Sitemap
Kim Dailey

Kim Dailey

A Day in the Night at Mikey’s Late Night Slice

By Kim Dailey, Timothy McGarry and
Maddie Poedtke

15 min readDec 2, 2014

Eric Graef is “fucking tired.”

The 31-year-old had just finished his shift as general manager of Mikey’s Late Night Slice in Clintonville. He had finished his last shift at 4 a.m. and got home at 6 before the sun had even peaked over the horizon.

It’s now 4 p.m. and Eric is back at it again.

Mikey’s opens at 5, when most other businesses are starting to close, and Eric has arrived early to prepare.

He opens the door and trudges behind the L-shaped counter. The store doesn’t open for an hour, but a customer, a guy in his 20s, walks up to the door.

“No. No don’t do it,” Eric pleads toward the door.

The man opens the door, walks in and looks up at the menu above the counter.

“Hey, do you have any slices ready?”

“Nah, man, we won’t have any ready until 5,”

“Ah, OK. Thanks.” He walks out.

Eric crosses to the door, turns the lock emphatically, and examines the “Sorry, We’re Closed” sign that had been displayed outward.

“That’s readable, right?” Eric said, gesturing to the sign in Vannah White-fashion. “Like you can read this?”

Mikey’s Late Night Slice is a pizza parlor dedicated to staying open late and serving the hungry and—more often than not—drunk customers that frequent the local bar scene. Late Night Slice, though, is more than just a drunk food destination. Eric says that coming to Late Night Slice is an experience.

That experience can’t begin until the restaurant is prepped. Eric’s first task is to make pizzas for “the rack,” the metal platform from which employees dole out individual slices.

He walks to the kitchen, a journey of no more than 10 steps, and begins to spread fistfuls of flour over the 8-foot pizza prep table. He chats on and off as he begins to prepare his first pizza of the day.

“If you can’t make a fucking pizza you’re going to be a janitor for the rest of your life,” he says with a laugh as he spreads out the dough.

Eric has been making pizzas for a variety of restaurants for the last seven years, and his process is efficient. He takes a ball of dough and flattens it with a rolling pin before picking it up and tossing it clockwise. Once the dough has become an 18-inch circle he lays it on a metal pan, leaving an inch and a half of space between the dough and the edge of the pan. He may say anyone can make a pizza, but Eric also knows there is artistry in tossing the dough.

“You have to master it; it’s like art. I can’t paint worth shit but I can luckily do this.”

He spreads a ladleful of pizza sauce on the dough and adds a handful of cheese, taking his time to ensure the topping is even. He moves the pizza to the conveyor belt oven and starts the next one. He repeats the same sequence four times; the toppings are the only things that change. Cheese, plain-ass pepperoni, spicy-ass pepperoni, mushrooms, and the pizza of the week called “The Silence of the Buffalo Chickens.”

After the first five pizzas are cooked, Eric turns his attention to the day’s entertainment.

“Getting pretty dull in here,” he mutters as he turns on a Spotify playlist featuring songs from Quentin Tarantino films, and puts in DVD of “Edward Scissorhands.”

And then it was 5 p.m. Eric unlocks the front door as “Twisted Nerve” by Bernard Hermann dies down and the Minnie Riperton’s “Inside my Love” keys up. The first customers push through the door. Late Night Slice is open for business.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

The idea for late-night pizza came in 2009 when Mike Sorboro, the Mikey in Mikey’s, lamented a dearth of after-hours eating options in the rising hipster enclaves of Columbus. And he wanted something different than the standard drunk-food fare like White Castle or Waffle House.

His idea, a pizza by-the-slice restaurant that stayed open until the wee hours of the morning. They would offer up hot, sobering slices to the masses at convenient locations located near Columbus’ watering holes. The first Mikey’s Late Night Slice location was opened up in an old office space below Sorboro’s loft in the Short North area of Columbus and had a simple but lasting pledge.

Some information provided by Mikey’s Late Night Slice Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/latenightslice?ref=br_tf

That pledge, according to the company’s mission statement: “…to create and maintain a culture based around raving fans, dedicated employees, and quality food. All are welcome to experience our shops, as our shops will be an experience to visit. We will be a loyal partner to our communities and a fierce defender of what’s right. One Human Family. Pizza for all.”

The effort to make Mikey’s an experience is evident before even walking in the door. A window cling of a cartoon pizza slice with a maniacal screaming face adorns the front glass. Music or sports commentary blares, depending on the employee’s mood, and there’s always a movie playing on the overhead TV. Framed pictures of pizza photo shopped into various famous films such as Precious and The Shawshank Redemption adorn the walls.

