The Reasons Why
Behind the question why we wanted to become dads was why we thought we had the right to do so.
When people ask me, “Why did you and your partner decide to become fathers?,” I like to say, “We were set up on a blind date in grad school, we got drunk, and 12-and-a-half years later we accidentally adopted a baby.” That usually shuts their inquisitive traps. Because—often—behind the question of why we would want to have a kid is why we think we have the right to have one.
It’s a funny question that I’m sure most bio families rarely consider. Ask a bio mom or bio dad, “Why did you have kids?,” and I’ll bet dollars for donuts that their responses would be rote. We’ve always wanted kids. We thought it was time. It’s what we’re supposed to do.
Try answering the same way if you’re an adoptive parent and chances are good that your answers would be deemed lacking. There must be some other reasons why. For adoptive parents like us, the level of scrutiny (from within and without) required to respond to a simple question like “why” is often fraught with peril. Desire is one thing, reason is another. People want to know, “What’s the reason why?”
Anyone who has gone through the adoption process can tell you that it is arduous and invasive. It takes a long time and necessitates the revelation of the most intimate details of virtually every aspect of your personal and professional life. I imagine that acquiring FBI clearance is less prying and somehow more pleasant. With adoption, the end game is that you (might) get a kid, but along the way, you are utterly exposed.
Get Kipp Jarecke-Cheng’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
The first question the adoption facilitator will ask you is, “Why?” Some aspiring parents will have carefully prepared statements, as if they’re responding to a court-ordered deposition or they’re in the final round of the Miss America pageant. Others, like me and my partner, will respond like smart alecks … because we are smart alecks. Either way, we’re screwed because there really is no legitimate, coherent response to “why.” It’s a trick question. The answer is simply “because.”
About midway through the adoption journey, the agency will invite wannabe adoptive parents to a Q&A with a family that has successfully gone through the process. Any doubts you might have had about going through with an adoption will be erased at this meeting. Under the buzzing fluorescent lights in a small conference room in a non-descript corporate office, you will sit among a dozen or so other childless couples as you all listen intently to adoptive parents who will recount the story of how they became a family. You’ll think, “What’s so special about these people?,” searching each word that anyone in the room says, hoping to find how you are the same as or different from them.
At some point, the happy parents will introduce their beautiful, smart, well-adjusted young son, who will be more interested in playing with his Spider-man toys than answering any of your banal questions. Still, you will listen in rapt attention to every word, watch every tiny gesture in the hope of discerning something—anything—that can help explain “why.”
You’ll imagine for a moment that one day in the (hopefully) near future you and your spouse will be the ones up there talking about your own adoption success story. You’ll size up the other striving couples in the room, taking mental notes about their strengths and weaknesses, and wonder where you’d rank in the competition (because you have no illusions that this supposedly innocuous meeting is—in fact—anything but a competition).
But in the meantime, you’ll just stare at that perfect kid with his mom and dad, and envy them—hate them, even—because they have something that you don’t yet have. It’s a cruel torture, like holding an AA meeting at a bar.
The one thing I can say about adoption that’s like childbirth is the forgetting. As soon as you hold your kid for the first time, you will immediately forget about the pain, the time, the screaming fights, the money, the heartache. You have your kid, and he’s the reason why.
People always say to us, “Your son is so lucky that you became his parents.” But they don’t know. Because we’re the lucky ones.
Originally published on Lazy Dad’s Guide to Everything.
Kipp Jarecke-Cheng writes about the joys and terrors of being a dad to his precocious seven-year-old son at Lazy Dad’s Guide to Everything. He occasionally writes about Millennials at MediaPost’s Engage: Gen Y.










