Sitemap
Hi_Hello

Hi_Hello

Shadowing

27 min readMay 2, 2024

--

When I was younger, I thought of old people as gentle and doddering — like manatees bumping off the side of an aquarium tank, floating among listless artificial sea grass.

This was when I thought about my elders at all, which wasn’t often. In college, in an uncharacteristic burst of filial piety — or probably just a remorseful morning with a hangover — I set up a recurring calendar invitation to call my grandmother, who lived alone. The calendar invite was for every 17 days, irregular enough that she’d never see a pattern and my calls would seem spontaneous and heartfelt. I told a boy I’d met on the dating apps, and he’d been impressed. So rad that you’re close with your grandma. He was earnest, and I felt ashamed. Close? We were not close. Although she’d watched me after school when I was small, she’d moved away and our visits since then had been infrequent.

But my own parents were in the midst of a divorce then; phone calls with them had turned into sour he-said-she-said affairs, then petered out. So when the calendar reminder would flash on my phone at 4PM every 17 days, Call Nana, I’d walk outside and dial my grandmother’s landline, one of the few numbers I still knew by heart as a kid. I’d get a dull jitter in my stomach as I left the library, grim study carrel smelling of sweat and mint gum that I chain-chewed.

Her answering machine would kick in first: hello, you’ve reached Nora, please leave a message after the beep, and when I’d say “Hi Nana, it’s me,” she’d pick up right away. I could picture her sitting next to the phone listening, which made me embarrassed for her.

Hello sweet pea! she’d say, her voice breathless with excitement. How are you. Great, I’d say. Always great. Her voice was always so filled with joy, a joy I didn’t inspire in anyone else those days. I’d rattle off some classes I was taking, a science lab, an english class, neutered of detail that I assumed she wouldn’t understand. I didn’t tell her about the slippery anonymous vertigo of knowing no one, of feeling accountable to no one. Getting Bs on essays from teachers who didn’t know my name. Eating greasy slices of pizza plopped straight onto the tray, no plate, in my dorm room bed, streaming a vampire TV show on my laptop. The boys whose confidence I chased, who left me feeling adrift. Those details I left out.

I’m so proud of you, she’d say. It’s so wonderful of you to call me. I love to hear your voice. This made me queasy. It would be easy for me to call her more often. I had nothing but free time. Loose plans that could be cancelled with one brief text. Classes I shirked. But yes, I’d tell her, college was so busy.

I rarely asked for details of her life. As lonely as I was at that time, I didn’t have room to hold more of her loneliness. She’d tell me anyway, about the handyman coming in three weeks and exactly what she was going to tell him about the bathroom drain. How they’d stopped stocking her favorite brand of blueberry jelly at the grocery store. How the mailman had told her that a neighbor’s dog would be euthanized for biting, how she’d seen the dog out the window so maybe he hadn’t. I found myself staring off into space while she talked. Mmhm, I’d say, and then some banal reply — isn’t that terrible. Then I’d say “I have to go, Nana” and she’d say “Oh, don’t let me keep you, you must be awfully busy. Don’t forget how much I love you.” And I’d hang up the phone and stare off into space some more.

Our conversations were stilted, surface-level. Why did I continue them? Out of obligation, and also maybe I enjoyed the ritual of performing normalcy. Faking it had fallen out of fashion in the 1950s it seemed. Now it was all authenticity and candor. What was so wrong about a little secret sadness, about pretending things were fine and getting to feel for a few moments that they were. Especially to a person who loved you so much for no reason.

When Nana died suddenly at 77 of a stroke, I flew to Indiana for her funeral. My mom was there, and a few of the older Catholics from town. These were the parishioners who showed up dutifully for any funeral, I sensed. The church had pulled a temporary wall to cordon off the rear of the hall, so that people would consolidate in the front and the pews wouldn’t look so empty. They still looked empty.

Nora was a gentle soul, said the priest. She treaded lightly on the planet. Afterwards there were store bought cookies, more than we needed for the people attending. I grabbed six off the plate and ate them in fast succession, just to make the plate look less full.