The experience making is not limited to just the decorum. The employees also put effort into making a trip to Late Night Slice memorable.

“I like to fuck around with them a bit,” says Eric referring to the customers.

Practical jokes are not uncommon on a trip to Late Night Slice, whether its leading a customer into believing they ordered the wrong thing or dropping a stuffed spider from the ceiling down onto customers heads during Halloween. Anything to insure that going to Late Night Slice is a much different experience than that which you have at Domino’s or Pizza Hut.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

A man wearing a black polo shirt walks in, glancing up at the menu board hanging above the counter. Eric smiles, leaving the workbench and maneuvering around the boxes that pile up in front of the dishwashing station.

“Hey man how are you doing?” Eric says as he leans his body toward the customer, keeping himself up by his hands.

“Uh can I have two of them?” the man says, his finger poking at the plastic shield that separates the work area from the dining room floor.

“I’m sorry which one?” Eric says moving toward the tower more to see which one the man is indicating to.

“That one,”

“Oh so two of the spicy-ass pepperoni?” Eric says looking up at the man, who nods. “You got it man.”

Pulling the pizza off of the tower and sliding it onto a pizza slab, Eric takes a pizza cutter and slices through the pizza on the guided grooves on the slab.

“These slabs are made by a company up north,” Eric says tapping on the slab. “They actually specifically made these for us, which is nice because it allows us to have consistent slices.”

Picking up two slices, he puts them into the metal warmer that sits in between the slab and the rack, warming up the slices to temp.

“Can I get a grapefruit soda too?” The customer says after peering into the gas station-like refrigerators behind the counter.

“Yeah man totally,” Eric says as he opens the refrigerator door and pulls out a Faygo Grape soda and sets it on the counter.

Eric plugs everything into the iPad with a Square card reader attached to it, which is mounted on the counter on a swivel metal frame that allows customers who pay with credit cards to sign for their bill and add a tip if they choose to.

“That’ll be $7,” Eric says looking up at the customer, who looks down at the soda can.

“I wanted grapefruit,” he says looking back at Eric, who responds by taking the soda can back to the fridge.

“I’m sorry man, I thought you wanted grape,” Eric says keeping the fridge door open with his back. “Which one do you want?”

“That one,” the customer says, pointing his finger across the shield to the yellow canned Faygo drink.

“The mango one?” Eric says pulling it out from the rack, another can to slide into replace it.

“Yeah I’m sorry,” The customer said shaking his head, causing his frizzled hair to bounce around in response. “The picture on the can kind of looked like a grapefruit.”

Eric slides his card through the card reader, slides the slices onto paper plates, and then packages the plates into a wax bag, handing everything to his customer after telling him to have a great day. He returns to the counter, where he looks at the book “How to Win Friends and Influence People” by Dave Carneigie sitting next to the register. He picks it up and inspects it, giving a sideways smile.

“At our Tuesday meeting, we were given these to help better motivate our employees to follow our mission statement,” Eric says as he takes the book from one hand and smacks it into the other. “I haven’t read it yet, but I got the book-on-tape for it.”

Press enter or click to view image in full size

“Sometimes it feels like a bee’s nest in here,” Eric says.

During any given shift, the two or three employees work without direction. Paul, thin and with a wiry 6-foot-4 frame to go along with his curly red hair tied in a bun, mans the prep station. Wes, a 5-foot-11 young man with big brown eyes and a boyish face that contrasts with his military background, pre-packs toppings. Drew, the newest employee, is the jack of all trades — emptying trashcans, breaking down boxes, grabbing items from the fridge.

“I like it how they all come in and instantly work,” Eric says. “I don’t have to say anything. They’re all adults, they have responsibilities. I don’t need to have a helicopter fly over head.”

Get Kim Dailey’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

“That’s the dream team right there,” he adds as he turns to a customer. “What are we having today?

Drew, with short brown hair and tattoo sleeves filled with skulls, stars and the Liberty Bell that run wrist to elbow, finally gets the chance to make a pizza. His pizza making skills are novice compared to his coworkers, he still to refer to the cheat sheets hung along the lids of the pizza prep table. After saucing a pizza, Eric steps in beside him.

“Remember it’s got to be to the edge,” he says tracing his finger above and around the edge of the dough. Drew nods sternly twice and grabs the saucing ladle to fix his work. In his defense, this is only his second week.

