Sitemap

Top 9 Email Metrics You Should Be Measuring

7 min readAug 1, 2014

Most organizations, public or private, don’t need to be convinced of the importance of email or its impact in reaching key audiences and getting people to take action. However, not every organization knows how to best measure the results of its outreach or even what metrics are available. Although every organization’s goals and content are unique, there are some basic components you should be measuring to ensure your email communications are successful.

Below are nine metrics — some that you’ve likely heard of and some that you may not have — that you should be paying attention to.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Open rate is defined as the percentage of unique people who opened messages from the number of messages delivered (opened emails/delivered emails). Any analysis of your message will include open rate, but this metric is not the most important measurement to consider, especially because its tracking depends on the recipient allowing message images to be displayed (of note is Gmail’s recent change in automatically downloading images. Read more in this blog post). Build it into your tracking reports as a data point for your communications engagement strategy, but you shouldn’t make critical communication strategy decisions on open rate alone.

Best use: Comparing the open rate of one message to other messages that are sent to the same audience, especially when performing in A/B testing on subject lines.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Defined as the total number of messages opened, this metric helps tell the story of your messages’ scale. While helpful in depicting the complete reach of your content, this number is just a part of your message’s performance and should be used only in the context of its overall success story. Like a message’s open rate, this metric also depends on the recipient allowing message images to be displayed. Because of this, your message’s reach may actually be greater than what the total email opens calculates to.

Best use: Demonstrating broad interest in messages or subject lines.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Click rate is defined as the percentage of unique people who clicked links within a message out of the messages delivered (clicked links/delivered emails). When you’re analyzing what messages worked and which ones need to be refined, this is a great metric to consider. Since most emails are designed to encourage an action or drive a recipient to a piece of content on your website, the click rate is a good parameter for how impactful or engaging your message’s content is. Evaluate messages by the performance of different links, their placement in emails, and the wording used to entice recipients to interact with your message over the course of time.

Best use: Evaluating which links and content resonate the best with different audiences.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Defined as the total number of clicks your link or links received, this metric helps tell the story of how many times your message generated an interaction. Since this does not consider just one click per recipient for each link, it should only be used in conjunction with other metrics. It’s a good metric to keep in your back pocket when comparing the popularity of different links or content in message campaigns.

Get John RG Simpson’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Best use: Comparing overall popularity of links in your messages or in your outreach campaign.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Unsubscribe rate is the percentage change in those who have unsubscribed from your updates either by individual message or from month to month. People will naturally unsubscribe from your content each month so you shouldn’t obsess over bringing this metric to zero. Instead, track the growth or decrease in the monthly amount of people who unsubscribe over time so you have better insight into whether your messaging is still holding the attention of your subscribers. If you are worried about increases or abnormal changes in your unsubscribe rate, try to create more focused campaigns tailored to specific audiences rather than broader or more generic messages.

Best use: Flagging any high increase in your messages or outreach campaign’s unsubscribe rate and breaking down performance by each message.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Just as it sounds, this metric focuses on how many times your email was shared across other digital channels, such as social media. The easier you make it for your audience to share your message, the more often they will spread it through the other tools they regularly use. While your email system may already have a “share” tool included in its design, consider also developing a Twitter or Facebook action button to be embedded in the message itself to allow for recipients to share a pre-designed message or hash tag that leads back to your content with one click. Some outreach campaigns depend more on Shares more than others, depending on their content and goals, but this metric is always something that should be considered when reporting on the overall performance of your messaging.

Best use: Highlighting in messages where you have explicitly asked recipients to share your content

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Click-to-open rate is defined as the percentage of unique clicks compared to unique opens. Although any message’s open rate can vary because of image tracking, this is still one of the more telling metrics that you can use in determining the success of different messages. It can also reveal information or themes that may be missed by only paying attention to your links’ click rate. Outreach suffering from low popularity can still have high click-to-open rate, showing that the fault in these messages may be in your subject line or some of your selected audience, rather than your content itself.

Best use: Comparing a different message’s Click-to-open rate along with their audience, content, and number of links to discover patterns and trends

For government organizations looking at performance, Engagement Rate is one of the most important metrics you should be measuring. This represents a percentage of trackable recipients who were sent a message and opened or clicked on a link in that message. Some organizations define this metric is tracked over the previous 90 days. Engagement Rate adjusts for the public sector, showing how many of your subscribers are interacting with your content and responding to your communication efforts over time. It also considers that the information coming from government is timelier so messages such as alerts on closures or time-sensitive notices may not require a click-through to be considered successful. This is why Engagement Rate is a better parameter for the success of public organizations’ overall communications than other metrics.

Best use: Tracking engagement rate for your organization’s communications rather than individual message metrics to gain a more holistic view of communications success and help your organization develop its own communication best practices.

For most organizations, this is where the rubber really hits the road. Conversion rate is a metric you can use to show how your messages have driven stakeholder action. This can be anything from people downloading a resource from your website to signing up for a webinar to getting a flu shot. It’s important to keep in mind that a conversion rate is not influenced only by how well you’ve crafted your message or the images in your emails. If you are driving an online action with your message, your portal’s user experience and the relevancy of your site’s content can affect your conversion rate. With digital actions, if you’re struggling with how to track your conversion rate, tools like Google Analytics can help. If you’re engaging stakeholders with offline actions, such as making an emergency preparedness kit, you’ll need to be able to get that offline data and map it back to the messages used to drive those actions.

Best use: Comparing conversion rates of messages across different actions and content types to determine what is resonating with audiences and where there may be areas to drive greater engagement to meet mission or program goals.

There is no magic formula that will push your audience to take action. If your messaging isn’t compelling or your content isn’t relevant, no numbers and figures will help change that. But by measuring what you are doing today, you can use these results to help determine where you can improve, where you have been successful, what quantitative impact you have made, and what best practices to implement to better meet your program goals. Only by combining the results of all of your work into one complete picture will you be able to tell the story of your true communications impact.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
John RG Simpson
John RG Simpson

Written by John RG Simpson

Digital comms strategist, St. Louis Cardinals fan, aspiring coder, and basset hound apologist