And I wondered if it was true, that she’d treaded lightly on the planet. I actually had no idea. Certainly the priest didn’t know himself; Nana hadn’t gone to church regularly. Maybe she was actually a bored, spiteful, angry person in her real life, away from her brief calls with me. Maybe she masturbated in her apartment to telenovelas. Maybe she had a gambling problem, or a long-distance boyfriend in the Dominican Republic. Or maybe she at least had some friends, some friends who she didn’t talk about to me. Maybe she wasn’t as lonely as she seemed.

I wouldn’t know, because I hadn’t really known her. Except that for reasons unexplainable, I had delighted her with my phony phone calls, and she that had loved me. That much I knew.

I couldn’t get back on the plane from Indianapolis fast enough.

Then one day, you wake up and discover you’re 77 yourself. Certifiably old. I do not feel like an aquarium manatee. I feel the same as I always have: a little scattered, every day a patchwork for should-haves and tomorrow-I’lls, punctuated by petty annoyances, small delights. The occasional event that tilts life out of orbit.

Some days I look down at my hands any they surprise me, like in a dream and my hands have turned into the hands of an old lady.

I spend a lot of my day with my own mind. I have friends, of course, but many friendships I’ve let lapse. Increasingly our conversations are about aches and pains. The pain I feel in my joints is mild compared to the scars of old grief; sometimes I feel like I’m floating over these conversations, like I’m already dead, looking down over their sweet small ailments. Then after the lunch, I feel exhausted, and the next time they reach out, I let myself forget to reply.

Many days, I have nowhere to be and nothing planned. I mop the kitchen floor, wait for it to dry, and then in woolen socks and a bathrobe I pad over to the kettle and start it boiling for tea. Read a book the old fashioned way, in print, on the porch. Watch the afternoon sun, my favorite time of day, but from inside the air conditioning.

Not today, though. Today is different. Today, my youngest, Ollie, is visiting from LA. He sent me a message on Christmas. I received it on my phone and watched it a few times in fast succession. At the start of the video, he stares into the camera and ruffles the front of his bangs, a gesture he’s done since he was small. His hair is receding on the side of his temples but the front is still long, which reminds me of when he was a baby and his hair first grew in.

I barely do video messages any more, he says into the camera, and then his eyes curl into a smile. But I know you won’t see if I contact you any other way. Merry Christmas. I’m busy this week but I’ll come see you early next month, okay? January 18th, I’ll be there around 10AM.

This is just like my Ollie. Reliable, agreeable, no fusses made on his account. I write it in my calendar. He confirms with another message two days before, but I know already he won’t have changed his plans. When Ollie says he’ll be there, he will.

For the last week, I’ve been leaving the doors and windows open to the warm spring air. Scrubbing the stove, the inside of the fridge, the surfaces in the bathroom. I hate the smell of old people, and how can I know if I have it myself now? Better to be sure. Last week, I went to the store to buy groceries. I cook only for myself, so I buy what I need each day with a quick to the store. But there’s nothing as unnerving as a clean empty fridge, so this time I fill my basket until it’s overflowing with cottage cheese, orange bell peppers, pineapple, fresh figs. I won’t be able to eat all this food before it spoils, but I want Ollie to feel like the house is alive.

I start the hot water boiling five minutes before ten, then sit on the couch, smoothing the blankets. I’d slept badly the night before. Dreams of Ollie at the backyard window, trying to talk to me through the glass pane but I can’t hear anything. I’m telling him to come through the door, but he smiles and shakes his head. Then the dream shifts, and it is my late husband at the window. He waves. Then again, and no, it is Jamie. I yell and reach through the window. My arm is bleeding with shards of glass, but he’s too far away. I shout again and start myself awake, the dream yell caught in a real groan in my mouth.

Ollie rings the doorbell at 10:01AM. I haven’t seen him in person in almost two years, although I talked to him virtually a few months ago. He looks gaunter, more tired, but still the same Ollie.

“Mama,” he says, and bends to hug me as I throw my arms around his neck.

“Oh my Ollie-o” I say to him, burying my face. My throat is tight. He’s so tall and smells of trees. He pats the back of my shoulders, pat pat pat, just like my husband used to, as if he’s not quite sure what to do with his arms in a hug, but then he holds on for awhile and lets me hug him.

