Staying Afloat
By Mason Bryan
I didn’t know how to respond when he told me he was tortured, and nothing has really been the same for me since. I was an intern for an English-speaking newspaper in Chile, and I knew about the darkness and dangers of our world in only a vague, distant way. A horrific truth changed that.
I grew up during the United States’ longest war, which surfaced as a momentary subject of personal interest at age 18. I felt somewhat ashamed of how little my peers and I knew about why we were in the Middle East, what purpose the war served, who we were even fighting. But it was never really about that. As high school came to an end, I began to understand the social benefits of appearing smart and thoughtful. My newfound awareness was not entirely vain, mind you; I did recognize that striving to understand Things That Matter had some inherent value. And at 18, what mattered was the war in Iraq.
This was 2010. Many people then had come to accept that we invaded Iraq for the wrong reasons. So, when I set out to write a brief history of this war for my high school newspaper, it wasn’t terribly complicated piecing together the narrative. I had figured out why we were there, and that we had gotten it wrong. Having spent nearly a month researching the topic, I took great pride in my story. My byline gleamed on the page.
It shocked me when a close friend called my articled biased. What do you mean, biased? I was hurt and embarrassed. If I hadn’t convinced him, I had just wasted a month, and, worst of all, I looked dumb.
That of course happened before I understood that personal politics predispose us to believe and reject facts as long as it maintains our peace of mind. Sure, many people who opposed the Iraq war and predicted its failure did so because of ideology, because Bush was just after oil, or because war is never justified. Is anything ever about God-honest facts — who actually knows all the damn facts? I do feel strongly that I will end up on the Good Side of history, but I imagine it’s also true that my ideological opposite feels the same way. I am nearly convinced that I must try to persuade my dissenters, if only to satisfy and embolden my own conceptions of what is Right. But, in the end, I suppose what will matter — what will determine the quality of a life — is not how many people I persuade to adopt my worldview, but how I treat and love my friends and family, and what objective, measurable good my beliefs bring about, if any.
I called New Mexico home for 18 years. I’d like to think that my time in the Southwest set the foundation for my worldview, but that’s not completely true. Tall walls of privilege obscured to me any honest idea of how the world might work.
My high school consisted largely of white, wealthy folk. This is fine, except that it’s difficult to know other people without, uh, actually knowing them. The only real glimpse past my narrow world (in which the opposite sex and soccer and snowboarding reigned above all else) that I could muster came through a couple of teachers and a handful of trips abroad. In Cambodia, age 15, I peeked briefly into a world mightily different from my own: At Angkor Wat little kids sold bracelets and fans to tourists. One young boy (11, tops) performed card tricks and impressed foreigners by counting to ten in more languages than I knew existed. He would collect money to bring home to his family who lived miles away.
As an unaware teenager, it was easy to romanticize the tribulations of poverty, feel momentarily moved by the struggle, then return comfortably to the confines of my New Mexican world.
Other journeys to South and Central America and Europe would all provide a fragment of what I desperately lacked: perspective. Having generally avoided reading books, a worshiper of SparkNotes, it was traveling that opened my door to the Real World. Entering, however, was a different story.
I was still painfully ignorant when I arrived to Seattle for college. “Faggot” and “that’s gay” were staples of my lexicon. Today, I’m not sure what makes me feel worse: the shame of knowing I unabashedly blurted those phrases, or the agony they now induce when I hear them. I never opposed gay marriage, and I don’t think I ever thought less of gay people. But I now recognize the brutally obvious contradiction between what I supposedly believed, and the way I spoke.
Seattle to me was the epicenter of cool. The Sounders and the Seahawks, the coffee and the fixies and the hipsters, that stunning mountain beaming in Southern distance. Despite the rain, or perhaps because of it, Seattle shined like no city I’d ever seen. It wasn’t until later that I began to love the Emerald City for less superficial and less aesthetic reasons.
Riding a bike and recycling were no longer just hip. As it became clear to me that we are on the verge, or in the midst of, environmental apocalypse, these things began to seem important on some bigger-than-me level.
