brothers were then brought face to face with the three men. Underhill and Franklin, according to Chief of Police Moore, Woodstock, immediately recognized the Garfields. Utting was a little doubtful, he said, until a long gray overcoat was put on one of the prisoners.
Vincent Perry, who was held up and robbed at 10.50 pm on January 23 at Talbot and John streets, stated that he identified the taller of the two Garfields as the one who attacked him.
Three suits of clothes had to be put on the taller of the two men before Louis Haddad, who was held up on January 17 and his till emptied of $18.50, cold begin to establish an identity. He declared that the eyes and the upper part of Garfield’s nose were indeed similar to those of the man who carried the revolvers the night his store was robbed. As to the shorter man, he was not sure. This fellow was at the till with his back to Haddad when he first caught a glimpse of him.
Two women, who gave their names as Kittie and Annie Garfield, were arrested with the two men Friday night. A report has been circulated in police circles that the two women were the other two maked bandits in the car which held up Haddad’s store. There is, however, no confirmation of this.
The quartet appeared before Magistrate Graydon Saturday morning, charged with vagrancy. All pleaded not guilty and were remanded to jail for a week. The two men said they had not been working for four weeks. Norman Garfield said he had been employed at the Neilson plant in Toronto. He had come to the city to visit his brother. In the prisoner’s box, they appeared calm and answered questions put to them quietly and without confusion.
The two women were defended by E W M Flock. Both were flashily dressed and stod before the magistrate in a haughty manner. Annie Garfield is better known to the police as Annie Harkness, “the women”, said Crown Attorney McKillop, “who has the reputation of having so many husbands.” The woman made no reply to this remark.
The story is being circulated that the Garfields came to the city some four weeks ago and that the London police, on information for Toronto, have had them under surveillance ever since. It is reported that they have lived in four or five different places during that time and that they had only been at 54 Dundas street two or three days.
A man by the name of Denton Garfield has a long police record at Mimico, it has been learned from C Ferrier, superintendent of the school there.
The Toronto World, 24 January, 1921
GARFIELD BROTHERS UP
Grand jury considers murder charge against them
Woodstock, Ont March 7 — The Grand Jury investigating the case of Norman and Denton Garfield, of Toronto, under arraignment for the murder of Benjamin Johnston, confectionery storekeeper, adjourned at 5 o’clock this afternoon until ten o’clock tomorrow morning without bringing in any report. It is believed that they will not report their finding before noon Wednesday.
Much interest has been excited in the trial, the most famous locally since the celebrated Birchall case of thirty years ago, and a great many visitors have flocked to the city to witness the proceedings. In his address to the Grand Jury, Mr Justice Kelly referred to the great wave of crime the country was experiencing, and deplored the fact that it was mostly young men of our own blood who were the guilty ones. The demand for amusements and convenience, the automobile and the moving pictures, were doing their share in breaking down the old morality.
The Gazette (Montreal), 8 March, 1921
Norman Garfield Is Convicted Of Murder
Admits Hold-Up In Winnipeg During Toronto Trial
The jury in the case Of Norman Garfield, of Toronto, on trial for the murder of Benjamin Johnston, local restaurant keeper, on the night of Jan. 30, retired at 6:12 this evening, and returned to the court room at 8:43 with a unanimous verdict of murder.
Norman’s younger brother, Denton, was convicted yesterday of manslaughter in connection with the same crime, and sentence on the two will be passed tomorrow. The court room was crowded all day, and was not even cleared during the time the jury was out.
Greater interest was manifested in the trial of Norman than of Denton, who was looked upon as the man who had done the actual killing.
Get Diarmid Mogg’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
During his cross-examination today by Crown Attorney Ball, Norman Garfield admitted having been arrested on Nov 18 1914, for helping to hold-up a coach near Spokane, Washington. Two men had been killed on that occasion, but he denied having any part in the shooting. He was sentenced that time for from, 5 to 30 years, and was pardoned after serving 4 years and 11 months. Later in Winnipeg, he was arrested for holding up a man and relieving him of $70. For this he was sentenced to three years, but made his escape.
Lethbridge Herald, March 11, 1921
PRISONER UNDER DEATH SENTENCE MAKES ESCAPE
Woodstock, May 25 — Canadian Press — Norman Garfield, sentenced to be hanged on June 2 for the murder on January 20 of Ben Johnson, restaurant and shop keeper, of this place, made his escape from jail at 5.25 this afternoon, and up to a late hour had not been recaptured.
Garfield seized an opportunity when Guard Ball had unlocked his cell door and was standing inside the cell door, totally unsuspicious of an attack. The prisoner grappled with the guard, threw him on to a table, seized his keys and locked him into the cell. Garfield then ran down the corridor, descended the stairs, and, after a short tussle with Rev Mr Gaetz, who was just leaving the jail after having paid him a visit, unlocked the main door and made his escape.
Mr Gaetz is supposed to have been the only person to see him make his escape, although the fail cook, a trusty, heard the commotion in the corridor, and rushed to investigate but Garfield was by that time out of sight.
Norman Garfield and his brother Denton were arrested in London, Ont … On February 15, they were sent for trial on this charge [murder] and were tried on March 9 and 10. Norman was found guilty of murder and Denton of manslaughter. Denton was sentenced to twenty years in Kingston and is now serving this term, and Norman was sentenced to be hanged on June 2.