Finally he pulls away. “I’m starving,” he says, and strides quickly across the kitchen floor still wearing his sneakers. I follow him and resist the urge to fix the collar tucked into his jacket. I’ve laid out a fruit platter, bagel fixings, eggs, a huge bowl of yogurt and granola.

“Jeez, it’s tidy in here,” he says. “We having guests over, or what?” I start to answer and then I turn to see he’s smiling. He knows he’s the guest.

“I’ve missed you,” I say.

He reaches out and grabs onto my hand. “I missed you too, Mom.”

We stand there for a minute, saying nothing. Then my eyes lower to our clasped hands and I do a double-take.

“Ollie, what the hell,” I yelp. I yank his hand up to get a closer look. He’s wearing a silver band, square-edged, etched with a wiggle of a wave. I look up and he is smiling, his cheeks the slightest hint of red.

“Is that a wedding ring?!?” I exclaim.

“Well, that didn’t take long, he says, eyes crinkling in the corners. The Ollie smile. “You’re not an easy lady to fool for long. I have some news…,” he tries to start but I drown him out with shrieks.

“You sneak!” I shout into his neck as I grab him into hug him again and he shoves me away playfully. He’s grinning and I shake his shoulders.

“Engagement!” he shouts over me. “It’s an engagement ring! I’m engaged. We aren’t married yet!”

“You didn’t even tell me you were dating someone!” I shout. “Who is she? Er, who are they!?” I correct myself quickly. (Habits die hard.) “And why didn’t you bring them here?”

“Her name is Anna, but slow down, slow down,” he laughs. “Let me make us something to eat and then I’ll tell you everything.” He’s smiling a little as he spoons parfait onto a plate. Ollie always delighted puckishly at holding back secrets, I remember. Something about being the youngest.

“Where are your glasses,” he asks as we sit down with plates, gesturing to my phone on the table.

“They make me dizzy to wear all day,” I say, pointing to their charging case on the piano. “I have to take breaks.”

Ollie smiles knowingly. I can tell he’s not fooled.

“But seriously, when’s the last time you wore them?”

“Probably a few weeks ago,” I admit. “I just can’t get the hang of it, Ollie. But I do like watching the Game of Thrones in Surround sitting on the deck at night.”

He shakes his head, laughing. “Do you use any of the Character features?”

I know what he’s talking about. With a few verbal prompts, I can watch extensions of Game of Thrones, or any TV show, on the glasses in any points of view, fully rendered. I want to live as Arya on an average day on the road. Let me watch the Red Wedding as a maid. I can act in the story, observe it, refine it if I don’t like how the plot is trending.

“No,” I admit to Ollie. No character features. “The renders of the people look real, but the sets don’t do it for me. The trees always look blurry when the people move. Plus, Ollie, there are almost three days of Game of Thrones episodes in the original series. I can’t even keep track of all the characters. I’m not sure I need any more points of view than that.”

I know how I sound saying it. I remember carefully showing my own mom about how to keep her iPhone charged, and about how to change the autoflip settings so she didn’t have to hold the phone sideways to text. But also, the end of college for me was when her Alzheimers got worse, so I often conflate her confusion with technology with her memory failing. It was a difficult time.

Ollie takes a bite of toast.

“It’s true that the natural imagery used to be pretty fuzzy on IOI40, but it’s improved a lot in the last few years, Mom. You should give it another try. And anyway, it’s more about the people.”

I shrug.

“How was Christmas?” I ask. “Were you with Anna?”

“Well, I was at physically in Echo Park, but yeah,” he says, “I spent Christmas with Anna, and then I also spent it with Dave and Jenna, and with the guys from Matilda & Sons. Jack found us some gig in an e-bar.”

“You played a gig!” I say, surpised and delighted. Dave was his college roommate, and Matilda & Sons was Ollie’s band from when he was living in New York after school. I took the train once into the city to see them perform, before most bars were fully remote. Some things change fast, but others not: maybe indie bands were the latter. Matilda & Sons had a dreamy sound that could’ve been from 80s, or the 2010s, or the 2040s. Ollie played bass, which I struggled to pick out from among the other snyth reverberations, but he looked so happy whenever he was playing music, so of course I’d loved the show. It had been so long since he’d talked about playing.