Supporting LGBTQ rights was no longer a peer-pressured expectation. I soon grew close to members of this community, learning quickly the consequences of my degrading vernacular. My school and neighborhood in Seattle are home to a large gay population, and I sometimes wonder if hate and intolerance would vanish if the hateful and intolerant (and uncomfortable) of this planet spent, I don’t know, a month on First Hill.
More importantly, at college I was told to check my privilege. Never directly. I was involved with student politics, and this allowed me to listen closely to these types of conversations. A distasteful and, I now understand, hurtful cover page on my school’s newspaper ignited an important debate about privilege, which introduced me to a subtle and nuanced world of oppression taking place in front of my eyes. Nuanced and subtle, that is, if you’re not the target of that oppression. And I wasn’t. And I’m not. People I admired led these conversations. They spoke eloquently and emphatically about “institutionalized oppression” and “structural violence” — terms I’d never heard of, nor expected to have played a part in. I was shocked to consider the very real possibility that I had played a part. But I rejected it because I, I struggle, too!
Thankfully, that rejection didn’t last long. Eventually the essence of the “check your privilege” campaign started to make some sense. It soon clicked that checking my privilege is not an unnecessary burden, that it might in fact have something to do with historical injustices and fairness. That it does have something to do with historical injustices and fairness. Even though I fall short often, I consciously try to be aware of the privilege my identities afford me, asking myself how I can use privilege for good. I’m still searching for the right answers to that question. And I’m not worse off for it.
College, thus far, has provided me an invaluable education on the Bigger Picture — or a slice of it, at least. I’ve learned how thoughtless use of language can be insulting and hurtful (most of us actually learn this when we’re like five). I now see that my whiteness is something that should be considered deeply, and understood still today as a potential instrument of oppression. I started to care about issues of race. I became aware of systems and institutions that perpetuate inequality.
At a Jesuit university, social justice is a paramount principle. I have become fond of my school’s mission statement and number one marketing slogan, that I’m here to become a “leader for a just and humane world.” I felt, and feel, that I actually have a role to play in that ideal. I’ve come to understand that an examined life is a trial of enlightenment, which, if we’re lucky, affords us a sense of heightened consciousness. The trick is not to gloat in that condition. It might be a farce anyway. The important question is what to make of it, how to use education for good, and to not drown along the way.
The larger, not so obvious point here is that even writing these statements makes me feel kind of disingenuous, fraudulent even. To care about social issues is by no means to understand them. Time and time again, when I thought I had grasped It — understood an idea or mastered a principle — a complicated geometry awaited me just around the corner, making it increasingly difficult to feel certain about anything.
Certainty, it turns out, is fleeting.
My dad always advised my brother and me to “know what we don’t know.” This is valuable wisdom, I think. The more I learn, the more it seems like I know nothing. Liberating as that may be, it’s never been easy for me. For a good chunk of my conscious being, I’ve held preconceived notions of what is Right, too intellectually lazy and too self-righteous to do the difficult work of actually verifying these views myself — opting, instead, to rely on the supposed truths of writers I admire and the friends and family I love most. My emerging worldview — or whatever it is I’m describing — had been in a large part based on fragments of experience and hasty interpretations. Perhaps that’s how this is supposed to work.
It’s tempting to call my year in Chile one of my most formative, although I doubt a twenty-something has any idea of that sort of thing. The time I lived in South America was marked by a constant battle in my young mind, one frequently bombarded by revelations that seemed, at the time, important and original. The latter they were not.
Santiago, Chile’s gritty capital, was the backdrop of my life’s most recent chapter. I struggled throughout with the pending realization that the world is darker and more complex than I previously thought. Loneliness soon crept in. No longer surrounded by like-minded people (you know, friends), feeling sorry for myself informed much of my early perspective on Santiago. I made unfair judgments of my new home, avoiding, at all costs, the more challenging work of understanding it.