A woman in her early 30s walks into the shop, wearing heavy red lipstick and a khaki colored sunhat.

“Hi can I get a slice of whatever will make someone sober,” she says with slurred speech. “Nah I just need some cheese.”

“Aw I thought you said you needed something to sober you up,” Drew laughs.

“Nah it’s for someone else,” The woman says getting out her wallet. “Ugh, I hate babysitting.”

She opens up her wallet, no cash is inside.

“Fuck,” she exclaims. “Oh fuck. Hold on. My car is at Ace of Cups. I just gotta- I’ll be right back.”

“Ok, no problem,”

She walks out the door hurriedly, muttering another “fuck” under her breath after realizing she might not have cash in the car.

She returns minutes later with a credit card.

“I’m so sorry,” she says, slopping her purse on the counter.

“Hey it’s ok,” Drew reassures with his hands up. “You’re just being a nice friend.”

“I hate babysitting,” she repeats.

“Man with attitude like that, you’d make a bad preschool teacher,”

Press enter or click to view image in full size

While Mikey’s Late Night Slice prides itself on providing a unique experience for its customers, the managers of its various locations maintain that it is important that the experience of Mikey’s be open to anyone regardless of race, gender, and especially sexual orientation.

To that end, Mikey’s is very supportive of the LGBT community and makes an effort to create a pro-LGBT environment. Advertisements for various drag shows and Pride events populate the front window. Copies of Quorum Columbus Magazine, a magazine dedicated to engaging Columbus’ LGBTQA community, sit out on the counter for anyone to read. One of Late Night Slices most famous and popular concoctions, a spicy and tangy dip known only as “Slut Sauce” bares the image of Nina West, a transgender dancer and performer from the Columbus area, on the logo. The image features West’s face on one side without makeup and the other side dolled up in her Burlesque fashion.

“It used to be a photo of a guy’s butt,” Eric says. “It used to confuse a lot of guys. They’d be like ‘Oh man, whose butt is that?’ and when they’d find out, they’d be really uncomfortable.”

Across from the L-Shaped counter and work area, placed above the bar hang two black shirts, one with the Late Night Slice logo on one side, and the other shirt featuring the phrase “No slut sauce for you Mr. Homophobe.”

“Yeah that relates to what happened last year,” Eric explains, throwing his head towards the shirts as he begins to press some pizza dough on the floured-covered surface of his worktable before shaping it with a rolling pin. “There was this couple who were gay who were getting something from one of the food trucks we have. This guy behind them kept making fun of them, saying something about holding hands and what not. So after a while, the guy who was serving them was like ‘Get the fuck out of the line.’ And everyone kind of rallied around him and started booing the guy.”

Eric throws the half-gallon plastic bag that once housed the dough into one of the two trashcans to the right of the workbench along with his gloves. He laughs, remembering the moment he discussed prior, as he begins to swiftly stretch out the circle shaped dough above the counter with his hands.

“I mean, the guy had it coming,” Eric said, returning the dough to the work bench where he presses the edges of the circle onto the screen it sits on, which allows it to be cooked while being fed through the pizza oven behind him. “The guy lives in one of the most popularized gay cities. That and he was in the Short North- what did he expect?”

The incident helped Mikey’s gain a bit of fame in the LGBT community, especially with the Clintonville location being close to Bossy Grrl’s Pin-Up Joint and Rendezvous, a bar and hair salon respectively known for being accepting places for the community and where burlesque and transgendered people frequent and perform.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

It’s a Friday night in mid-October around 11:30 p.m., about two hours after the Columbus Blue Jackets game has ended. Eric and Paul are swamped with customers clamoring for slices. Eric mans the counter, striking up conversations with each patron; discussing music, football and plans for the night. Paul works silently, making pizzas as customers continue to file into the storefront. A line has formed inside the shop and out the door. When the crowd is small enough for the door to close, a wind rushes in as soon as the door opens with a jingle, blowing the customers hair about.

“Man it’s like the big bad wolf is out there,” Eric says as he swipes a customer’s card.

Eric and Paul will sell 567 slices of pizza over the course of the night although right now all they can focus on is on is helping the next eager customer.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
The amount of slices sold during this Friday night were around 4-inches higher than former NBA star Yao Ming when each slice was put into a 1-inch thick pizza box.

After waiting his turn in line a 30-year-old looking man walks up to the counter, followed by two ladies around the same age. The man is dressed in a red Calgary Flames hockey team baseball cap and jersey, displaying his team’s colors for the game that ended around 5 miles from Mikey’s Late Night Slice.