“Remind me how exactly that works, I said, stirring my tea and looking up at him. “Like, what exactly were you doing on Christmas. You were playing the bass? Or you were with Anna, or you were eating dinner with Dave and Jenna?”

I’d knew how IOI worked in theory, of course, and I had used the most basic version — just a 3D live video chat, with glasses on— to talk with Ollie a few times from LA. I’d even done an uninspiring free trial of a render. But I liked to hear Ollie explain things to me. Clear, direct, precise. When his dad had died of cancer eight years ago, Ollie had seamlessly taken over the duty of explaining.

“Well, I mean, as you know,” he sips his tea. “Renders are modeled versions of people. My two renders are trained on all of my digital interactions, conversations, videos. They look and talk like me. They are me. They’re expensive of course, maybe in a decade I can afford a third. But two keeps me busy. I can adjust how they behave actively, by taking over live control or by giving new guidelines — or I can just let them act on my behalf. Because they’re trained on everything I’ve done or said before, they’re remarkably consistent with how I’d act. Each day, I decide where I want to be, digitally moving between the renders, filling in with live control when I want to, or when the situation gets hairy or interesting, and then letting the model act autonomously otherwise.” He puts the tea down.

This I know, of course, but hearing it again I have to remind myself that this is not science fiction: it’s the present, the right now. My own son, living this life.

“So you, Ollie, on Christmas,” I persist. “You, not your renders. You were at home with your girlfriend? Fiancee. Anna.”

“I was at home, yes,” Ollie replies, looking down. “And some of the time, I was virtually playing the show with Matilda & Sons, on my real bass at home. But then when I got hungry, I let the render take over playing, and I went and ate some Chinese food takeout.”

I crack a smile. My husband‘s favorite holiday tradition was eating Chinese food takeout and watching Seinfeld on Christmas evening with the boys.

“For Dave and Jenna’s, none of us were live actually. They went to his in-laws cabin outside Santa Fe and the internet’s shit there. But we haven’t hung out much recently, and we want to keep up the Christmas tradition up, you know— so our renders had dinner, and we all watched the highlights later in first-person POV. We’ll all be up to speed on what’s going on in our lives when we hang out again next time.”

My head spun every time I thought about this: virtual models of ourselves, interacting seamlessly with rendered or real versions of other people. More interactions to feed increasingly life-like renders. A rendered interaction between friends on near equal footing with a true interaction. Watching yourself live parallel second, third, fourth real lives.

“Honestly, Olls,” I say as I reach for the sugar. “I just can’t imagine trusting a version of myself out there to act as me. A render that other people literally think is me. Don’t you constantly have to apologize for what they do, your renders, when you’re not live controlling them?”

Ollie smiles ruefully. “Well, I also have to clean up plenty of messes for things I do in person too,” he says, shrugging. “At least my renders follow guidance.”

“Anyway,” he continues diplomatically, “It’s not your fault your renders will never quite act realistically. You weren’t digital as early. They say that the training data from when you’re young, all those records from daycare, old phone videos, before they just put glasses on kids like they do now — I guess that early data is essential for a really robust simulation. The little-kid data is the secret sauce to predicting how you act as an adult.”

I picture baby Ollie. My husband was better at taking videos of him. I would lose myself in the live wonder of my sons —their skin, their sweet breath, their tiny fingernails — that I’d forget to pick up my phone. Ollie especially was so easy to be around, even as a baby. His long eyelashes, his giggle when you’d kiss his neck. He’d gaze up adoringly at you when you’d change his diaper, chirping and then laughing at his own coos, an infinite loop of laughs. He’d giggle at the adults’ jokes from my lap when we’d have a dinner party, looking back and forth for his cue to stop.

Not like Jamie. Jamie was so different. I swallow, waiting for the sick lurch like clockwork whenever I think of Jamie. But today, maybe because my real Ollie is sitting here beside me at the table, I’m able to think about him for a little longer than usual. Toddler Jamie with his blonde shock of hair and his wide grey eyes. He was always reserved, cautious. He’d turn away shyly when I caught him in a smile, embarrassed to be seen happy. He’d whimper instead of crying, trying to try to soothe himself first, fist in his mouth before finally letting out a single, plaintive little wail. And then when I’d pick him up to comfort him, he’d suck his thumb desperately, his little head pushed hard into my chest, gasping to get his breath back quickly. Ashamed to have needed anyone’s help.

