Sitemap
Danny Mitan

Danny Mitan

The Real Reason No One in the NFL Wants Tim Tebow
By Daniel Mitan

14 min readNov 18, 2014

--

This article is written in response to a post by Steve Matoren entitled Why No One in the NFL Wants Tim Tebow. Certainly feel free to read Steve’s article first, but I warn you; it’s going to be about twenty minutes of your life that you’ll never get back.

Honestly, it seems as though most of the world and all 32 NFL teams have moved on from caring about Tim Tebow, but, apparently, one blogger named Steve Matoren has not. At the request of a mutual friend, I responded to Steve’s article, and maybe I can also help all of you reading this understand why Tim Tebow is no longer in the NFL.

The reality is that Tim Tebow cannot read an NFL defense or throw a football accurately enough to play at the NFL level. His skill set is much better suited to play Fullback or Tight End, however, he is too stubborn to change positions full time.

In a way, I feel kinda bad shattering Steve’s dreams of ever seeing Tim Tebow suit up in an NFL uniform again. Honestly, I don’t like being the one to tell a kid that Santa Claus isn’t real.

To open up, I will just cut through the all the bullshit and pretense. ALL people who contest that Tim Tebow should be playing in the NFL at the Quarterback position fall into one of TWO categories: They are either (1.) Evangelical Christians, or (2.) super-Florida Gator fans who can’t let it go. It does not take much research to figure out that Steve falls into the latter category, thus reinforcing the truth of my statement. Meanwhile, there is no one who thinks Tebow should be an NFL Quarterback who does not fall into one or both of the aforementioned categories. And if you are reading this and you want to see Tebow playing in the NFL, then you also fall into one of those categories.

So let’s look at Steve’s essay, shall we? He states that Tim Tebow won a state championship in high school. Okay, great. Guess what? 50 kids win high school championships each year. (Actually, the number is much higher than that, because most states have multiple champions since there are different school sizes that don’t compete against each other.)

Then Steve goes on to say that Tim Tebow won two National Championships in college. TWO, he says! I don’t know, I just think that is AWFULLY generous to attribute the National Championship that CHRIS LEAK WON as the starting Quarterback of the Gators as “Tim Tebow’s Championship”. Did anyone happen to notice that Tebow essentially played Fullback for approximately forty snaps that entire season. How exactly does that count as “Tebow’s Championship”? ‘Cause I don’t get it. Should we also say that LaDainian Tomlinson won seven NFL starts at QUARTERBACK because he threw seven halfback passes for touchdowns?

Then he goes into Tebow’s 2007 college stats. Tebow threw for 29 TDs and rushed for 21 more. First of all, I would tell you that those stats are somewhat inflated because Tebow basically served as the team’s Fullback that season, so he scored a lot of short-yardage rushing touchdowns that normally would have been scored by a Running Back. Furthermore, like most Tebow supporters, Steve likes to pick and choose the stats that he wants people to see while completely ignoring other statistics that don’t further his argument. Like the fact that Tebow’s team had FOUR LOSSES THAT YEAR. One of those losses came in a HOME game to an UNRANKED Auburn team, capped off by losing the Capital One Citrus Bowl to the same Michigan team that got beat by Appalachian State earlier in the year.

Nonetheless, Tebow won a Heisman Trophy. Meanwhile, Colt Brennan threw for 58 touchdowns in 2006 and then went undefeated with Hawaii in 2007. And I know that Hawaii played in the WAC and not the SEC, but Colt Brennan did it with the “talent” at Hawaii (FYI, they do not have the budget to recruit on the mainland at Hawaii). And yet, there is no clamoring for Colt Brennan to play in the NFL. Why not?

Steve’s next big stat is that Tebow is 8–6 as an NFL starter.

Well, that is super-impressive and hard to argu… Wait! Did you say 8 and 6? EIGHT and SIX?!?! Hmmm… that’s so weird. Skip Bayless always makes it SEEM like Tebow is 7–1 as a starter. Well, there it is. The calling card of the Tebow supporters. Focus on the stats you want and ignore the rest.
“Tim Tebow won eight games as an NFL starter!!!” (Let’s NOT mention the SIX losses, though.) Eight and six isn’t that impressive, though, now, is it? ‘Cause guess what? When they replaced Tebow with Peyton Manning on that same team, they went 13–3. Twice. They also went to the Super Bowl two years after Tebow’s departure.

Steve then laments Tebow’s decision to go to the Jets. See, I’m afraid ol’ Timmy’s gonna have to take responsibility for that one. You see, the Jacksonville Jaguars were also interested in him. And that would have been a much better fit. But in a decision to market his “brand,” Tebow (and/or his advisors, to be fair) opted for the bigger market NY Jets over the hometown Jags. To quote Julia Roberts’ character in ‘Pretty Woman’, “Big mistake. Big. Huge.”

