Putin’s Lies
As a former KGB man, Vladimir Putin is quite comfortable lying. But lies impose limits. Especially if you believe your own lies. The fundamental problem with Putin’s war effort is that it is based on lies. Most problematic are the lies that Putin appears to be telling himself. Namely, Ukraine is not a nation, the west is weak, and Russia is capable of being a great empire. First, with an economy smaller than that of Canada, Russia is an unlikely empire. That is the first lie. Then, Putin believed that all he had to do was push the door open to Kyiv and the whole country would fall into his hands like ripe fruit. The invasion force was not set up for or prepared for a long struggle. They were set up for a dash into the capital, Kyiv, and takeover. But the dash turned into a quagmire. As the old paraphrase of Moltke goes, no plan survives contact with the enemy. Putin failed to consider his enemy.
Sun Tzu’s famous book begins with a chapter entitled “Estimates” for a reason. Knowing your enemy’s capabilities and intentions from the very start is the key to success in a conflict. It also helps to know your own. Putin didn’t just fail to consider what Ukraine and NATO would do in response, he lied to himself about his potential enemy, indulging in wishful thinking. He thought that the west was weak and that his energy blackmail gambit would be enough to keep NATO’s response minimal. He thought that Ukraine would greet his tanks with flowers. But Ukrainians want no return to Russian domination, no repeat of the Holodomor or the years of Soviet-style occupation. Instead of garlands, Ukrainians met his vaunted paratroopers with fierce resistance at Hostomel and elsewhere. His army broke down at the gates of Kyiv with a 30-mile-long column of vehicles stuck in a traffic jam. Ultimately, they failed, retreating back to Russia. So far from the quick imperial land grab, Putin found himself locked in a losing war with a determined enemy. He has managed to accomplish the impossible, galvanising NATO into total resistance and bringing neutral Sweden and Finland into the fold.
Get Mark Pullinger’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Putin told another lie to himself, that his military was invincible. He is not a military man, he is a spymaster. His defence chief, Shoigu, is also not a military professional. Like many of the rest of us, looking at his military on paper convinced him that he would win easily. The numbers looked pretty convincing. But contact with a determined opponent backed by powerful allies revealed how incompetent and unprepared the Russian military was. The Russian army it seems is plagued with breathtaking corruption at all levels. Units were ill-trained and ill-equipped. Weapons didn’t work. Communications utterly failed. Armoured vehicles broke down or ran out of gas. Truck tyres rotted off their wheels leaving frontline troops stranded without supplies.
Russia lied to their own soldiers, not telling them they were about to invade another country or what the plans were. Modern combat operations require close coordination and that every soldier knows their role. Russian soldiers were not even told they were about to invade another country. Not understanding the operational objectives of a mission means you are lost with no plan. Using doctrine that would be more at home in the Tsar’s army 150 years ago, Russia does not trust their soldiers enough to share operational details prior to a major engagement. They do not train exhaustively in realistic training as does NATO. Consequently, they were unprepared for the task ahead of them. Russian forces also lack a strong NCO corps, the backbone of modern armies. Again, this would require trust, allowing for the delegation of decisions to the tactical level, something that is considered essential by most modern armed forces. This contributes to a lack of discipline. When things go wrong, as they always do in war, Russian soldiers are incapable of making decisions. It’s not their job. So, what do they do? They run like a mob, stealing civilian clothes and bicycles to escape as quickly as possible. They also take out their frustrations on the local population.
The failure of phase 1 of the Ukraine war has put Russia in a difficult position, to say the least. What was supposed to happen was a quick war that would result in a lightening takeover of Ukraine, its industrial sector and natural resources, all while an impotent and paralysed NATO looked on in horror. Putin would be regarded as a great player on the world stage and Russia would be enriched and feared. Now Putin finds himself isolated on the international stage as demonstrated by last weekend’s SCO meeting in Samarkand, losing on the battlefield at Kyiv and Kharkiv, having his Black Sea fleet sunk or bottled up, his energy bluff called, his economy in peril from sanctions, and now facing a renewed and more powerful NATO. This is the exact opposite of what Putin was trying to accomplish in the first place. The great strategist might be a laughing stock if he was not so incredibly brutal.
Putin has left himself with some unenviable options. He could declare war and fully mobilise Russian society. That might be the only way for Russia to win militarily. But that creates its own problems. Putin has lied to his citizens that this is nothing more than a “special military operation.” They didn’t sign up for this. Life in Moscow has gone on much as it had before. Mobilisation would change this. Suddenly daily life for Russians would become very difficult. And a lot of young men and women would begin coming home in body bags. This could only result in the growing unpopularity of Putin and his regime. It could also result in a wider conflict with NATO. More likely, Putin could sit back and allow the stalemate to unfold in a grinding and bloody inconclusive conflict lasting years, hoping his foes would get tired and give in. That option is the easy way out but involves more self-deception. Putin has revealed himself to the world and it is unlikely that Ukraine and NATO are prepared to give in. And ceding the initiative has rarely won any wars. Putin would do well to stop lying to himself. Possibly, he should listen to Mr. Modi and Mr. Scholz and recognize the truth that there is no good way out. Perhaps Putin could be allowed one more lie: declare victory so he can leave Ukraine now before it’s too late.










