Analysis: Dam Effects
Kendall Moyer
http://www.dameffects.org/index.html
This interactive website allows users to visually see the differences in a river before and after a poorly run hydro-electric dam and a well-run hydro-electric dam are put in place. The user can click on categories for the river from when it is natural, poorly run with hydro-electric power and well-run with hydro-electric power. The categories include riparian areas, fish passage, recreation, sediment and debris transport, and river flows. Users can click through each to see how they change based on the existence or non-existence of the dam, and whether it is a well implemented dam or not.
Get Dams and Globalization’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
In category one of the natural river, riparian areas, users learn that the riparian area of a free-flowing river system is the lands next to the waters. These are often extremely productive and biologically diverse due to the presence of water. Tree-lined banks provide shade, refuge, and hideouts for wildlife. Grassy wetlands filter the water and slow the river. The lands around the water act as a buffer to outside pollution. As for fish passage, we see that animal species can move upstream and downstream. Some fish, like salmon and eels, move great distances in their lifetime, while others that live permanently in the river still move around, finding cold water on hot days, or looking for food. Fish use extensive reaches of the river for habitat, contributing to ecosystem-wide diversity and the greater food chain. As far as recreation, free flowing rivers create opportunities for fishing, swimming, boating, and more. Sediment and debris, such as pebbles, branches, and sand move downstream under the force of flowing water and settle to form patches of diverse habitat. Fallen trees provide shelter. Submerged gravel beds make a home for insects and other creatures that form the base of the food chain, or provide a spawning ground for migratory fish. Finally, natural rivers flow down the first path they can find.
Next, users explore the area of poorly run hydro-electric dam. Riparian areas are destroyed in this area. The original riverbanks are underwater in a dammed river, so the riparian riverside lands are now functionally shoreline. Upstream, the shoreline is stripped as the reservoir water levels rise and fall. Downstream, unnatural changes in flow can erode banks or result in the growth of shrubs and trees in the riverbed. Erosion occurs much faster than in a natural river system because structural materials like wood and sediment are trapped behind the dam. These dams are created to provide power production and may not be safe for recreation during times of high electricity demands. Flat-water recreation can exist when safe, but access to the river is often reduced, and there are fewer wild fish populations. In dammed river, materials are blocked from traveling downstream. Material from eroded banks piled into the reservoir. Downstream, the river is starved of its natural materials and cannot provide habitat. As for fish passage, the river life is split into two, and the upstream and downstream populations no longer mix through the entire river. For migratory fish, dams block the way home. Resident fish are fragmented into isolated groups, reducing genetic diversity and range. This can lead to unhealthy inbreeding and population nosedives. River flows stop being natural under this system, and are instead determined by computers and plumbing systems that often reroute water, resulting in a river that is de-watered or even dry for miles.
Next, users explore how a well-run hydroelectric dam system looks. Here we see a reservoir with stable water levels to prevent erosion and to allow for swimming, fishing and boating. Dam owners can release scheduled flows in such a way that maximizes recreational opportunities. River flows can be improved using research that shows the essential ecological pieces of river flow like spring peak, drought and flood level. We can optimize flows for specific uses, like wildlife habitat. To mitigate for the sediment and debris loss downstream, dam owners can remove wood and large debris from the reservoir and place it downstream, or build up shoreline vegetation to stop erosion in the reservoir. A well run dam addresses its responsibility to abate pollution build-up in its reservoir, even by looking to reduce pollution upstream.
This website is very helpful in illustrating the differences between a poorly run dam and a well-run dam. It provides general guidelines for how a dam manager can mitigate the harmful effect of the dam. It does not suggest getting rid of dams, although it does illustrate the benefits of free-flowing, un-dammed rivers. Provides practical solutions to a large amount of the environmental issues created by dams.
etuI3��)






