Sitemap
IanHartsough

IanHartsough

Strategist, pianist, writer, golfer, cook. I have a complex about making things simple.

A Response to Ev Williams

2 min readApr 15, 2014

--

Mr. Williams:

I don’t know you. You don’t know me. But through the magic of this cool platform (and others) that you’ve built, I’ve come to know a little about you and keep reading what you have to say. Maybe, after this, we’ll start having a conversation…

I’m not sure your definition gets to the real essence of Social Media — opportunity.

You wrote that your definition for social media is:

“Media for which the consumer’s relationship with the creator is relevant for understanding or value.”

This is true for all media. It may be that more or less existing context provides increased or decreased meaning to a piece of content. However, that is not to say that there isn’t always some level of relationship — even if the people in question are strangers. Relationships aren’t had or not; they’re constantly in flux, constantly developing from the moment a person (user)’s eyes are open.

Get IanHartsough’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

And, that there is not always a 1:1 relationship with the reader or consumer isn’t really the deciding factor in whether any given media are social. For example, I’m writing this to you because a) I saw your content b) think you’re an interesting businessman c) you, as a brand and person, are a force with which I have a relationship by virtue of a and b.

Social media is about the opportunity
to connect.

Your criticism about companies not “being” social by being on so-called platforms is legitimate — especially given some of the gaffs that have happened in the past months and years. It remains true that companies are actively and authentically participating in social media (some better than others) just by being where social conversations are. When done honestly, brands who make an effort to speak the various platform-specific social languages of their consumers are, by even your definition, social. What carries them into being social is the commitment to engage with their customers honestly and openly.

The thing that feels most “social” about the media in question is a standing infrastructure to facilitate a conversation about and around content. Other forms of broadcast-style media have trouble doing the same conversational (social) work as content on natively social platforms — there is a lack of opportunity to connect with it iteratively. At the same time, they often provide more complete thoughts about ideas that are discussed in social settings and complement multiple pieces of content from that perspective.

Social is just one (important) part of the story.

That combination of media elements is what can help brands (and people with resources) tell a rich, complete and captivating story. That’s exciting to me, as a person in advertising. And, as someone who makes fantastic products for people to use, I would hope that would excite you, too, since stories, like our little exchange here, are the things that people discover and hold on to. Stories are what the best brands are made of.

Cheers,

Ian
@IanHartsough

--

--

IanHartsough
IanHartsough

Written by IanHartsough

Strategist, pianist, writer, golfer, cook. I have a complex about making things simple.