Sitemap
Elizabeth Crisman

Elizabeth Crisman

Fight Song

12 min readAug 16, 2014

--

I. Overture

Gearing up to rain that day, and we walked by twos and threes on still-dry pavement, across the creek-bridge, down the road, across one street, two, to the Starbucks one block down, one away. There, we sat — it took two couches, three armchairs and a footstool to hold us, and still, we sat squished, hip to hip, though most of us were barely friends, passing faces in the hall, names tied to them only loosely, then. There’s a picture floating around, somewhere, of that day; as it happens, we smiled.

Fay Harper was a year younger than me, and sharp in a way I wasn’t — sharp jaw, sharp wit, eyes lined black, and always laughing. Abrasive as often as not, but I wanted her to like me; was never sure why, but that validation seemed pressing, somehow, so I sought it. She sat by me, that day, to my right; we talked some, not much, before she went outside to smoke.

The middle-school kids had arrived not long after us, from the building just across the road, a block from our own, in a drove like ours, and sat outside, once they had their coffees and cocoas and whatever else — we’d taken their usual spot, I suppose. They were there when Fay went outside, and we could see them talking, through the front window. We saw the smoke curl out of her mouth and into their faces, saw lips moving on both sides, silently.

She came back in, wind and smoke on her coat, and sat beside me, laughing, telling us what was said. “They asked me why I smoked,” she said, loud enough for those on our periphery to hear. “I told them I wanted to get cancer. They looked so fucking shocked. It was hilarious.” And it was, to us, that day, on that cramped couch, just before the rain, so we laughed and laughed, and fifteen minutes later, she went out again, a repeat show, encore, encore.

The rest of the day was, on the whole, unremarkable. Our parents picked us up in ones and twos — none of us could drive yet, though some of us were close. We were all still children; I know that now. Just kids.

It didn’t get bad till nightfall, really, though I felt it all the while, on my mind’s edge, gnawing.

It was a small wrong, I told myself.

She’s the one who said it, not me. I only laughed. Laughing isn’t wrong.

They’ve probably forgotten it by now, anyway. The kids and the others, both.

It won’t matter, in the long run.

It won’t make them start smoking, of course not. That’s not how real life works.

They started it, too — by the looks on their faces, they were telling her off.

If they’d just left her alone, she wouldn’t have done it, and we wouldn’t have laughed.

Even if they do start smoking, that’s not my fault. It’s not even her fault.

And I only laughed, after all.

Laughing isn’t wrong.

Right?

It would sound so little, later, all of it, the whole thing, but that night, I was miniscule before it. I didn’t sleep — how could I? I’d contributed to the deaths of who-knew-how-many innocents, and for what, the approval of an almost-friend one rainy afternoon? Mine was a small part, sure, but a part all the same. I was not innocent. I would never be innocent again.

I watched my clock that night, and the minutes ticked by slow. Sometimes, I’d shut my eyes for awhile, still sleepless, like a child on Christmas Eve. Morning will come faster if you sleep. Santa can’t come when your eyes are open. The morning would bring me solace. In the morning, I would tell her what I’d done, and she’d tell me what I deserved for it. She’d tell me how far, in fact, I’d fallen. Maybe she’d forgive me. Maybe she wouldn’t.

Of course, it was to be my mother. There was no one else. There was me, but I was me, I was the wrong one; the wronged, the kids, were gone, home, away, wherever. My friends? They wouldn’t get it, and I didn’t trust them, anyway. She was all I had. The only arbiter who counted. In the morning, I would tell her. I just had to make it till then.

4:30. 4:45. 5:00 A.M.

Do I really have to tell her, though? I wondered. Is it really worth all that?

Maybe she’ll just laugh and tell me it’s nothing. Maybe it is nothing. Maybe it’s nothing at all.

I won’t know, though, unless I tell her. So I’ll tell her.

If she gets mad, well, I deserve it, then. It’s the least I can do, for what I did.

If I hadn’t done it, I’d be asleep right now.

They’re all asleep right now. The kids are. Fay is. Mom is.

Fay didn’t know any better. She’s younger than me, and she’s not so smart, and she didn’t know better, like I did. My laughing, then, was worse. I knew better. I was worse.

5:45. 5:47. 5:56.

This is going to be embarrassing.

I don’t want to do this.

Sarah will hear, too, even if I’m quiet.

But I have to. I can’t not. If I don’t, I’m worse. If I don’t, I’m awful. More awful.

So I have to. And I will.

So I did, and for a moment or two, it was awful, until it wasn’t. She forgave me, as well as she could, all tired eyes and confusion. “Why is that such a big deal?” she said as I sobbed. “You were up all night over that?”