Then, older. My two boys, Ollie and Jamie in the garage, taking apart old appliances together— an analog lawnmower, an electric mixer — in their dad’s work shop. Jaime, attention rapt, standing on a stepstool and carefully separating two wires, his mouth pressed in a thin line of concentration. Ollie watching him, waiting to scurry for a tool and place it gently on the work table beside him. Ollie always so bubbly and amiable, and Jamie brooding, but a wordless, peaceful equilibrium when they were together.

“Yes,” I say to Ollie finally. “I can imagine that early training data helps.”

Ollie continues eat as I ask him about his job, his cat. Then we fall into silence, him spooning fruit off his plate with a satisfied scrape. He’s jittering his knee against the table leg and twisting the spoon just slightly between his fingers.

“Ollie, the suspense,” I finally say. “I’m old and its killing me. Tell me about Anna! Who is she?? When did you meet her? What is she like?”

He takes a deep breath and looks up from his plate. He’s smiling but I can tell there’s something behind the smile. “You can ask her yourself. You’ll meet her today too,” he says finally. “She’s planning on it.”

“She’s coming here?!” I exclaim. Then I realize he means virtually, of course. “What are we waiting for? Is she free now?! Have her join us for breakfast! Let me reboot my glasses and make sure they’re working.” I hurry to the piano to grab them off their charger.

He takes a deep breath. “She’s free, yeah,” he says slowly. “But Ma. Um. There’s something you should know before you meet her.”

His tone gives me pause. I turn, and he’s looking at me, and I see now that he is nervous. Very. Unlike Ollie indeed. I sit back down, clutching the glasses, and touch his arm. “Olls,” I say carefully. “If Anna makes you happy, there’s nothing about her that I couldn’t like. You know that.”

He raises his eyes to look at me. A little pleading.

“Mom, about Anna … she’s … she’s not,” he pauses. “She’s not corporeal,” he says at last.

I tilt my head. Squint, confused.

“What do you mean, not corporeal?”

Get Hi_Hello’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

“Anna is …” he pauses and tries again. “She’s not embodied. She’s a fully rendered person,” he says quietly.

Silence.

I stare at him.

“Your fiancee? Anna? Anna is … she’s not a … she’s not human?”

He frowns. “I wouldn’t say it that way,” he replies quickly. “She’s trained on human data. She’s just not embodied.” That word again.

My brain feels syrupy, slow moving. Ollie continues, talking quickly now.

“It’s getting way more common, actually. People creating renders based on aggregated data from across many people, rather than from a single person. It makes sense, really — so much of our lives are rendered, why shouldn’t you fall in love with someone without an embodied counterpart. Of course, there’s the sense of touch,” at this he reddens slightly. “But there are other solutions. And they’re starting to pass some legal protections for marriages of embodied and rendered partners like us. On the West Coast at least. In my case, you know, with all my… my baggage, dating hasn’t been easy for me the last few years. But then when I started seeing Anna, it just … it felt easy.”

His baggage. My mind flashes to the last time I visited him in LA, after his dad’s death. My astonishment when I’d seen the back two rooms of his house stacked to the window sills with an assortment of items. Broken computers, guitars, disassembled toasters, grocery bags, VCRs. The pain in Ollie’s eyes when I’d asked him what it all was. If he needed help cleaning it out. “I can’t,” he’d said simply, helplessly. I wondered what his house looked like now. We hadn’t mentioned it again . What is there to ask? We all have our own ways of coping.

“But where… where did Anna come from, Ollie?” I hear myself say. “Who made her?”

He’s still not meeting my eyes fully, still rattling words off so quickly. “I mean, in any of these cases, someone has to pay IOI for the render. In Anna’s case, that’s me, of course. I pay for the compute power, and I tuned some of her initial starting personality attributes before we first met. And then some of them are tuned automatically based on what the system knows about me and my… ,” he trails off and reddens. “My preferences,” he finishes.

Tuned. The syrupy feeling in my head, like time moving honeyed and thick.

