Sitemap
Jesse Cain

Jesse Cain

theatre producer :: writer :: political junkie

The original Eureka Flag, on display at the Museum of Australian Democracy at Eureka (Melbourne)

The case for an old Australian Flag

5 min readNov 24, 2014

We Australians are a funny old bunch. We have a cultural nervousness to public displays of overzealous patriotism (usually seen overseas), and yet there are few subject matters that seem to be more taboo outside of the local anarchist collective than whether we ought to change our flag.

In fact, there is more support for Australia becoming a republic, and that support is pretty low. As Dan Meagher from Deakin University put it, ‘The Australian flag may not engender the same kind of mystical reverence that its American counterpart evokes. Nevertheless it remains a potent, evocative and enduring symbol of Australian nationhood.’

It’s a fascinating paradox. We seem to take great pride in being an independent nation, punching above our weight in global affairs relative to our population and economy, but not so much lest we appear an upstart. We cautiously balance our relationships with the great powers of the age, and yet our national symbol distinctly and overtly ties us to another country, from another time.

Across the ditch, the New Zealand Prime Minister is leading a “national conversation” to change their country’s flag from its existing blue field with the Union Jack in the upper-left quarter and the red-starred Southern Cross — essentially, identical to the Australian flag, save the missing the Commonwealth Star and coloured constellation.

(Of course, a “national conversation” is usually code for “this is what we’re going to do, so get used to the idea.”)

John Key’s argument — which he is prepared to take to a referendum in 2016 — is that it would be ‘one more step in the evolution of modern New Zealand.’ His preferred design is the silver fern on a black field, a ubiquitous New Zealand symbol on the sporting field. Its colours would be unique amongst all other world flags, and would certainly and overwhelmingly resolve the most common complaint that their current flag is too easily confused with Australia’s.

It seems to me a step of confidence for New Zealand to take into the early years of the 21st century; just as in 1901, Australia looked to take its first tentative steps as a newly federated nation, by replacing Britain’s Union Jack with our own new flag.

And while New Zealand “has the conversation”, so too it seems an opportunity for Australia to question whether our current flag is an appropriate symbol to take our nation into the next 100 years. Is the ‘Blue Ensign’ still representative of the country, the culture, our past and our future?

I believe it isn’t. And I believe that we don’t have to create a new design in order to address these representations, as we already have one.

I believe the Eureka flag should be our national flag.

Get Jesse Cain’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

It is distinctly Australian: it references our place in the world with the venerable Southern Cross, certainly the most recognizable antipodean constellation; and yet does so without looking like other Pacific nation flags.

It features a strong, central star — symbolically resonant with the current “Commonwealth Star”, emblematic of Australia’s federated states and territories.

It is derivative of the Union Jack, retaining an echo of our historic links with Britain: our common systems of law, the Westminster system, our colonial past, and of course our language. By the same token, it also removes the overt presence of the Union Jack, and therefore the symbolism of being a subordinate nation.

All of this is before we even consider the context of the flag’s creation — the Eureka Stockade itself.

The Eureka flag was designed, sewn and first flown in 1854 in Ballarat, as a symbol of defiance during the Eureka rebellion on the gold fields. Miners protesting the unfair taxes being levied against them by the colonial power, pledged their allegiance to the “Southern Cross”. In the exchange of gunfire at the culmination of the rebellion on Bakery Hill, at least 22 miners and 6 soldiers died.

Yes, people died under that flag. Not as many as at Anzac Cove, or on the Kokoda Trail (though there is a complicating factor that our current national flag was rarely flown during those combats), but they fought and died and — whether they intended to or not — began to forge the same Australian identity that we recognize today: the land of the “fair-go”, freedom from oppression and tyranny, an egalitarian society.

And more than these subjective values and qualities, the Eureka Stockade was the event that led to many enduring rights of Australian citizens. Following the trials of the captured miners, the Victorian parliament was the first district in Australia to grant universal (white) male suffrage. Laws were passed implementing the secret ballot — a right that we take for granted today.

It’s a flag that should appeal to both conservative and progressive politics: it comes from a campaign for small government, entrepreneurialism, and individual rights; and a strong society, workers rights, and power in numbers.

Sadly, the Eureka flag is — fairly or unfairly — tainted with the implication of tyrant unions: it’s all too easy to find images of the emblem prominent on a belligerent protester. However, this is not all too different from our present flag being misappropriated during, for example, the Cronulla riots, or indeed at any sporting event or music festival when worn by aggressive “patriots”.

Just as we are indignant when our national flag is so desecrated, so too should be respond to the Eureka flag being misappropriated. It’s ironic too, and somewhat tragic, that in some minds the Eureka flag has become synonymous with thuggery and corruption, given the context in which the flag was first hoisted. It is one more reason why the rest of Australia ought to reclaim this significant symbol.

It’s a symbol that speaks to a nation independent in thought and action. It seeks the betterment of society and to provide fair opportunity for its citizens. And it suggests that these ideals can be achieved peacefully, but that we will not let authority take advantage of us.

Of course, I am but one voice in nation of 23 million, and every voice is entitled to their opinion. Some have called for the Aboriginal flag to become our national ensign. Others, indeed most, don’t see value in a change at all. But if we do change: before we look to the new; before a design competition that might yield “Australian Flag 2.0”; before the design-by-committee that produces a tacky design that wouldn’t look out of place in a kitsch Australian souvenir store, let’s look to our past to represent our future.

--

--

Jesse Cain
Jesse Cain

Written by Jesse Cain

theatre producer :: writer :: political junkie