Regarding Scottish Independence and the Divorce Metaphor
My father was a family lawyer, and as a kid I occasionally clerked for him. A secretary from another office once stopped me in the middle of doing business to say “I just want you to know: your Dad, he’s one of the good guys.” And I believe this was true. Others have said similar things…never quite so explicitly. What was it that made him a “good guy”?
He summed it up for me one day when he explained how he interpreted the core mission of a lawyer, “zealous representation of your client,” and what it meant to him. Lawyers, like medieval knights battling for their damsels, are supposed to zealously represent their clients; but my father suggested that zealous representation didn’t have to mean pinning his opponent to a wall. “Zealous representation,” he explained, “means doing what’s best for your client. That’s not the same as getting everything they want.” In a divorce proceeding, the parties are emotional, bitter, vengeful. They fight with uncommon vitriol, determined to hurt a person they once loved, inclined not merely to inflict as much damage as possible but to convince themselves that every action is justified. It’s a natural emotional state when you feel cheated and besieged. That you might not actually want sole custody over the children might get lost in the need to “win.”
A better answer, my father contended, was to look for a solution that left everyone feeling “whole”. If an attorney offers a solution unacceptable to the other side, he said, if he knows it will be rejected, that’s not zealous representation. It simply means more time spent negotiating, more legal bills, more heartbreak for the parties, and probably extended litigation…possibly even follow-on litigation…as each side searches for something that feels like justice. It means each party will attempt to gouge out small victories so they can ameliorate some portion of their larger failure.
If, rather than seeking to pillage the opposition, an attorney enters the negotiation from the position of the best outcome for both parties, he fulfills to a far greater sense the notion of zealous representation. No one gets everything they want (parties rarely do in any case); instead, they settle. Consider what that word “settle” means. Certainly it means settling for less. It also means less upheaval, less heartache, less risk, less expenditure, less acrimony.
I want to suggest this as an object lesson for the current situation in Scotland, currently considering the referendum “Should Scotland be an independent country?” Having lived in both England and Scotland, having many friends on either side of the border, and on both sides of this debate, I have steadfastly maintained an “on the fence” attitude regarding this question. That doesn’t mean disinterest. Quite the opposite, I’ve become something of a news junkie on the Scotland plebiscite, and engaged repeatedly in discussion, mostly to urge calm, reasoned debate, and to discourage either side from caricaturing their opponents or resorting to wildly inaccurate statements.
Two interesting things occurred today that made me want to revise my position slightly. I still have no interest in picking or even suggesting the “right” answer for the people of Scotland. But these two events did prompt me to want to bring my father’s lessons on divorce to bear. The first was a new YouGov poll showing, for the first time, the Yes vote in the lead.
The second, and more important, was a statement from UK Chancellor George Osborne offering further devolved powers to Scotland in the event of a No vote.
Get Marc Tanenbaum’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
SNP representatives have lauded the poll and derided the offer as a bribe or a mark of desperation. They may be right on both counts. But J.K. Rowling tweeted this:
“I sincerely hope that the rumours in the Sunday papers that we are about to be offered Devo Max are true #bettertogether.” “Devo Max” is basically a version of the UK in which Scotland governs all its own affairs, with the exception of defense and foreign affairs. Originally, SNP leader Alex Salmond wanted Devo Max to be on the ballot, as an option alongside pure independence and simply leaving things as they are. Conservative PM David Cameron rejected the idea, presumably thinking that the starker choice would result in a certain No vote. But with the polls now showing a definite tightening and even a possible lead for Yes, it may be that the forces of the “No Thanks” campaign are reacting to the (hindsight 20/20 and all that) misguided wisdom of that strategy.
So consider Devo Max for a moment. It would mean Scotland was still subject to the Bank of England and the pound, but the SNP has indicated that it desires to remain tied to the pound anyway (the other parties have insisted this wouldn’t happen, though the future is always murky). It would mean Scotland involved in wars that its population didn’t support. It would also mean that Scotland would not be able to “stand as an equal among nations” as a popularly-repeated phrase goes. On the other hand, it would give Scotland the ability to control services and taxation locally. This would considerably blunt the domestic impact of UK governments elected that vary in temperament from the Scottish populace. It would protect the NHS and education, and allow the Scottish people to build a more socially democratic country, which it seems many (though hardly all) view as the actual intent of independence.
If the rumour J.K. Rowling points to is real, think about what that means. If Devo Max is in fact to be offered, it means the No camp has blinked and would rather cut a deal than play the game to the end. Put another way, ‘Yes’ camp, if Devo Max is the offer, you’ve won.
So the question is, what’s your next move? It’s tempting to want to make the final thrust, to pin your opponent to the wall and walk away. But since you don’t actually get to kill the other knight in this metaphor, you need to remember that the competition isn’t over, and still think several moves ahead. In fact, perhaps the best way to contemplate this metaphor is to think of yourself (if you’re a voter) not as the client, but as the attorney. You are an advocate for Scotland. What do you advise your client to do? Just as an overzealous attorney attempting to get too much for her client may lead to recrimination and further litigation in the future, so too dragging everything you want from the UK might be perceived as getting a bit greedy with your winning streak. It might lead to unpleasantness for years to come with a neighbour who is not going to go away.
I don’t urge you to vote No, particularly. You may feel that the issues surrounding foreign policy are more important. No one can tell you that a cry of “not in my name” is unimportant. You might believe that Scotland will be stronger, fairer, richer, what have you, as an independent country. As long as the people get their democratic say, I’m satisfied with the result.
What I do urge is that if Devo Max is proposed, you take that offer seriously, regardless of the motivation you think lies behind the offer. Allowing yourself to seriously entertain that concession might allow everyone to walk away feeling whole. And getting most of what you want might ultimately be a preferable answer for Scotland than getting all.







