Sitemap
Luc Weinbrecht

Luc Weinbrecht

BPM Consultant and Software Architect.⎮ // todo: add poetic, cool description 👨🏻‍💻 Blogging mainly on: https://blog.lwluc.dev/

Filter bubbles

3 min readDec 1, 2019

--

Are filter bubbles restricting our internet research?

A short recap on a presentation Anna Maier and I did to put your attention to the possible filtration happening during your internet research.

What are filter bubbles?

Press enter or click to view image in full size
filter bubbles visually explained
“The Internet is showing us what it thinks we want to see, but not necessarily what we need to see. Your filter bubble is your own personal, unique universe of information that you live in online.” (Pariser, 2011)

For each individual user in the World Wide Web, with the help of algorithms, individual profiles are created and based on this, information is displayed or delimited and pre-filtered. According to Eli Pariser, every user lives in his own “bubble”.

If you illustrate this with an example from a colleague of mine: If you follow a person with a political background on Twitter, from this point on, a large part of your twitter feed is politically enriched.

The effect of the filter bubbles is reinforced by the constructs of the confirmation bias and the echo chamber effect. Because of our confirmation bias, we are more inclined to information that correspond to our opinion than others. As a result, we already have an idea about the result of a search before we have even done a google search. The echo chamber effect describes the condition assuming us, that everyone thinks as we do, because in our filter bubble we only receive content that fits our opinion. We forget for short period of time that there exist other opinions.

Get Luc Weinbrecht’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Whether the construct of the filter bubble really exists in the digital world has not yet been scientifically proven. In a survey among colleagues (about 25 business informatics students), the following opinion emerged: 54% believe that filter bubbles exists or are found in our everyday life. 40% voted for nonexistence, the remaining ones are not sure.

Technical influences

Filter bubbles are caused by the following factors (a google example):

  • The search-history and our surfing behavior,
  • how recommendation systems work,
  • which user agents we use,
  • the location we’re in,
  • cookies,
  • personal data (gender, …) that is known about us,
  • documents in Google Drive,
  • and about 240 more signals.

Do filter bubbles empower their owners?

The opinion on the question whether the creator or owner of such an algorithm can enable power or limit society was quite clear among my colleagues: There is certainly power on the part of the creator or owner. This can also be clarified by the statement of former Google CEO Eric Emerson:

“We always know where you are. We know where you were. We know more or less what you think. “ — free translation of the German.

Reducing the impact of filter bubbles in your web search

Filter bubbles can not be completely avoided. Here are a few possibilities to reduce their influence:

  • Change the search engine and / or the browser,
  • use ad blockers to avoid tracking
  • use a VPN for “anonymous” surfing,
  • delete all website data regularly,
  • and consciously decide against pre-filtering measures.

Due to these measures, however, it is possible to leave most of your old filter bubbles, but doing so, you are likely sliding into new filter bubbles. It is therefore advisable to search in different ways with different media on the Internet to escape these influences.

Reading this blog post you may find yourself in a new filter bubble or expanding your existing one: By writing this blog post and preparing the presentation we did, we may build a new filter bubble due to our confirmation bias. Because if someone else had given this talk or written this post, the main point might not have been to put your attention towards filter bubbles.

If you want to have a look at a presentation and the results of the poll about filter bubbles check your Slides (they are in german). The Ted Talk of Eli Pariser about filter bubbles is also very clear and interesting.

--

--

Luc Weinbrecht
Luc Weinbrecht

Written by Luc Weinbrecht

BPM Consultant and Software Architect.⎮ // todo: add poetic, cool description 👨🏻‍💻 Blogging mainly on: https://blog.lwluc.dev/