Sitemap
Marni Willms

Marni Willms

Soul traveler .. somewhere in that place considered “middle-age” .. always shifting, always growing .. forever in search of deeper meaning and deeper connection

This was fiction?? ……

6 min readSep 26, 2014

I read a short story this morning that was soul-touching. The writer tugged at my emotions in a very poignant way as he reflected on what was and what could have been while attending his ex-wife’s funeral. He succeeded in sucking me right into the moment.

And then I read the comments of other readers, most of whom had similar responses.

And then I read his response. The piece was fiction.

Why? Why did I experience a let-down? What made this story less inspiring to me once I realized it was fiction? Why did I have the thought going through my head that he MUST have experienced at least some of what is depicted in the story?

Why do I want it to be real? Is it because I thrive on the messiness of life? The highs, the lows and everything in between? The growth afforded by the unending lessons? If I had known going in that I was about to read fiction, would it have changed my perspective?

Don’t get me wrong. I love fiction. As I’ve begun to question myself about why I want to write and what inspires me to write, I have traced it all the way back to my childhood. I learned to read at an early age. I was reading fluently before entering kindergarten thanks to the loving attention of my pre-school teacher, the wonderful woman who eventually became my step-mom.

This makes me think of an interaction with my wife yesterday as she was laughing her head off over an article entitled “19 Unintentionally Disturbing Moments from Kids’ Books”. As she read the excerpt from my beloved “Dick and Jane” … “Look up, Baby. Look up and see Dick. See Dick go up. See Dick go up, up, up.” … I had to wonder if my mom had to suppress peals of laughter as I read this passage over and over. But I digress …

Where was I? Oh yes, fiction. As a young child and then all throughout my teenage years I was a voracious reader. The phrase “so many books, so little time” truly was my motto. Favorites in my early years included anything Nancy Drew, Hardy Boys or Bobbsey Twins, which then progressed to love affairs with Anne Shirley and Josephine March, then on to historical romances including a kinship with Scarlett O’Hara, leading to a foray into the epic fantasy realm of Robert Jordan’s Wheel of Time, and finally culminating with the medical and forensic thriller worlds of Robin Cook and Patricia Cornwell as I went through nursing school.

Get Marni Willms’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Of course, there was so much more in between. I never went anywhere without a book or two in my hands. After all, you never know when you’re going to have a chance to read. And if you finish one and still have time to read, you’re going to be awfully disappointed that you didn’t grab that second book.

Two things changed over those years.

First, I took an English Lit class in my first year of college. My professor was a short man from Brazil, Indiana – I’ll never forget that. (Brazil? There’s a town in Indiana with the name of a foreign country? Whaaat? Yes, I led a very sheltered life in small town southern Illinois.) One of my assignments during that semester was a research paper. The topic I chose was desertification. I worked so hard on that paper, following all of the MLA documentation standards as I typed it up on my sheik, portable Brother word processor. No doubt my hands were shaking as I proudly turned in my “masterpiece.”

I got a “C”. I think it was a + or a -, don’t really remember which. I was devastated. Seeing it marked up with red ink, the grade plastered across the top and the very matter-of-fact comments on the last page made my heart sink. I can feel my ears heating up as they turn red, even now. I was pretty much a straight A student in my little high school class of approximately 35 students. I wanted so badly to write. I took pride in excelling. I took pride in being at the top of the class. My naïve little college freshman world came crashing down. I wasn’t good enough. Because, after all, one must be perfect from the start, right? Practice? Who needs practice? Though I continued to journal sporadically, my dream had been crushed.

The next thing that completely changed the course of my life was realizing at the age of 25 that the reason I never clicked romantically with any of the men I dated was because I was attracted to women. Well, let me tell you … coming from an incredibly sheltered Midwestern small town, Methodist background, there was enough “messiness” to go ‘round and ‘round for years. Between that and starting my nursing career, I no longer had the need to read someone else’s fiction, or even real life account. I was living it. I pretty much stopped reading. And I lost myself along the way. Yes, even though I had discovered my true nature, I still managed to lose myself in both rebellion and the day-to-day drudgery of adulthood in the working world. But that’s a story for another day.

Over the last couple of years I have been on a journey back to “me.” I’ve kept a journal more religiously than ever before in my life. I’ve simplified my life to allow room for reading and creativity. I’ve found myself overcome by the giddiness of a renewed love affair with the written word. In reflecting on my past love affair, I now know that what attracted me to certain authors was their ability to sweep me up and take me to other worlds … ones in which I knew each character intimately and experienced their messiness on a visceral level. This is why I want to write. I want to take the reader to deeply emotional places outside of their everyday realm.

Many great authors have stated that in order to become better at writing, one must read AND write voraciously. After a time of being enamored with a particular genre and devouring writings of a precious few, I’ve now begun to venture out to other genres and the works of writers and bloggers with whom I’m unfamiliar. I’m discovering that the first-person account of events tends to be one of my favorite styles.

So why this sudden tightening in my chest after reading that this very intimate account of one man’s internal dialogue surrounding the passing of his ex-wife was fiction? A first person account can’t sweep the reader away unless it is based on life’s messiness that the author has experienced firsthand? Why did that feel so unauthentic to me in the moment? Especially when I have so thoroughly enjoyed fictitious tales that were written in first person format? Was it envy? Was it the old feeling of not being good enough to write fiction since I can’t even write a research paper? Along with, perhaps, the old pattern of thinking that things have to be perfect from the get go, rather than experiencing the blood, sweat and tears of hard work that is rejected over and over? That IS, after all, the messy part. Right? I’ve already come to the conclusion that “messy” is where it’s at … which includes ending a sentence with a preposition.

Therefore, I will follow the advice of those who have gone before me and make it a daily practice of both reading and writing. I will put myself, in all my messiness, out there in order to improve. And I will accept, with gratitude, any and all growth that may ensue as the result of reading the works of others, receiving constructive criticism, and the effort of “just doing it.” And if you’re still with me, reader, thanks for sticking it out. YOU are the one who will help me to improve. Peace on your path.

Now it is time to head over and tell that author how much I enjoyed his story.

--

--

Marni Willms
Marni Willms

Written by Marni Willms

Soul traveler .. somewhere in that place considered “middle-age” .. always shifting, always growing .. forever in search of deeper meaning and deeper connection