I can feel the heat rising into my chest, giving my throat an itch that I get when I feel anxious. I hear my voice, the words clumsy and harsher than I mean.

“Ollie, what are you saying? You … instantiated, created, whatever — you bought a fictional wife, customized her to make her exactly what you want, you’re paying a company to continue to see her? What does it that mean, Ollie? She, Anna, she’s … she’s not real?” I know how I sound, but the words are spilling out before I have a chance to catch them.

“She‘s real, Ma’,” he retorts, his cheeks still flushed, his voice rising a slight notch higher. “I set some of her initial variables, but after that her behavior is modeled, nothing that I’m doing. I re-tuned her after some of our first meetings but…” He stops, and his voice catches.

“For many mixed couples … couples like us, I mean. It’s customary that once we’re married, I won’t tune her any more. I give up my password to administrator controls on the site, as part of the marriage. I love her as she is, and it’s up to us to put in the effort to make the marriage work.” His voice cracks. “Like you and Dad. Like any other couple.”

I sit, frozen still, processing this, the glasses clutched in my hand. Ollie is breathing a little hard from talking fast. We sit and say nothing, me staring at him, eyes wide in confusion, Ollie looking at his feet.

I do not know what to say.

For so long, after so much death — Jamie’s, my husband’s — and then watching Ollie’s grief consume him, watching him retreat into rendered reality, like a third death. I’d given up any specific hopes for our family’s future. Better to focus on the tenuous present. I’d vaguely register weddings of friends’ children. They were kind enough not to invite me, probably imagining that they’d cause me pain. But they didn’t really — only gentle recognition of something I’d long ago hoped for, and now didn’t even let myself imagine.

I slowly uncross my arms and unfold the arm of the glasses.

“Let’s meet her then,” I say. Ollie looks up.

“You came all this way for me to meet her. Let’s meet Anna.” I’m shaking my head, subconscious astonishment. I put the glasses on. The frames whir against the bridge of my nose, and I watch the display boot up, subtle labels brightening to read over my thermostat (68ºF), my fire alarm (in need of new batteries), the door of my fridge (mayonnaise expiring in two days). I run my finger along them to dismiss the notifications.

“Ma, if you’re not ready, I understand…” he starts to say.

“It’s … it’s a lot to process,” I admit. “But if you’re happy, if … if you love Anna, Ollie. Then off course I want to meet her.”

He raises his eyebrows at me, over the frames of his glasses, and I nod firmly. He nods back slows, taps his glasses on, drums his fingers on the sides of the earpiece, and then with one blink, we both see Anna sitting at the empty chair next to him.

I startle every time, even though I’ve seen it before. IOI hasn’t quite solved the problem of smoothly walking with glasses on yet, but sitting, the augmented reality of renders is seamless. There she is, at our table, in the chair next to my son. Anna. She’s looking at Ollie expectantly.

My first impression is that she is old. Older than I would have expected at least; I’d had in my mind some kind of 20s femme bot, which maybe wasn’t giving Ollie enough credit. Anna looks 40, closer to Ollie’s age than I’ve been socialized to believe is beautiful. Thin, almost hollowed out. Her skin is weathered, and her hair is brittle, blonde-grey, like it’s been dried by the sun.

Which is a ridiculous thing to think, because Anna has never been to a beach. Anna is the output of a computer.

I stare at her, and she turns to stare back. She has a small smile, but it is careful, wary. She looks from me to Ollie, then back to me.

“Anna,” says Ollie. “This is my mother.”

I am fixed to my chair.

“It’s … it’s nice to meet you, Anna,” I say slowly.

Anna nods. A small smile.

“Ollie tells me you show your love with food,” she says wryly, gesturing back toward the kitchen. “I’m glad someone does that for him, since I can’t.

Ollie chuckles shyly. Anna has a low, flat voice that is familiar in a way I can’t place.

“I …” I begin.

How odd. What a strange, strange place the world becomes, if you live long enough to see it.

“I hear congratulations is in order,” I say finally. “I’m … so happy you’re happy. And …. you too, Anna.”

She has grey eyes, large and unreadable. They look familiar to me.

“I guess this is pretty weird for you,” Anna says quietly. “I get it.”

