Measuring Knowledge in a
Games-Based Educational World
The weakest point of the ongoing game-based learning revolution is the challenge it has over the old educational method of measuring and grading the student’s knowledge.
While it is known that tests show mostly how the student is familiar with the material, and not their capabilities of using or memorizing what was taught in class, only a few educational systems have abandoned this old way of teaching, only delaying it to high school.
While I agree with this “no tests” educational view, and have almost no formal tests in my classes, I believe we must bridge between using games and formal tests, otherwise we will not be able to promote educational progress on a worldwide scale.
This is my 3-stage “bridging” system:
1. From iPad to Paper
As I see some progress in my class using games, I do this simple but extremely important action of taking pictures of game “stages”, printing them, and then giving it as class work. The students do not automatically recognize this as “work”.
Different perspectives seem to block their intuitive thinking, throwing them into insecurity, over logical thinking and thus, many mistakes. My students refer to it mostly as “un-erasable mistakes”, meaning unlike playing non digital games, when you make a mistake it stamps the page, and you can’t just start over so easily. It’s like being punished for every mistake and when you become afraid of mistakes, you stop believing in yourself.
However, as they get use to this system of crossing platforms, their intuition from the game is to revert to the paper work, and the results are very close.
2. Formalizing Game Knowledge
As we move from Gamification which is just a funnier class exercise, to game-based-learning, the knowledge does not come as a question or a puzzle, but as part of a bigger play.
Get iMagine machine’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
A good and basic example would be a problem such as “papering a game” like FIFA 2012. The enormous geographic knowledge that FIFA-soccer games posses over cities all over the world is unmatchable, but no game screen can be printed to work with in class.
What can be done ? Game-based-classwork.
In this example, I hand out papers to students and ask them to write 5 cities in 5 countries, matching flags to countries and cities, or homework to play the German league and learn 10 cities by heart for the next class plus a picture of them winning the championship.
Another exercise is a written contest for every class: who knows the most cities in a certain region.
When I develop my own educational games I create them together with a class worksheet which matches the game, but mostly I just need to create them myself to match the variety of games I use.
3. Test-like Class Work
A puzzle in a game, on paper, and in a test have different perspectives. Different and unknown perspectives hold back students’ intuition, putting them into a state of “shock”.
Therefore, after papering the game, my last stage is to familiarize my students with the test. I simply show an example test, and how it relates to class work, referring to a game they know and love. We try it together and individually until they get comfortable. Then, they are ready to take a formal test.
No matter how little time there is, never give a test, even if it’s exactly the same as a class work or a game puzzle, without familiarizing them with it, or you’ll be creating unnecessary obstacles for them and for the “game-based revolution”. These bridges do not take a lot of time, they are enjoyable for a class who is used to iPads and therefore excited by the diversity called “paper and pen”.
4. Bridge It and Share It — Conclusion
We are still far from having a large community who supports each other with materials which bridge technology to paper. Most of our work is still individual but step by step, we will make this game-based-learning reachable and useable for the common teacher and our old fashioned, yet still working educational systems.
Originally published at blog.thelandofvenn.com.






