Bye Bye Banks?
Silicon Valley is coming for banking and the result will be the biggest change in the history of the sector.
Marc Andreessen, founder of early web browser Netscape and a venture capitalist who has backed disruptive start-ups such as Airbnb, Buzzfeed, Coinbase and Earnest, has proclaimed “we can reinvent the entire thing”. What will the new competitive landscape look like and what will it mean for existing players?
In industries such as media and telco we’ve already seen the disruptive power of new technology. Driven particularly by the internet and mobile computing, barriers to entry have fallen, allowing well-capitalised entrepreneurs to join the market with nimble, customer focused companies. And so, what Buzzfeed has done to traditional media and Whatsapp has done to telcos, might Square, TransferWise and Venmo stand ready to do to the banking industry?
Get James Haycock’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Traditional banks are already dealing with plunging consumer trust, fines from regulators, a large and unwieldy governance structure and outdated technology platforms. Will their business models be “torn to shreds” by new market entrants as bank CEOs told EU Digital Commissioner Neelie Kroes at Davos this year or will they be able to reinvent themselves?
Could the immediate threat be of becoming ‘dumb pipes’, which has already happened to telcos. The arrival of broadband and, later, the iPhone made possible a slew of applications from Skype to Facebook to Apple’s iMessage all competing for services core to a telco, reducing the incumbents to simply transporting the data, with little control over it or the services it drives.
Some telcos have tried to respond by becoming ‘smart pipes’ — allowing app developers and businesses to create services using the network and becoming the centre of that ecosystem. Some in banking are already talking about responding the same way but this raises the question of what happens when new entrants or technologies start to attack the pipes themselves?
The pipes in this case might be the core activities of a bank — lending, investing, payments and money transfer. All these services are already being offered by the likes of Lending Club, Funding Circle, Nutmeg, Transfer Wise and Venmo. Even more fundamental though is technology such as crypto-currencies and the block chain that threatens to transform money itself — in other words, the thing that travels along those banking pipes.
Banks are currently benefitting from inertia among customers who have always had bank accounts and may be unlikely to shift. However, the generation coming of age today might not see a need for a traditional bank at all, just as they don’t see any reason to have a landline, send letters or buy newspapers. Banking cannot rely on incumbency to save it. The change is coming and the question is whether banking will be swept away by it or will choose to meet it by rethinking its operating model and even its business model.