“I … don’t think you can possibly get it, exactly,” I retort dryly, with a short bark of a laugh. “But thank you?”

“Mom,” Ollie says.

“It’s ok,” says Anna, in that same low, impenetrable tone. “I’m not offended. I mean, you’re obviously right. I can’t understand, really.”

We all look at each other. Silence.

“Do you…” I start. “I’m sorry, I’m not trying to be rude, but I don’t know the rules are for talking to someone who’s not … not corporeal. Do you come programmed with a backstory, Anna? Can I ask you where you’re from?”

“Mom, you don’t have to say programmed— ,” Ollie says but Anna flicks her wrist in gentle dismissal.

“It’s fine,” she says evenly, almost indifferent. Why does her voice sound familiar to me? “Most people say treating us just as they would another person is easiest. I‘ve got memories, yes. To me they feel real.” She shrugs. “I obviously don’t know what your memories are like, so I can’t tell you they’re the same. But I’m from San Diego, I dunno. I grew up near the water. I’m a writer for a zine, fiction.” She shrugs again. “Pretty normal stuff. Human stuff.” She raises an eyebrow. Is it a joke? I can’t tell if she’s laughing at me.

“Anna’s an amazing writer,” offers Ollie.

“And Ollie’s an excellent hype man,” says Anna flatly, but then she smiles at him knowingly.

It’s eerie, her familiarity. Of course, I’ve never seen her before. But there’s something about her that seems so reminiscent of …

“Do I get to see pictures of you as a little kid,” says Anna, looking around at the kitchen. She swats at him coyly. “I bet you look the same.”

“No pictures,” says Ollie widening his eyes, and then he looks up at the wall. “Mom, Jesus, your smoke alarm’s had no battery for 7 months?!” Woops. I’d forgotten he has permissions on the devices in our home. He strides out of the room up the stairs, toward the cabinet where we keep the batteries, leaving me alone at the table with Anna.

I stare after Ollie’s footsteps, then back at my soon to be daughter in law. Silence. I swallow.

“Um. Well. What … what kind of stories do you write?” I say, mostly for Ollie’s benefit. I can’t believe I’m making small talk with a computer.

“Sad ones,” says Anna, apparently unmoved. “I’m writing about a trainer in the last Sea World, before they banned captive live animals. The feeling of putting down the last captive whale after they ran out of money.”

I wince. What masochistic beings we humans are, building computers that let us generate fictional pain. I hear Ollie rattling around in the closet upstairs.

“Your son. He’s really special. I’m lucky,” Anna says after a long pause. “We’re both lucky.” She reaches toward me, a clever optical illusion, her arm extending just far enough from me that I couldn’t reach it even if I tried. “And he’s lucky to have you too.”

This. It is too much. My teeth clench and I look up, hardening.

“This marriage,” I hiss, lowering my voice, quiet enough that Ollie won’t hear us from upstairs. “He’s committing to only be with you? He’s agreeing to a life where he can’t touch other humans? Real humans?”

She tightens her lips, and a shadow glances over her face. “I wish I could touch him,” she says quietly. “Obviously. Of course, they’re working on solutions. But for now, yes. That’s what marriage means. To us, anyway. ”

“That is completely insane, Anna,” I whisper. “And you know it. Or you would know it, if you were human. Which you are not. Ollie, he … he has such a big heart.” My voice turning into a ragged whisper. “He loves so much, he always has. There’s nothing to stop him from having a normal life. He’s grieving still, sure, and the … the keeping stuff, I guess.” I trail off. I cannot use the word hoarding. Too undignified for Ollie, my sweet Ollie. “But you don’t get it, he’s so much better than he was a few years ago. He’s playing music again. Please, Anna. Don’t let him do this. Humans need other humans.” It comes out short and desperate.

Anna lets me finish. Ollie calls down, something muffled from upstairs, but I do not reply. We stare at each other.

“He…” I start, barely audible, and now my voice cracks. “Ollie loves children. He was always good with kids. He could’ve been ….” I cannot finish the sentence. It is too far.

“If you love him,” I am still whispering, raspy, begging now. “Stop this, please. Convince him to call it off. Break up with him. I don’t care. Please, Anna.”

She says nothing. More muffled cabinets opening and closing upstairs. from upstairs.