But as long as we’re on the Jets, let’s look at a statistic that the majority of Tebow backers LOVE TO IGNORE… Namely his “Not-NFL-Worthy” 48% Career Completion Percentage. For a point of reference, I will elaborate on what is considered a quality and acceptable completion percentage at the NFL level. See, the truly elite Quarterbacks (Brees, Brady, Manning, Rodgers) complete around 70% of their passes. A good NFL Quarterback will complete around 65% of his passes. 60% is about the cut-off point to remain a journeyman starter on an NFL team. Especially with today’s passing rules giving more unimpeded releases to receivers. Mark Sanchez of the Jets was under scrutiny because he threw about 55% complete. Tebow throws 48% complete. Name another contemporary starting NFL Quarterback with a career completion percentage that is under 50%.

Go ahead. I’ll wait.

Stumped? Don’t feel bad. It’s a trick question! THERE ARE NONE! See, ‘cause if you can’t complete over half of the passes that you attempt, you DON’T BELONG IN THE NFL!!! Even if you’re really nice and rescue kittens and have lots of twitter followers and bake cupcakes and do charity work and go to church and stuff.

Now we get to the heart (or really the entire basis) of Steve Matoren’s assertion that Tebow should still be in the NFL. Ready? Okay. Here is the basis of his argument. Tim Tebow won A playoff game. Steve then mentions a bunch of mediocre Quarterbacks who have also won playoff games (Matt Schaub, Jeff George, Bubby Brister, Rodney Peete, Steve Walsh, Steve Beuerlein, David Garrard Marc Bulger, Erik Kramer, Elvis Grbac, Don Meredith, Steve Barkowski, Steve DeBerg, Joe Ferguson and David Carr.) I guess his idea was supposed to be that these guys won playoff games and stayed in the League, so why not Tebow? However, what I extract from this is, “Look at all these average Quarterbacks who also fluked into winning a playoff game,” or, “Anyone can get lucky and win a playoff game.” So I think he’s actually hurting his argument more so than helping it with that stat.

And guess what? Trent Dilfer WON A SUPER BOWL and was looking for a new team the next year. Jeff Hostetler also won a Super Bowl. These are not great Quarterbacks. Ultimately, football is a team game, and while the Quarterback is the most important position, it is possible to win a game or even a few games with a bad Quarterback. Anyone notice how much better the Broncos are after switching from Tebow to Manning? Because Steve doesn’t mention that at all. Why not?

But here’s my favorite part. Ready? Basically, Steve’s WHOLE argument is that Tim Tebow should still be in the NFL because he won ONE playoff game. Are you ready? I am so excited to tell you this next part…

MARK SANCHEZ WON FOUR PLAYOFF GAMES.

FOUR!!!

That is four times more playoff wins than Tebow has! Steve must think that Mark Sanchez is the Greatest Quarterback of ALL-TIME. In fact, I am now wondering why he has not written an article about how Mark Sanchez should be handed the reigns as the Philadelphia Eagles starter for the next decade. Or perhaps he is working on that now. Maybe the Tebow essay just a practice essay?

So at this point in Steve’s article, he decides to break down Tebow’s season, and I’m gonna do it along with him. This is gonna be fun! I hope Steve doesn’t mind if I mention some facts that he has noticeably omitted. I mean, they are FACTS, after all, so I’m sure he can’t object.

And in this section, Steve Matoren also ominously writes MY ABSOLUTE FAVORITE LINE of his essay…

“Remember Kyle Orton — more on him later.”

(No, seriously, remember Kyle Orton. There will be more on him later.)

Let’s recap…

WEEK 6 – vs. MIAMI DOLPHINS
Due to some bumbling ownership, the Miami Dolphins actually decided to honor the Tebow and the Gator National Championship team on this day. In that regard, the Dolphins deserved to lose. Karma will pay them a visit. Tebow plays three-and-a-half Quarters of the worst NFL football anyone has seen (until Josh Freeman stepped in at QB for the Vikings in 2013, but, I digress). Tebow is 13–27 with only 161 yards (sheesh!), but, with the help of an onside kick, they do manage some late touchdowns to tie the game. The Broncos kicker Matt Prater nails a 52 yard field goal in OT to win the game. Tebow receives the credit for an onside kick recover and a 52 yard field goal. Much like Chris Leak at the University of Florida, Prater is somehow overshadowed by Tebow, who is given credit for the win.

