Why do artists hate to call their creation a product?
“Book writing should be approached in the same way; a company would launch a new product. And like most products, marketing is crucial for the success of book and authors”, said a panel member in a big literary fest recently.
“Excuse me. How can you refer to a book as a product”? Immediately retorted another big author, who was part of the same panel discussion. It was intriguing to see this kind of response from her and made me think- why do artists hate to call their creation a product?
While these conflicting thoughts of the authors made the debate lively ( not in the controversial way, in which literary fests are known for), the debate is a reflection of the wide chasm of thinking prevailing between commercial fiction authors (CFAs) and the literary fiction authors (LFAs). The differences are also shared by readers of both these genres of books. It is not uncommon to see the undeserved thrashing, which the likes of Chetan Bhagat get at many forums and online media and also to see the high ground which many literary authors seem to take when they refer to the commercial fiction authors.
Get Pankaj Korwar’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Let’s try to understand the reasons behind these two divergent stream of thoughts. Let us take the case of LFAs. With the leeway of generalization, it can be said that literary authors and many others in related areas like painting, journalism, hate to be called creators of products. This opposition to any idea comparing books or their other creations to a product is easy to contextualize. Products, as its broader understanding suggest, has multiple ownership of creation. In contrast, the complete ownership of a book by its author, or the ownership of an art by the artist would like to be unchallenged. Products have limited life cycle. They are fallible. They can be misfit. By connoting literary or other artistic work with a product, would be accepting the same temporariness which any product has. This is something which the creator would not like to happen to his creation and even if it happens in the real world, it is tough to admit. When a piece of work is called art, it escapes common criticism which can be subjected to products. So, by detesting being called a product, LFAs succeed in giving away the reigns of their creation to market dynamics.
Is there a downside to this belief of LFAs? As human psychology suggests, human beings do not have an internal value meter to measure the real worth of things. Many products suffer from this problem. Their acceptability is hampered on many occasions, where people fail to ascertain their real value. In the real world, demand pull, comparison with similar product, etc helps us greatly in ascertaining the value of something. That is how we decide our purchases or shape views about products. In the case of art or other literary work, by their very nature, it is difficult to measure the real value of the creation.
However, it will always be matter of debate, whether artists have benefited or have suffered because of these “non-value-ability” of their work. It can also be a subject of controversy, that whether this non value-ability gets propagated to safeguard art or the benefits of few artists- largely the big ones.
Now, let us try to understand the views of the other side- the Commercial Fiction Authors (CFAs). The idea that a book should be approached as a product, has a undertone of commercial and personal success strongly ingrained in the argument. After- all if the author spends so much effort in writing a book, gives up his/her career for writing, than its natural to expect commercial success and visibility. The other underlying argument is that even if the book is good, it remains undifferentiated than many other similar good books which competes for readers attention. So writing the book as product, keeping in mind what the prospective reader might want, and marketing it well like a product, seems to be a very good idea. But wait, this too can be argued. Let us look at what authors ( Robert H. Frank and Phillip J. Cook) of the book-“The Winner Take –All Society” has to say on this. The authors, has written extensively on the prevailing market norms and how the winner gets disproportionate returns of his real contribution. Consider the following excerpt from the book. “Book publishing is a lottery of the purest sort, with a handful of bestselling authors receiving More than $10 million per book while armies of equally talented writer earn next to nothing. Under these circumstances, author’s naturally jump at any chance to increase their visibility and sales”. As we are seeing in Indian context, that even in the case of commercial fiction authors, there is room for only few books at the top. The best sellers will only be those 5-7 authors. In this scenario, does chasing commercial success in such a winner- take — all society, a good idea? Or, creating things for the long tail, a more viable route?
Also, aren’t’ these divergent thoughts complementing each other? Does the existence of undifferentiated successful, commercial work make real art look more important? I don’t have an answer yet. Well, let me first create something.