While taking classes at a Chilean university, I worked part time at the Santiago Times, an online English newspaper. I filed stories on a range of issues important to me and conducted interviews with people who were important to Chileans (and soon thereafter, to me). It was, at this point, the most fulfilling professional experience of my life.
But truth be told, I was miserably anxious and insecure during those months that I was writing about Chilean society.
On my first day, I showed up much like I did my first day of college: bright-eyed and ready to save the world. I was assigned a story about a Peruvian immigrant who stepped on a landmine crossing the border into Chile. And I was mortified. Not because of the Peruvian’s experience. I couldn’t figure out how to make a phone call. And my first day was almost over.
A human. A weapon used to kill humans. He stepped on a landmine and lost his leg. Surely he knew about the dangers in crossing the border. What was he thinking? The risk must be worth it?
Another time, I was asked to cover a strike by the country’s postal service. The workers, who had been on strike for a month, demanded fairer wages in the face of lavish salaries made by the company’s executives. (This was only one of many strikes that Chile has seen in the last several years; they have erupted from various industries, all of which protested unlivable wages.) I left the newsroom in the morning to take pictures and to interview the strikers, who were posted up on the banks of the Río Mapocho, a filthy river that flows — barely — through Santiago. I scribbled some questions in my yellow-paged notebook. I took some deep breaths. I walked along the river, toward the workers. I took some more deep breaths.
These people want fairer wages. They’ve forfeited their paychecks for a month. They have families to feed. So why aren’t they working? The loss must be worth it?
I was now hyperventilating.
I hope it doesn’t seem like I’m apologizing for my delayed sympathy and curiosity about the Larger Point. For me, growing up means perpetually cringing at my former self. I’m okay with that, though. Sure, I welcome the day when it stops happening so frequently, but, in the meantime, I’m happy to be growing at all. Hopefully I’m becoming a more decent human in the process.
At this point, still young and relatively naive, it’s easy to get caught up in the idea that every task I face — writing a story for my internship, for example — and every decision I face — like how to write that story — will play a monumental role in the course of my life. I think this is the case for many Millennials. Trying to stay afloat in the midst of so much self-inflicted pressure is at times overwhelming. I’m not quite sure what to do with important questions about politics and economics, human rights and equality. These are things I hope to understand someday; they’re things I truly care about. But who am I kidding? I fluctuate between moments of seeming enlightenment and utter aimlessness. When does that stop?
Santiago is a chaotic place. Chaos, in this sense, meaning: the hazy film of brown smog that arrests (usually) any possibility of a pleasurable view of the Andes. The traffic. The mayonnaise. The fucking mayonnaise. The monstrous electronic billboards. The KFC, Subway, Pizza Hut and Wal-Mart in walking distance from my home. The rich’s contempt for the poor. The poor’s contempt for the rich. The glaring contrast between rich and poor neighborhoods.
A more rational version of me recognizes that, in many cases, politics rests at the heart of why things are as they are. In other words, the decisions made by people in power can completely change the Game. How the Game changes may largely depend on your perspective. I wanted to understand these decisions — political or otherwise — that explain who Chile is today.
My initial dive into Chile’s political context was more a result of my environment than a conscious decision to engage. Last year, Chileans collectively remembered the forty years that have passed since their 1973 military coup. (I say ‘their’ as if the coup singularly belonged to Chile and a large group of Chileans unhappy with Latin America’s first democratically elected Marxist president. That’s not exactly true. The U.S. role in the coup is indisputable. And the torture and murder and disappearances that followed that fateful day were a result of political decisions by very powerful people, the consequences of which, at least in my view, were horrifying. (Strangely, not everyone feels that way.)
Learning of my country’s role in this history-defining moment did not come as a complete surprise. Indeed, I vaguely understood that the U.S. has historically meddled in the politics of many other nations. (And, to be clear, ‘vaguely’ in this last sentence only refers to my previous understanding of U.S. meddling, not the intensity of U.S. meddling. Which was not vague. At all.) But to hear first-hand accounts from people who lived through the dictatorship, to interview and to write about torture victims and their families, to learn from them, and to walk through establishments forever tainted by human rights violations and murder is to illuminate the consequences of U.S. meddling in a way reading about it never could.
