Sitemap
Griffin Smith

Griffin Smith

My name is Griffin Smith and I am currently a senior at the UNH. I am from Concord, NH and I enjoy all New England Sports, fishing and golf.

Copyright’s Death Grip on Creativity

2 min readOct 15, 2014

This week we continued with the topic of copy and how copyright laws are as Lawrence Lessig puts it in his piece Remix: How Creativity is Strangled by Law (2013), “limiting” our creative nature. Lessig goes on to talk about a number of interesting ideas and concepts that are extremely relevant in today’s society and that the culture has been struggling with. Remixes have become a major part of artistic expression in our culture. The Act of Massively Regulating Every Creative Act is something that is negatively affecting people who enjoy remixing and mashing up videos and songs. Throughout the whole reading I was thinking to myself, there has to be some sort of happy medium that companies that own copyrights and the people who have found joy in altering these things can work out.

Get Griffin Smith’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

After reading the article and watching the video produced by Jonathan MacIntosh Buffy vs. Edward Remix, I was left with a sour taste in my mouth. Liongate (the copyright holder) had removed MacIntosh’s video multiple times from YouTube for supposed copyright infringement. MacIntosh had produced the video for pleasure and he was not making any money off the video, but it did have a substantial number of hits on YouTube (+3 million). Liongate then proceeded to starting selling ad space on the video and when the creator realized this, he filed an appeal with YouTube to eliminate this from happening. Jonathan MacIntosh’s YouTube account was later deleted for multiple copyright violations, whether they were visual or audiovisual it did not matter and he was shut off. I have a problem with Lionsgate in this particular instance because I feel that they are abusing their power. The creator of this remix altered/cut/edited both of the videos that are present in the short video and he was just trying to make a creative statement about modern vampire culture. I understand that Lionsgate owns the copyrights, but the video was not hurting anyone and it was not making any money (there were no ads until Lionsgate got involved). In Lawrence Lessig’s piece, he talks about how there has to be a happy-medium or mutual understanding between copyright owners and the public domain. Creative commons is one option that we might look into, but it will be interesting to see how this dilemma will play out because remixing and mashups are becoming ever more important in our society and culture.

--

--

Griffin Smith
Griffin Smith

Written by Griffin Smith

My name is Griffin Smith and I am currently a senior at the UNH. I am from Concord, NH and I enjoy all New England Sports, fishing and golf.