Rev Mr Gaetz’s story is that he had made Garfield a short visit and had been let out of the cell by Guard Ball and was waiting in the lower hall for the latter to come and unlock the rear door of the jail and let him out. He though he head Ball coming and turned round, to see Garfield standing some distance off. The clergyman said to him, “Norman, what are you doing here? Have you gone crazy?” Garfield made no answer, but continued on to the main door and proceeded to unlock it. Mr Gaetz followed him, repeating his question, and seizing him by the arm. At this, the escaping prisoner shouted, “Stand back,” and with one arm hurled the parson from him. “He was soon outside,” said Mr Gaetz, “and before I could recover my senses he was across the street and gone.”
Garfield’s wife and mother visited him earlier in the afternoon and his mother was so impressed by her son’s peculiar demeanor that she had Kitty Garfield telephone to Mr Gaetz to go and see him. “Before I left the jail,” said Mrs Garfield, senior, “I put my arm around him, kissed him, and said: ‘God bless you, my boy.’ His answer was cold,” continued the mother, as the tears coursed down her cheeks. “Do not bless me,” he said.
Mrs Garfield denounced her son’s action in escaping from the jail. “I would rather have him meet his Maker on the scaffold,” she said, “that bring this further disgrace on all who have been so good to him.”
May Have Stolen Auto
At 5.30 this afternoon a Ford automobile was stolen from in front of Mr Hosack’s on Light Street. The loss was not made known until some hours afterwards. It is now almost certain that Garfield took the car as the place from where it was stolen is just two blocks from the jail, and in the same direction which Garfield took when he left the county building. Fifteen or twenty minutes later the car passed through Hickson at a terrific speed. This village is eight miles north of Woodstock.
The Montreal Gazette, 25 May, 1921
MOTHER WISHES SON HAD BEEN KILLED
Woodstock, Ont, May 28 — The clutch of the hangman is again at the throat of Norman Garfield. After fifty-six hours of agonised liberty the murderer of Benjamin Johnson is again on his way back to the death cell here. His mad adventure has failed even to postpone the date of his death and he will be led to the scaffold on Thursday morning next.
Garfield was captured at Stewart town, just outside Georgetown, Ont., after he had travelled about 80 miles by stolen auto and on foot. Two women, Mrs. I. A. Tracy and Miss E. Appelbe noticed him resting on a bench behind the railroad station. Mrs. Tracy notified her husband, who despite his sixty odd years, went out alone to capture the murderer.
Tracy, who is clerk of the township, picked up two men on his way to where Garfield was resting and it was well he did, for Garfield was not taken without a fight. The struggle was short, however, for the murderer, exhausted by his travels, was no match for the three men. He was quickly manacled with a pair of handcuffs Tracy had taken with him and was soon lodged in Georgetown jail.
Garfield was still wearing the suit in which he escaped, but had purchased a hat and a new pair of boots at Millington.
“The thing looked so easy I could not resist the temptation of walking away when I saw Ball come back of Mr Gaetz’s hat,” said Garfield after his capture. “I do not think any man in my position with death staring him in the face would have acted in a different way. No, I did not have any confederates.
“I had plans, I will admit, to get in touch with some of my friends, but the opportunity came and I grabbed it.
“Well, I guess I’ll hang after all. The game is up, but I played it for all it was worth. I am sorry that I had to adopt the method of playing the jail people for suckers, but it was my life I looked after first.”
“Oh, if he had only been shot down in his track and his body brought to me,” were the words of Mrs Garfield, mother of Norman when told that her boy had been recaptured.
Garfield’s mother, wife and child wept bitterly and the younger woman seemed about to collapse. Mrs Garfield continued:
“I don’t think that I can stand the terrible ordeal that is bound to come in the next few days for now it is certain that this action in escaping has ended his last chance for a reprieve.”
Dunkirk Evening Observer, May 28, 1921
Norman Garfield Bids His Relatives Farewell
Woodstock, Ont., June 1 — Norman Garfield, who is in jail awaiting execution at dawn Thursday morning for the murder of Ben Johnson, of this city, is reported as calmly bearing the strain of his pending doom.
This afternoon, his last on earth, he was given the freedom of the corridor when his mother and wife, two brothers and sisters were with him bidding him a sad farewell.
Winnipeg Free Press, June 2, 1921
GOES TO GALLOWS AFTER ‘SMOKE’
Norman Garfield Pays Penalty for Killing of Ben Johnston
Woodstock, Ont., June 2. — Norman Garfield, convicted of the murder of Ben Johnston, a confectioner, last January, was hanged at the jail today. He smoked a cigaret while the executioner prepared for the hanging.
Garfield had several days freedom last week, when he escaped from his cell and made his way to the open country. He was rearrested after a sharp fight with officers.
Lowell Sun, June 2, 1921
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
Epilogue
Here’s a final clipping, which features an earlier picture of Norman, from 1912, nine years before he was hanged.
ESCAPED FROM PORTAGE INDUSTRIAL SCHOOL
Two more escapes were effected Monday from the Portage la Prairie reformatory. The lads who escaped are Edmund Cole and Norman Garfield. The escape was effected a little after 7 p.m. while the two youths were cleaning up the stables and feeding the horses. Both while at the reformatory were fairly well behaved but were considered in the light of rather bad characters. Cole was sent up for holding up a pedestrian in Edmonton, and Garfield for burglary in this city. Both had been in the reformatory for some months. Garfield is 20 years of age and Cole 19.
Manitoba Free Press, November 13, 1912