Just as I began to settle into my Santiago life, it was becoming clear how tormentingly complex my new and now immediate world was. My mind filled with unease and curiosity. I badly wanted to make sense of it all. In retrospect, I think my unease was fueled by the then-impending and unoriginal revelation that capitalism and its biggest fans are history defining forces, for better or worse. I submit that my angst also stemmed from the admittedly provincial notion that KFC and the like reflect consumerism and excess, which many, including me, consider to be an American disease. I saw the worst of the U.S. in Santiago, and the familiarity of it all was unsettling. But there was something else, too.
The country at the time was saturated in commemoration. The moment that changed every Chilean life just forty years ago was being remembered in newspapers and magazines, in television specials, in street art, in theaters, in universities, and in my home. The dialogue was vibrant, full of both optimism and hurt. It was the type of national conversation that only just began to be possible sixteen years ago when democracy returned to Chile. Many people spoke out against the impunity of former junta leaders. Family members still uncertain of the fates of their loved ones who disappeared during the dictatorship took to the airwaves to tell their stories. In the meantime, I wondered if the U.S. Embassy in Santiago felt as uncomfortable as I did during all of this.
I reveled in my conflicted thoughts, trying to reconcile how Chile had become a bastion for global capitalism and inequality, and the role my home nation played in the pain this entire country was remembering right in front of me. A pain I, and probably you, will never understand.
Monday afternoons became one key medium through which I started to tackle these big questions.
I met Yelena when I first arrived to Santiago during an activity meant to help familiarize ourselves with the city. She had just spent several months interning at the Santiago’s United Nations office, and so already seemed to know the city well. And, when she wasn’t taking sips of water from her Brown University Nalgene, she spoke Spanish beautifully. I was probably more nervous than I let on. I could tell that Yelena was exceptionally intelligent, and I was captivated and, frankly, intimidated by her.
Get Mason Bryan’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
We saw each other in passing and not much else for about six weeks, which I imagine was a consequence of my Ivy-laden inferiority complex. Until, to my surprise and great excitement, she invited me to coffee.
“As an American, what do you honestly think about communism?” she asked, pointedly, at a community center coffee shop named after Gabriel Mistral.
I took a sip of my coffee. Shit, how do I respond to that without looking like an ignorant American?
Yelena, daughter of a Canadian mother and Beninese father, grew up in Swaziland. I won’t relay to you the entire context of her interesting upbringing, but believe me when I say she enjoys a high level of Political Consciousness, of which I am quite envious.
I didn’t have a satisfying answer for her question. Communism is bad, I figured. I’ll spare you the details, and me the shame, and assure you that we worked through my wrong conception of this political system to which a strong minority in Chile ascribes. (Not to mention the huge swath of communist parties around the world).
Monday afternoons could not come fast enough. Our conversations touched on everything from the role of journalism in a democracy to the limits of free market economics to neocolonialism. We spent hours debating what she called the U.S. tentacle — my nation’s influence around the world, and what the tentacle had meant for Chile forty years earlier. Over the course of our conversations I began to feel a sense of comfort discussing Things That Matter in a way I never had before. Yelena’s curiosity and passion for issues bigger than us were endless, and contagiously so.
But the truth is that I spent most of the time fearing I would be found out, revealed for the fraud I was. I eventually confessed this to her. She laughed, told me to shut up, and we never looked back.
Of course, the newspaper where I interned covered the forty-year anniversary of the 9/11/73 military coup. (We from the U.S. are not the only ones with a tragic 9/11.) I was tasked, along with two other reporters, to cover the dictatorship’s impact on Chilean music. We chose to tell the story in several parts, through the lives of three musicians all uniquely connected to this dark time.
