Sitemap

Happiness by Design Report: The Apple Watch

--

**For best viewing experience please follow this link**

What is the best gift you have ever received?

Money? You could buy anything with it; unlimited choices!

No? .. You don’t remember what you bought with it…

So what’s the best “real” gift you ever received? Probably one that was given with love and passion by someone who cared about you; a thoughtful gift.

You didn’t have any decision to make; someone else did the processing for you while having your best interests at heart.

Do you see where I’m going with this? If you are a designer or involved in design processes, you might have guessed already.

The designer’s best work is when you feel that someone took the right decisions for your best interests .

Happiness by design: The Designer’s mission

As designers, we face many challenges and obstacles that move us away from our intended vision. However, we can make a difference, by keeping our focus on the true problem. It is easy to dismiss a detail when you are deep in the development and pressured to meet a deadline.

Without a good step back, it is common to miss the big picture; Am I creating value that can bring happiness by design?

Happiness by Design Report: The purpose

As mentioned in 6 Design Values to create happiness by design, the ultimate goal is to enhance human life. The Happiness by Design Report is giving us the opportunity to evaluate products, services and apps that are thriving to have a positive impact on our lives and see how they compare to those 6 Design Values.

Most importantly, it gives us a chance to see if those creations have a real impact on our happiness.

To kick things off, let’s jump in directly and evaluate one of the hot topics of this fall; let’s have a different look at the famous Apple Watch.

The Apple Watch

This watch does not need an introduction. For years, everyone was waiting to see what would come out of Cupertino in the wearable market. We are aware that the market is in expansion, and we all see the big promise; wearables will change the way we interact with our surroundings and has the potential to greatly enhance our lives.

The big question remains: Will the Apple Watch answer a true need and enhance our lives?

Mr. Ive quoted:

“Obviously, you’re not going to read ‘War and Peace’ on your wrist. But for lightweight interactions, for casual glancing, it’s absolutely fabulous. And I think this is the beginning of a very important category. With every bone in my body, I know this is an important category, and this is the right place to wear it.”

This is my favorite statement from Mr. Ive on the Apple Watch. He’s laying out the foundation for the real use of a wearable. He knows the limitations. He knows the advantages as well. He understands where the value is. It confirms he has the right vision for the product. Now, how will Apple translate this vision into the right product.

We will refer to this quote later in the article to see if the launch preview of the watch answers this vision.

The Reviews

Everyone has done its hands-on/review. Everyone has his opinion. Let’s look at some of those statements:

  • “Probably one of the best smartwatches on the market — but still not enough to convince us this is a real category.” — Techradar
  • “The Apple Watch was underwhelming, but its use of haptic feedback may finally justify the smartwatch category.” — Evan Dashevsky PC Mag
  • “The Apple Watch will enter the same skeptical marketplace, with an even harder case to make: If it’s essentially a dedicated smartphone accessory, is it just a redundant gadget? A lot of people might wonder why they need it.” — Editor’s CNet
  • “The bottom line is that I’m still not satisfied that Apple is delivering something with the Apple Watch that is really going to make my life better, to the tune of $350 or ,” — Peter Cohen iMore

As you can see, so far the reviews are mixed. Some of us think it’s the best watch that we’ve seen so far, some others don’t see where the real value is. Let’s see how the Apple Watch can create Happiness by design .

Apple Watch: Happiness by design features

What are the best/innovative promised features that will enhance my life?

Haptic feedback

As mentioned in this article, the apple watch gives us a glance at the future of Haptic UI interaction.

Heartbeat & Tap

One of the biggest irritant in SMS and emails conversation is that you can’t quite grasp specific emotions in the message. These sorts of communications lead to a whole world of interpretation, especially since each and every one of us see and interpret things differently depending on context. This gap can end up causing unwanted situations or miscommunications that lead to potential problems.

So how can we translate more emotions into an SMS? Apple is slowing giving us hints at a partial answer with the promising haptic feedback on the watch. Let them feel how you feel. Strong taps could eventually mean that you’re somewhat angry or experiencing an intense moment depending on the context.

Those vibrations on your wrist will add life to a simple SMS; your heart is jumping for your loved one, send her how you feel.

It will be in the hands of third party apps to explore this feature as much as possible to enhance the user’s overall experience.

Heartbeat feature — Apple Watch

Walkie-talkie feature

We started to see the Audio recording as part of the iMessage application. Since I discovered that, I can’t stress enough how much fun I had with this feature.

What is a better way to make someone smile, than quickly sending them a message with the sound of your voice .

You don’t have to call your voicemail, wait for the lady to present you the different options, enter a password and finally hearing a “Call me back please…”.

Why go through those steps when you can just say; Hey You!

Taking the same concept but applying it to the watch is a great way to enhance communications between Apple Watch owners. We’ll have fun with that one for sure! Hopefully, it will eventually be integrated/compatible with other communicating system.

Walkie-Talkie — Apple Watch

Luxury craftsmanship

Apple did it again. Their unparalleled supremacy in the tech manufacturing world is still very present. They demonstrate once again they can craft an object with precision and attention to details while preserving the vision.

Here are the winners*:

  • Seamless curved screen transitions between rounded watch case and glass
  • Minimal split lines for interchangeable bands
  • Dial ring detailed pattern
  • Back housing integrated heartbeat sensors
  • Overall seamless housing (no splits except for screen and sensors)

Honorable mention to the various bracelet designs, as mentioned by @MKBHD. The market is going to be massive for 3rd party band manufacturer.