“Hey man, what’s going on?” Eric says to the man as he leans on the counter.

“Yeah, I ordered a pizza about 30 minutes ago?” the customer replies.

“Yeah, you got the olives and anchovies, right?” Eric says as he puts a hand on the pizza box. The customer’s face drops, a horrified expression to form in his bearded face. A few moments pass between him and Eric, where no words are exchanged and the only sound heard among the group is the two girls giggling at their male companion. Eric begins to chuckle, a smirk sliding into place on his face.

“I’m just playin’ with you man,” Eric says shaking his head. The customer opened the box slowly, just to be sure. Upon discovering seeing what he ordered, his face relaxes into a smile.

“You got me man,” the customer said with a playful finger waggle comfortable to take the box in his arms, the girls next to him continue giggling. “They say anchovies are supposed to be extinct by the year 3000.”

“I’m sure we’ll all be gone by then too,” Eric says with a snide smile.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Because of the nature of Mikey’s business, the shop experiences plenty of turnover as old employees move on and new employees are brought in rapidly. This means the hiring process at Mikey’s moves quickly.

“I looked over your resume and it looked pretty cool,” Eric says to Marcus, the stores latest prospective employee, an African-American teenager with short curly hair, during his interview to work at Mikey’s. It is an hour before Mikey’s opens and Eric is pressed for time.

“Honestly the hardest thing to know here is how to toss the dough, if you can do that you’ll be fine.”

The interview continues for another minute or so before Eric cuts it short “Are you available tomorrow around 2 o’clock?” he asks.

With a confirmation from Marcus, Eric thanks him for his time and directs him out the door so he can return to his task of prepping the restaurant. Hiring Marcus will help fill the void left by the last employee who unexpectedly quit and Eric needs to replace him as soon as possible in order to keep his head above water.

“Same shit, different day.”

Five weeks later at 3:01 a.m., Marcus promptly closes the door, delicately taking the open sign out of its holder and turning it around. No more pizzas will be sold for another 14 hours.

Marcus is taking inventory of what is in the restaurant, something that he has been putting off all night.

“I just didn’t feel like doing this today,” he says plugging in information for how many sodas are currently in the fridge.

Marcus pulls the cash from the drawer and counts it down, making sure it adds up to what the register says. Stacking it in $100 piles with a couple $20s, a few $10 bills, and a bunch of $5s of $1s, he bends down, reaching out to the safe underneath the counter.

His fingers linger over the buttons, then, in defeat, he pulls the safe’s code written on a scrap of paper from his wallet. He pulls a moneybag from it, stuffing the bills inside. He pulls a pad of deposit slips out of a draw underneath the register, writing today’s deposit for tomorrow. He lifts it off the pad, fighting with the slip as it staggeringly rips off the pad.

Looking at the rack, Marcus lets out a defeated laugh.

“I made too much tonight,” he says as he pulls them off one-by-one. “I guess I was a little hopeful we would get a late rush crowd.”

Taking the 14-gallon trashcan that sits underneath the counter, Marcus slides whole pizzas into the bag, shoving a meal’s worth into the already full bag.

“We’re allowed to take the pizzas home, but you get sick of it after a while.” he says as he judges if he can tie the bag together. “My roommates always want me to bring some. They think it’s the best.”

No use. The bag gets picked out of the trashcan to join the rest in the 32-gallon one in the front to be dumped outside.

At 3:45, Marcus is still at it, sweeping and mopping the floors, washing and drying the equipment and ensuring all of the ovens and fryer are turned off.

“I didn’t drink red bull until I started working here,” Marcus says. “I only drink one can while I’m here, but that’s sometimes like five or six days a week.”

A popular drink among the employees at the store, though some opt for a few quick shots at Ledo’s.

“Apparently it used to be pretty lax about being drunk on the clock,” Marcus says as he leans against the soda fridge. “Like, I heard where employees would have six packs with their managers back then. But it’s not so much like that now.

“I guess it’s ok if you can work while like that, but I’m not about to go and do that,” he adds.

Eight minutes shy of hitting 4 a.m., Marcus is finally done. The floors are cleaned. The food is packaged away. In another 12 hours, Late Night Slice will welcome its next employee. Hitting a sequence of light switches next to the door, the shop turns dark as Marcus handles the last bit of trash, tucking it under his arms as he heaves the large wooden door behind him. Mikey’s Late Night Slice is closed.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

--

--