I had never heard words so comforting as those. There’s a catharsis, see, not in the confession, but in the moment you realize it was unnecessary. It’s something lost forever, mourned and buried, brought back bright and shinier than ever. It’s land you reach five miles from where the lifeboat left you. The contrast is sharp, and once the sting is gone, you’re reeling in less than you had before, but it’s more, somehow, and you’re tired in the finest way. It is addictive. I know that now.

II. Reprise

It did not end there, of course. A void was left by the forgiveness of the one, a space just the right size for another, and so another came. Each one felt larger than the last, made the last look miniscule to scale.

Was it the military pamphlets my friends and I mocked in front of the soldier handing them out that weekend, next? Or did I dip back, right away, to the antiques, barely-remembered — was it the prank phone call to Enrique whoever, confirming his onine order of red lace panties? Something earlier, perhaps — something from middle school, or fifth grade, or kindergarten, because hell, I’d always been me, so it all counted. I could excuse nothing; everything was fair game.

I’d wait till the shower went on to start; for all that I needed my mother to hear me, Sarah was meant to be spared. (It got to where the noise of the shower itself upset me; operational conditioning is a powerful thing.) Then, I’d tell her whatever the latest Everything was, the latest thing I could not let go, myself. She’d laugh it off, or look concerned, not for it, but for me, and relief would rush in, every time. Less and less and less each time, but what I needed, all the same. The only way I could keep on, long-term.

My limit, holding something in, was about six hours, then. I could bury myself in work, sometimes, and drag it out longer. (I got an A in chemistry that year; stoichiometry precludes self-reflection, see, so for those few months, I near cherished it.) The time between, though, was hell.

Get Elizabeth Crisman’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

I was too far gone, those months, to see my mother there, beneath her role, worrying. What I was doing had no name to us, then; to her, I was falling apart. How sick would it be to feel guilty for that? How ironic?

Anyway, it was a holding pattern. It couldn’t last like that, and so it didn’t.

III. Crescendo

It came to a head on graduation day, when I was still a sophomore and playing in the band. The catalyst of the day was Lara Jackson; I could see her from my seat, across the rented stadium, in the far bleachers, near the top.

I don’t think I’d ever spoken to her, then, but her story had been all over school a few months the November prior. People said she’d given that shithead Mike Stein a blowjob in the men’s restroom, and she said he made her do it, but no one believed her. He was littler than her, see, a size-small freshman to her size-large junior, so he couldn’t have, we said, and I know I know I know I know I know I know I know, but that’s how it was, and that’s how I’ll tell it.

So I sat there, playing in the band — Fight Song, Anthem, Graduation March — and I watched Lara Jackson in the stands, and I remembered a friend’s birthday party the December prior, at a restaurant with a dance floor, formal-dress. My friends and I…we made up a dance move, that night, and called it the Lara. We performed mock fellatio on an imaginary man. And we laughed.

That’s all we did, really, was laugh.

She wasn’t there. She didn’t see us. She never knew.

We didn’t know it was wrong, at the time. We were a bunch of 15-year-old Missourian children, and we laughed, and we danced. It was over in ten minutes, months before that graduation day. It was a delayed reaction, but sharper than I’d ever felt.

There was no clock in the stadium, so I just waited. My mother would pick me up when it ended, but for the time, I was frozen, static, stuck. I could only wait, so I waited.

And waited.

And waited.

Late afternoon, bordering on dusk, and it ended, as it had to, as I knew it would. It was beautiful out — sun lighting trees golden before sinking behind them, graduates filing out, blue and white against the world’s green and yellow-gold.

I was so scared.

I blurted it out as soon as the car doors closed. Of course I did. I don’t remember just what I said — I don’t know if I was coherent, but I got it out, and waited for the relief.

And waited.

And waited.

“What am I supposed to say to that?” she asked. “Like, do you expect me to say that’s okay, that you laughed at that girl for getting attacked? How do you expect me to respond?”

I had never wanted to die, before that. It’s not in my nature to even consider it, but there it was, the unlocked car door, and there I was, unforgivable. I told her to let me out, let me walk home, at least, and she refused. “That was a shitty thing to do,” she said, “but I don’t want you to die for it, and I don’t trust you right now. You’re scaring me.”

That wasn’t enough. There was no relief in that. No forgiveness, and I knew it. The sun was gone by then, though light still lingered, and I was done for.

I went to my room when we got home, laid in bed for hours and hours. The sleeve of my fancy-dress shirt cut into my arm, but I would not move, because I deserved it, I deserved it, I deserved anything that hurt. My mother tried to help, but it didn’t matter anymore. I heard Sarah ask what was wrong, from the living room. I heard their murmurs, but didn’t really listen. It was done. I was done.

I realized I wasn’t brave enough to die, though to my mind, that day, I deserved it. The sun sank, and I cried, and my sleeve cut red into my arm, and I deserved it.

