The future of music listening?
Curated radio vs pay-for-play
Last night I went up to Cambridge for a conference/roundtable discussion on the future of the music industry, led by two very different tech startups. One was Martin Rigby, CEO of Psonar, who is betting heavily on the future of paid music listening being pay-per-play, and pricing his model at 1 penny per play; and the other was Mat Clayton, the CTO of MixCloud, a service offering curated radio and DJ sets, currently wildly popular within the EDM world.
Get John Merritt’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
It was very interesting to listen to both present their views on their opponents, as they view the industry differently and have tailored their products to solve different problems. MixCloud’s core audience are 18-25 with high levels of disposable income, and probably listen on an iPhone with high-speed data connections. Explaining his approach, Clayton claimed that the Pandora-style algorithms cannot discern between a harp and an electric guitar, and often the recommendations of friends are worthless if they don’t share the same music tastes. Psonar is targeting 12-25s who don’t have bank accounts or credit cards and therefore can’t use The Apple Store, Deezer, etc. Inversely to Spotify, they want to provide 10% of the world’s music to 90% of the population. The vast majority of music listeners listen to the Top 40 on repeat, and this is relatively cheap to provide. Credits for the service come out of your mobile phone top-up balance, and bundles start at a very accessible 50p.
Obviously, monetising the two products also requires separate approaches, and whilst MixCloud is enjoying success with brand tie-ins and non-intrusive display advertising, Psonar is looking to tie up with mobile operators who currently offer free Spotify/Deezer accounts with their premium smartphone contracts, as well as revenue from users paying into their credit accounts.
Psonar launched in 2013, whereas MixCloud has been online for nearly 5 years, so they are both at very different stages of development. Interestingly, they have negotiated differently with the four major labels (Psonar has a deal with Universal and is in the process of negotiating with the remaining three) which means that MixCloud cannot currently provide cached music to use offline, although Clayton dismissed it as ‘easy technology’, but Psonar have the opposite problem — they have licences but not the programming capability to rollout across the devices they support.
Coming at it from a firm technological background, Clayton explained that the data gleaned from users had the potential to be very useful to record labels, although he doubted their capability to use it effectively. They can map changes in users’ listening habits through the day, where artists should plan to tour to next, what days of the week or months of the year are best for releases, etc. Monetising this data could be a very profitable source of revenue for the EDM world, where releases come and go at a much faster pace than in other genres.
Having just secured £200,000 in seed funding from angel investors, Psonar will be an interesting one to watch in emerging markets in 2014.