WEEK 8 – vs. DETROIT LIONS
Tebow goes 18–39 for 172 yards. The Detroit Lions are literally laughing at him. This game is like “Voldemort” for Tebow-backers…
“It shall not be named.” Or mentioned ever again.
(But, fortunately, I have no such constraints.)
Tebow looks like a joke and the Broncos lose 45–10

WEEK 9 – vs. OAKLAND RAIDERS
Tebow has the luck of facing the hapless Oakland Raiders and Carson Palmer fresh out of retirement. (Literally, Carson was at home on a couch the week before.) Tebow goes 10–21 with only 124 yards. Broncos still win.

WEEK 10 – vs. KANSAS CITY CHEIFS
Tebow only goes 2–8 for 69 yards, but one of the passes is a deep ball TD pass. What goes largely unmentioned is that Matt Cassel plays even worse than that, going 13–28 for 93 yards, and only musters 10 points.
Broncos D holds opponent to 10 points and Tebow gets credit for the win.

Get Danny Mitan’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

WEEK 11 – vs. NEW YORK JETS
This is a GREAT example of a Tebow “win”. Tebow goes 9–20 for 104 yards.

The Broncos OFFENSE scores 10 points. The Jets offense scores 13 points. But the Broncos defense gets a “Pick 6”, which ends up being the difference in the game. Nonetheless, another “victory” for Tebow.
Broncos win 17–13

WEEK 12 – vs. SAN DIEGO CHARGERS
Apparently, Tebow super-fan#1 Steve was at this game. Somehow, he even describes this Defensive Snoozefest as “electric” (I wonder what he was watching?) But he did get to see Tebow throw 50% complete! (Although laughably below the League average, an above-par personal performance for Tebow.) The Broncos Defense holds the Chargers to 13 points through regulation and overtime, Matt Prater kicks 3 Field Goals, and Tebow gets all the credit. Broncos win 16–13

WEEK 13 – vs. MINNESOTA VIKINGS
Tebow actually does play well this game. 10–15 for 202 yards and 2 TDs.
So there’s ONE. Broncos win 35–32

WEEK 14 – vs. CHICAGO BEARS
Broncos catch a break and face Caleb Hanie instead of Jay Cutler. Another fine Defensive performance for the Broncos holds Chicago to only 10 points. Nonetheless, Tebow is unable to score more than 10 points in regulation and Prater bails them out again with a 51 yard Field Goal in Overtime. Broncos win 13–10. Let’s not mention the Defense, though. Or the Kicker.
It’s all Tebow, right?

WEEK 15 – vs. NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS
These are the games that all the Tebow supporters will IGNORE COMPLETELY. Like they never happened. Tebow goes 11–22 with 194 yards. But this is nothing compared to the thrashing that New England will unleash on Tebow and the Broncos in the Playoffs. (But that New England Playoff game must NEVER, EVER be mentioned by Tebow fans. A lot of them actually had the game erased from their memory using hypnosis.)

WEEK 16 – vs. BUFFALO BILLS
Tebow goes 13–29 for 185 yards, and they get their asses whooped by Ryan Fitzpatrick and the Buffalo Bills, 40–14. Outplayed by Fitzy. Ouch!

WEEK 17 – vs. KANSAS CITY CHIEFS
So, let me set this up for you, because there is great drama and subtext with this one. If the Broncos win this game; they are in the Playoffs. If they lose, they have to rely on other outcomes to make it. They control their own destiny!!! How fitting is that for Tebow? But, wait!

This is my FAVORITE PART, right here! Remember when I said, “Remember Kyle Orton — more on him later.” Remember that?

Okay, I can’t take credit for it. That was Steve Matoren’s line!

Well here’s why we wanted you to remember Orton.

See, the Broncos waved him, and now he plays for the rival Chiefs! So with the Broncos controlling their own fate, all that stands in their way of a guaranteed playoff berth is their old Quarterback, Kyle Orton, who gets a head-to-head battle with Tebow!!! It’s just too much! So, here’s what happens…

The Broncos Defense is up to the task, holding Kansas City to 7 points.

But TEBOW GOES 6 for 22 WITH ONLY 60 yards!!!

Denver only scores 3 points! Why don’t these owners want this guy Quarterbacking their team?!?!

With the loss, the Broncos dropped to 8–8, and were swept at home by their division rivals for the second time in three seasons. The Broncos finished tied with the Oakland Raiders and San Diego Chargers for the AFC West division title. However, the Broncos won the tiebreakers over both teams based on record against common opponents (5–5 to the Raiders’ and Chargers’ 4–6).

