Sitemap
Ezra Cooper

Ezra Cooper

Is this really happening?

4 min readDec 11, 2018

Twitter has one UX feature that seems so utterly wrong, I keep asking myself if I’m really seeing it.

Here’s the scene: when a friend posts something, maybe with a question, I want to jump in, so my eye finds the little comment icon. I immediately notice that it has a little number next to it: 10. Ah! says I, there are already 10 comments in reply to this one. Of course I’m going to check those out before launching my own. What if someone already said what I’m about to say? What if the original poster already clarified her question and I had misunderstood the original? In any case, piping up without knowing what else was said would look gauche, wouldn’t it?

Press enter or click to view image in full size
A tweet, showing 10 replies already.

So instead of touching that comment icon, I touch the tiny little number next to it. I want to know about those 10 comments! I expect to see the screen unroll in a satisfying animation and for a discussion to spread itself out in front of me. I can’t wait to see what’s going on! I already have FOMO for this conversation!

Instead, the original tweet skooches to the top, opening lots of blank white space, and a prompt for my own reply appears. Wha?!

Press enter or click to view image in full size
A gaping void pleading for my all-important voice

It’s like being at a party and every time you lean in, trying to pick up a conversation nearby, everyone fades into the dark corners, a spotlight comes up, and a cheerleader hands you a microphone.

“Oh!” you say. “I didn’t want this. I must have touched the wrong thing. Back button.” There’s the original tweet. Says 10 comments. How do I get to those? It must be by touching the 10, right? I want more detail on that bit of information! I want to zoom in. I want to drill down. I try to aim more closely at the little number. Everything disappears, prompting for my reply.

I find this so frustrating, trying to tune into a conversation and every time I get closer it just amplifies the thundering pulse in my own ears.

Get Ezra Cooper’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

How is it possible that Twitter is designed this way? It offers an often elegant and surely well-researched user experience. Was this feature designed at all? It seems just precisely wrong; like, if you wanted to implement a platform to maximize talking and minimize listening, this is exactly what you would do. If you thought, “This platform is for talking, for broadcasting—It is for discovering writing prompts and launching your immediate replies—It is a place where threads (if they exist at all) are a hideous melange of mismatched flavors, each a high-traffic, uncontrolled intersection, begging for an accident”—if that’s what your platform is supposed to be, you would excel by making the “existing comments” button take me straight to the “new post” screen.

Que what?

Okay okay, there’s a way to see the thread. (I figured it out.) You have to touch the text of the tweet. But I’m unable to teach myself that; I’m inexorably drawn to the reply bubble and that little number next to it.

Your Worst Fears Confirmed

In my dim gloamings I remember that that image of the chaotic intersection, full of loud, mismatched ideas, is just what so many people are saying Twitter is. I don’t remember it that way.

Twitter was, for a long time, just a place that made me laugh. I followed my friends, and it was the perfect venue for their one liners. We all tweeted about whatever seemed to be going on in our towns, or in popular culture. Originally, you couldn’t find a thread at all, so you didn’t worry about that. Quips were quips.

And wasn’t there a time when the threads were easy to find? (I can’t remember! Does anyone document that kind of cultural history: the history of the interfaces we were forced to endure?)

Now we have today’s shoot-first, read-later behavior, at least as far as that tempting little speech bubble is concerned. We hear rumblings of a conspiracy on the part of the execs: to stir the pot, to propagate a write-only medium, to revel in the chaos and the titillating engagement (the excellent ad money!) breathed out by those power-user provocateurs, the pop stars, activists, and presidents that all fuel up on feuds.

I don’t want to believe it. Everyone is good, we’re just lazy all the time—asleep at the wheel, asleep in the cockpit, sleep-walking at the pulpit and podium. We love sleep! Our Ativan is ad-money, melatonin our Moloch.

Therefore, let’s get hopped up on caffeine and tilt in to the adjacent martini-convo. Let’s read all the replies before the TWTR owners can stop us. Let’s shimmy all night in these splendiferous threads!!!!

--

--