* Those statements are solely based on pictures seen online since I haven’t had the chance to handle one myself yet.

Apple Watch: Unhappiness risks

What are the risks foreseen that could cause frustration or unwanted behavior?

Too many choices

The Apple watch has introduced a big change of vision direction for Apple. There is no longer a one size fits all philosophy. We have seen it with the iPhones; we see it with the watch. Apple introduced a huge amount of different configuration for its watch. Gold, Rosegold, Stainless steel, Black Stainless, Aluminium, 38mm, 42mm, plastic bands, stainless bands, leather bands and we haven’t talked about colors of the bands.

Gone are the days where you had to decide between black or white .

You might think having more choices is better (remember the best gift you have received?), but I can tell you that for your happiness; it’ not.

Here is exactly why:

Barry Schwartz exposes the downfalls of having too many choices; affecting directly in a negative way your daily happiness.

Get Louis-Xavier Lavallee’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Moreover, as mentioned above, this is a big change in design philosophy for Apple.

Apple is showing signs that they are slowly falling in one of the three design evasions; Delegating.

In this brilliant comparison and analysis on design, we see that what use the be Apple’s unique characteristic that distinguished them from the pack was their ability to make decisions for the user.

The third design evasion: Delegating

The banner of “choice” is always good PR and may even be good product strategy for many companies. But it’s not design. Design means curating the choice for the consumer. As an analogy, giving someone birthday money instead of taking the time to choose a gift seems eminently logical — why limit the recipient’s choices? But the gifts we remember most fondly are seldom checks.

It seems that they are slowly giving more responsibilities to the user by giving them plenty of choices of hardware but also in the software with “customizable” screens/watch faces as seen in the picture below.

You may argue that a watch is something very personal as their slogan clearly states: Our most personal device yet. However, we can’t forget that regular watches are only made to be looked at, which is the simplest interaction you can have with an object. They don’t ask you to zoom in, rotate, swipe, select, glance and read an email.

Apple Watch — Customizable Watch

Not enough “ glancing”

Remember Ive’s quote? “[…]for casual glancing, it’s absolutely fabulous.[…]”

I am very skeptical when looking at those screens and state that Ive’s vision was fully respected. Especially looking at this interesting statement on their website, which left me quite perplex; Start on Apple watch continue on iPhone.

I wonder how long that will last?

Will you want to start an email on Apple watch; spend extra time on something that wasn’t purposely made for this?

In the end, if you want to send an email, you will use the fastest way possible which is clearly not by Apple Watch. Even Apple knows.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Apple Watch — Email transition

Too many interactive ways

We have recently seen the tip of the iceberg with the coming out of the developer Watch Kit. Hint: It looks complicated.

As highlighted by @TheVerge; long gone the days where you had an iPod roulette and an ok button. Here is a summary list of those future interactions:

  • Short Look
  • Long Look
  • Glances
  • Notification actions
  • Vertical swipes
  • Horizontal swipes
  • Edge swipes
  • Taps
  • “Taptic Engine” haptic feedback
  • Siri
  • Force Touch
  • Digital Crown scrolling
  • Digital Crown button
  • Single-click the side button to open Friends app
  • Double-click the side button to use Apple Pay by waving the watch at NFC reader

I’m pretty sure my mother will have a hard time figuring this out.

Battery life

Everyone is asking the question, and it might be one of the biggest make or break feature for the acceptance of such a device in our lives.

Apple Watch Happiness by Design Score

Happiness by design Report — Apple Watch

The Design Values breakdown

Simplicity

I don’t think my mom will be able to use it properly.

Tailored to your needs

Wearables are getting better, but the Graal is still up for grabs.

Design that works

It will work very well… for power users.

Understated Beauty

Hardware Well crafted, however somewhat bulky. User Interface While graphically fluid, lacking simplicity.

Design that last

The least durable timepiece? Hopefully, not…

Quality that makes a difference

Based on history, Apple is always near perfect execution.

The Perfect Wearable?

If you had to design a wearable today; What would be the 4 main features that you would want ? I have asked myself the same question and after long internal debate; here are the four features (with two “small” cheats) that would truly enhance my daily life.

  • Real-time healthcare data gathering and reactive device (heartbeat, blood flow, stress level, tracker, etc.) ; Alerts and automatic urgency calls/emitter when something is wrong Suggestion of lowering stress activities (with the accumulated data)
  • Direction based GPS device with haptic feedback (Powered by voice command software Siri/googolplex) ; Easy navigation through an unknown city without having to look down your wrist or phone, triggered by distinctive haptic touches.
  • Universal walkie-talkie (Powered by voice command software Siri/googolplex); I can quickly communicate with everyone i want
  • Long battery life (5–6 days) ; I keep the wearable on my wrist, not in my room charging.

You probably guessed that the two cheats are:

  • It needs to be independent; I don’t need another device on me to make it operational.
  • The voice command technology needs to be robust.

Maybe that’s why the wearable market isn’t there yet.

Looking back at those four features, what did you notice?

(Hint: maybe it doesn’t need an LCD screen…)

Let’s have the discussion @louisxavierl #HBDReport

Originally published at louisxavier.com on December 2, 2014.

--

--

Louis-Xavier Lavallee
Louis-Xavier Lavallee

Written by Louis-Xavier Lavallee

Private Jet Designer @Bombardier — Passionate by #luxury #branding #UX #UI. I believe in Happiness By Design — I’m a #Typography Padawan, aspiring Jedi.