Sitemap
Kelly Vedi

Kelly Vedi

Fair Play

2 min readMay 11, 2015

--

An argument against using ‘Fair Play’ to justify unethical tactics in politics.

Some people believe that politics is a game with its own rules. The normal rules of morality do not apply. If your opponent attacks you it is completely fair to attack them. This line of thinking is so common that much of our political language is sport metaphor. We talk about who is running, tight races, and winners and losers. And like in any game, you are allowed to act within the game in a way that is morally reprehensible outside the game. What players do on the football field is assault anywhere else.

If you think in this way then it is very easy to justify any number of tactics. Everyone involved is an adult. They’ve agreed to participate in the race. Smear campaigns and character assassinations are no different than laying a bomb in Mario Kart, giving your opponent something to handle while you try to take the lead.

This line of reasoning is attractive. It lets you use almost any tactic that you think will help you win. It is this very appeal that prompts closer scrutiny.

Under inspection the reasoning does not hold up. Arguing from analogy only works when the analogy holds across the important features of the comparison. Here’s why politics is not a game and therefore, why you can’t turn off normal moral rules.

1) In a fair game the players can be easily identified.

Get Kelly Vedi’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

2) They know what the rules are and willingly agree to abide by them.

3) They volunteer to play and don’t have to play if they don’t want to.[1]

In politics, there is disagreement on each of these. Let’s start with who the players even are.

Certainly the candidates are players. Probably most people would say that those who campaign are players. But what about people merely related to the candidates? What about voters? What about non-voting residents? If people do not even agree on who the players are, using a game schema is as dangerous as letting football players tackle anyone standing on the sideline.

Second, in a game everyone knows and agrees to the rules. Our conversation right now is evidence that the rules to this ‘game’ are not decided on. Certainly there are regulations around elections. But beyond these explicit rules there is wide disagreement on what is right and wrong when it comes to campaigning.

Finally, in a game you don’t have to play unless you want to. While it is true that no one is forced into running for office, because of the disagreement on who the ‘players’ are in politics, some people end up being attacked without running at all.

Politics is not a game, and it is time we all stopped treating it like one.

--

--