BUT. But I had reading that night. I was a coward, see, a coward who would not die, and if I was to live, I had to keep on as I always had. And I was hungry — I could smell dinner cooking, and after two refusals, I realized I wanted it, so I took it. I was not good, but even monsters eat.

So I ate, and I read. I cried, but I kept on. Will this work? I wondered. Is that it? Can even this be swept away?

I suppose not; we went to the hospital that night, when the tears wouldn’t stop. I protested. I brought my reading.

You go to the same emergency room, you know, when your emergency is mental. It’s not a different room or anything — you’re right in there with the chainsaw wounds and endless flus. I had not known that, but it didn’t bother me, not really. I tried to keep reading, but couldn’t, so I watched the goings-on and wondered what they’d say to me.

I talked to probably seven nurses that night, and each one asked if I wanted to die. I do not remember what I said. How was I to explain that, sure as I was that I deserved death, I was nowhere near brave enough to bring it about, so they didn’t have to worry about that? How does one explain that to people who, to your knowledge, have never known self-loathing?

Finally, one — a heavyset woman, about forty — went just a step further and asked what happened. So, I told her. Tearfully, in fits and starts, with wrung hands and glances to my mother, I did what I did best, again, and confessed. The truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. So help me…well, you know. Whoever. I told her about Lara Jackson and that shithead Mike Stein in the first-floor men’s room handicapped stall, about the maybe-rape that no one called that, about the names that no one said to anyone’s face, no, never to anyone’s face, but with no reserve, no regard, no relief behind anyone’s back. I told her about the dance.

“Now wait a second,” she said. “You said he was a…what was it…a junior in high school, and she was a…freshman, right? Do I have this down right?”

“Wha — no no no, the…the other way around. She’s a junior. He’s a freshman. That’s…that’s why no one believed her, which I know is wrong and I’m sorry, but…no. The other way around. Did you guys think…?”

“Wait, seriously?” my mom chimed in. “That’s nowhere near as bad! I wouldn’t have believed that either! Are you sure that’s what you told me the first time?”

Look, I know. Three years into college, with a mental cachet full of Ad Council PSAs and the enlightened world view you need to get by in polite society nowadays, I know. But what you need to understand is that that load of bullshit probably saved my life that night, that week, that semester, that year, five years ago. And Lara Jackson? She never knew my name. She graduated a year later with a smile on her face. I played in that band, too. I watched, and I have to believe she came out of it all okay. Okay?

The nurse told us, then, what my mom swears she’d already figured out: that I was very very sick, not morally, but chemically, and that my sickness had a name — rife with contradictions and misunderstandings, but a name nonetheless, and, better, a treatment. I had — have, will likely continue to have — purely-obsessional obsessive-compulsive disorder. Had I been born three hundred years earlier, I probably would have entered a convent and never left. Had I been born sixty years earlier, I probably would have entered a madhouse and never left. Had that nurse not put my chronological confusion to right that May night…well, I don’t know. Maybe I’d still be here. Anything’s possible, but anything’s not, too, and I’m thankful.

So I went to a psychologist — an old, sorry woman who didn’t understand, then a psychiatrist — a younger man who didn’t much care beyond the check, then a young, impassive pharmacist, who gave me pills, glorious pills. Of course, the first batch or two clogged my throat and gave me hives, but eventually, they got it right, and within a few months, I was…normal, again. That sounds like a lie, or a scam, or a hoax, but it wasn’t. I know all about the placebo effect, but it wasn’t that either, and if it was, I don’t care. It was over. It was over. It was over.

IV. Coda

I was afraid, before my own graduation, that the songs would stir something for me from that day — that it was still within me sleeping, the disease, and that the music could awaken it, note by note.

I got lucky, though. During my four years of high school, graduation was not held in the same place twice, and the year I walked the stage, it was on our home court: a small, sweaty gymnasium, half again too full, nothing like the rented stadium, two years before. Less pleasant, objectively, but you wouldn’t hear me complain, because the songs alone weren’t enough: any fear conditioned in me needed more than them to rear its head again.

Fight Song. Anthem. Graduation March.

I was fine. Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors were binding to the presynaptic neurons in my brain, increasing the total levels of serotonin in the synapses and keeping me okay. One hundred milligrams a day, and I could pass for a carefree adolescent. My friends, those friends, they did not know. Do not know. If you asked them today, they’d still laugh at Lara Jackson.

The worst part? Some part of me is glad for that. If they never feel guilt like I have, I’ll be glad.

Other people like guilt, you know, as long as it’s not theirs.

Other people don’t understand what guilt means, not really.

But me? I get it, and I’d wish it on no one. I’ll forgive near anything, now.

Stab me in the chest, I dare you. Kill me, then go home, cry, and wish it wasn’t so; my lingering ghost will hope you can forget.

--

--