PLAYOFFS vs. STEELERS
Tebow actually does play well. So there’s TWO. He still throws under 50%, and the game winning TD was an 18 yard crossing route that the receiver ran for another 62 yards. And the Steelers didn’t have most of their starting defensive secondary for that game, but whatevs. Tebow won. And Tebowmaniacs seem to think the story ends here. You know, like nothing comes after this. Even in Steve’s essay, there are many mentions of the Playoff Victory, but NO MENTION of the OTHER PLAYOFF GAME. Shoot, even I was objective enough to mention the TWO games where Tebow actually played well. I guess I’ll have to fill you in with what happened next.

PLAYOFFS vs. PATRIOTS
Tebow goes 9–26 with 136 yards. Denver loses 45–10

This game is erased from the minds of Tebow supporters using the same mind control device that Edward Nygma engineered in the movie “Batman Forever”. Since our author Steve has no memory of this game, he might think that I am making it up, but like I said, people, these are FACTS.

At this point in the essay, Steve starts inventing stats to make Tebow look as good as the Broncos Defense was in 2012. Look at his percentage of completions that go for touchdowns! (Again, LaDainian Tomlinson is 8 of 12 with 7 TDs. Maybe some NFL teams should give him a starting QB job!) Steve also mentions “QBR,” which is basically a statistic that ESPN invented largely for the purpose of making Tebow look more competent. You don’t believe me? Check this out…

Look how close he can bring his completion percentage to 50% against prevent defenses! Tebow threw for 300 yards against the Steelers back-ups in a playoff game when the starters got injured! (BUT DON’T YOU DARE MENTION THE NEW ENGLAND GAME THE FOLLOWING WEEK, where he was 9–26 against the 28th ranked Pass Defense! That game never happened, right, Steve?)

Let’s invent more stats to make Tebow look good! Tebow is undefeated in games when the moon is in its “waning crescent” phase! Tim Tebow completes 100% of the passes he completes! Tim Tebow has never been beaten in a game that he won! Inventing stats is awesome!

Then the essay talks about what a good samaritan Tebow is. Well, golly, I’ve never been arrested. Maybe I should be given a starting NFL QB job, too? Then Steve talks about how popular Tebow is, which, again, has nothing to do with reading a defense or throwing a football, two skills an NFL Quarterback needs and Tebow lacks.

Speaking of throwing a football, not to be mean, but have you ever really watched Tim Tebow throw a football? More often than not, it looks like a punt. Can you imagine being a Wide Receiver on the Patriots? Tom Brady throws you a tight spiral that hits you square in the numbers on your jersey, and then you get back in the receiver line and Tim Tebow throws a pass that sails twenty yards over your head?

Anyway, back to Steve’s essay, which quickly devolves into a bunch of emails to all of the NFL owners demanding an explanation as to why Tebow is not in the NFL. Kind of a childish stunt, really. Maybe alumni from every college should email all the NFL owners to complain about why their star College Quarterback isn’t in the NFL. Tommy Frazier! Colt Brennan! Vince Young! Matt Leinart! Eric Crouch! Jared Zabransky! Jason White! Ken Dorsey! Hell, even Danny Wuerffel!

There are many reasons why Tim Tebow is not in the NFL. One is that he refuses to change positions to Tight End or Fullback. Another is that he refuses to play in Canada or the Arena League to showcase his skills. Steve mentions Kurt Warner going from “bagging groceries” to the Super Bowl. Ummm… actually Kurt Warner played in the Arena League first. See, he didn’t just throw himself a big, ol’ pity party with an “NFL or bust” stance. He “auditioned,” if you will.

So, let’s recap. What have we learned here today? We learned that no starting Quarterback in the modern NFL throws under 50% complete. Also, that some people think that an 8–6 is somehow such a stellar achievement that it is inconceivable that any Quarterback, even Tom Brady or Peyton Manning would be able to achieve such a winning percentage. We also learned that although Tim Tebow won a playoff game, Mark Sanchez won four.

(Tebow is 1–1, btw, Sanchez is 4–2 in the Playoffs)

Moreover, Kyle Orton beat Tim Tebow head-to-head in a game where Tebow only mustered 3 points. And if we’re really being honest, out of fourteen games, Tebow really only played well TWICE. (Gator fans and Evangelical Christians don’t like to be that honest about it, though.)

And, lastly, we learned that “because Steve Matoren REALLY REALLY wants Tim Tebow to be in the NFL,” just isn’t a compelling enough reason.

Someone on facebook told me that I spent way too much time responding to this article. And that’s a completely valid point. I did spend way too much time on it. But then again, I didn’t email every NFL owner, now, did I?

P.S. – Since Steve was kind enough to end his essay with a Tebow highlight video, I will do the same.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qUYftLla5vs

--

--