Then, softly but clearly, still flat, she whispers back, “Ollie knows what he’s giving up. But he also knows what he’s getting. Humans love humans, but humans also leave each other. For Ollie, they’ve left.I won’t speak for him, but I don’t know if Ollie can survive any more leaving.”

Ollie’s bounding steps down the stairs. “I found the batteries,” he calls, swinging the package in his hand as he walks into the room. Anna turns to look up at him, and then suddenly, it is obvious. The recognition feels like a hand around my neck. I watch Ollie’s face light up, smiling at Anna, a laugh. “Double AAs, just like I like them.”

I rip the glasses off my face, drop them onto the table with the muffled clink of metal on wood. Ollie jolts to looks at me and back and forth to the empty chair where Anna was. “Wha — “ he starts. He looks at my face, startled. “Mom, what is it.” He sees my face, frowns, and looks back toward the chair.

“Why don’t you give us a minute, A”, he says to the empty chair and taps the corner of his glasses to power them down.

“You trained her on him?” I gasp. “On Jaime. You trained Anna on Jaime? The eyes. The way she talks, the way you can’t fluster her. It’s Jaime. What is this, Ollie. What are you doing. I don’t get it.”

His face winces like I’ve hit him. He curls up his fists into balls, then shakes his head.

“I didn’t,” he says sadly, shaking his head more firmly.

“You did,” I whisper, watching his face twist in pain. I can’t stop. My eyes are filling. “You must have. How else does she … the gestures. How else does she know.”

“I didn’t,” he repeats. “I probably would have if I could’ve, and you might’ve too, if you spent time with renders you would’ve thought of it too, but you can’t. It’s not legal. They passed laws early on that without consent, you can’t recreate a person after they’re gone. Their digital records are sealed. And you know how Jaime felt about the whole thing, renders. No way would he have consented to that. He hated it all.”

I think of Jaime, the last time I saw him. His jacket pulled tight against the mist in August, walking on the beach together in Southern California. Just as solemn and guarded as he’d always seemed, so unwilling to open even a crack into his thoughts to let others in. Except Ollie, maybe. Then, the call, while I was waiting in the parking lot outside the oncologist’s office for my husband, three months later. They hadn’t found a note, the police officer had explained, sounding wrecked on the phone. I’m so sorry for your loss, ma’am. I’m so sorry.

I’d driven straight to Jaime’s apartment, buzzing with a frantic prickling on my skin, before I called either Ollie or my husband to tell them. Cleaned savagely, like a person possessed, bleach smell burning acrid in my eyes. Touching every object in Jamie’s house over and over. Looking under every cushion, leafing through every piece of unopened mail. Certain that somewhere in the house I would find an explanation. Hours like that. Hours before I could bring myself, my whole body shaking, to dial my husbands number. I let him tell Ollie. I couldn’t do it myself.

“They call it shadowing,” Ollie says sadly. “It’s common, I guess. Synthetic renders, they ones you’re drawn to, they often resemble people, their gestures or their moods. They have the shadowing of someone you know. Or someone you knew.” He stands there, fists clenched, his big grown man shoulders hunched over. A tear trails miserably down his cheek. He looks like my husband, standing there. Years of shadowing in this house, stacks upon stacks of shadows. I can see my husband, bouncing Ollie to sleep, shhhh, shhhhhh Ollie-oh, lit up by the overhanging fluorescent light over the stove. Jamie in the doorway, watching them both silently, his thumb in his mouth. My husband and me, sitting at this table, his hand in mine, with nothing else to say. Our life, once a myriad of possibilities, narrowed to a single destination.

“Ollie,” I finally say to him. “Are you sure this is what you want?”

For an instant, I let myself imagine it differently. A different Ollie, a different shadow, standing in this same kitchen, a baby boy on his shoulder, shhhh, shhhhh. Handing the baby to me, this is grandma, she loves you, she loves you, smiling. A soft baby cheek. It could have been different. I would live it again, and again, and again, over and over. Even if it ended the same.

Ollie nods. He looks so uncertain, so alone. But I want so much to believe him. I stand up and wrap my arms around him, his hands pinned to his sides. We stand like that. Surrounded by shadows. Embodied.

--

--