Anita Tijoux was one of these artists. She’s a thoughtful and piercing rapper, and Grammy-nominated, although she’s not one to tout that fact. Her parents, victims of the dictatorship, were exiled to France, where Anita was born. I first met her one afternoon at my host family’s house.
She and many others were over at my new home for lunch. For anyone who has tried to learn a new language abroad, it is enormously difficult to keep up during table conversations. I knew enough Spanish to grab some words and phrases, even to contribute once and awhile. I hadn’t started at the Santiago Times yet, so I wasn’t thinking about sources or potential stories. I was just trying to keep up.
The conversation drifted, as it so often does in Chile, towards politics. It was here that I learned that I was no more American than Anita. I am North American, she South American. We are both Americans. The conversation escalated. What business does the United States have placing military bases around the world? Fighting wars that aren’t our own? Starting wars on false pretenses? Justify Guantánamo. Do you actually think Obama fulfilled his “hope” and “change” campaign promises?
Uh-oh.
I felt defenseless. Not because I wasn’t familiar with the criticisms — it was exactly these critiques of the U.S. that prompted my interest in journalism and politics. I first encountered the world’s aversion for the United States in Southeast Asia, this time in Malaysia, when an old, drunk man yelled “Fuck Bush!” at our group while we walked down an orange-lit street in Kuala Lumpur. It was the first time I questioned what it meant to be a U.S. citizen, the same question I would end up asking myself countless times in the future, the same question I was asking myself now, at this big, loud Chilean lunch.
I could only nod my head in agreement, spewing out the same conciliatory remarks I’d become accustomed to making in these kinds of conversations. Fortunately for me, I do feel strongly that Bush and his administration made unforgivable mistakes, like going to war on false pretenses. I’m deeply unsettled by U.S. meddling, and I admit that I struggle with the idea that my nation should be a moral force in the world. I see why American exceptionalism brews disgust abroad. And Guantánamo. Can anyone justify what happened there, and what continues to happen?
Anita probably knows more about U.S.-sponsored torture than I do.
I felt defenseless talking to Anita because I could offer no balance, no counter perspective. I couldn’t even defend Obama, who I admire a tremendous amount and who has certainly helped the U.S.’s reputation around the globe. Until recently, that is. I cannot, for example, pardon his authorization of drone strikes that kill civilians and incite fear among innocent communities. Let’s be honest: Anita was right. And she didn’t even mention the crooks in the U.S. government (Richard Nixon and former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger) who helped bring to power the Chilean dictator responsible for her being born in exile. She was, in other words, laying it on lightly.
As a U.S. citizen, where do I fit into Chile’s history? Do I share some blame? Maybe. Maybe not. But having been a visitor and a guest in this country, I felt that I might carry some burden of decisions made by government leaders who my family members and family friends may have helped elect. Of course, I could crawl into a corner and proclaim my separation from it all. I’m only 21, and the foreign policy decisions of governments past are far beyond my reach. But that doesn’t sit well.
Tito Fernández, a famous Chilean folk singer imprisoned during the dictatorship, was another subject in our story for the forty-year anniversary coverage. When speaking with a source in Spanish, I oftentimes lost track of what was being said, relying on my voice recorder to make sense of it all later. This strategy didn’t make for the best interviews, as it was difficult to question an idea or ask for clarification. And it was no different with Tito Fernández.
Until he said he was tortured.
I had missed his statement’s context, but it didn’t matter. I understood exactly what he said. As a student of politics and a reader of newspapers, I understood. I knew that torture was real and continues to be real today, but it was different to hear that truth spoken so plainly to me by a victim. Sympathy — (or whatever the visceral feeling is that surfaces when you realize you’re truly incapable of relating to a particular struggle or experience, but you can easily conclude that it’s measurably worse than anything you’ve experienced) — that feeling, manifested in me physically. I felt shivers shoot through my body and an unpleasant sensation in the pit of my stomach.
He was tortured. He was tortured. He was tortured.
Torture, like genocide and sexual slavery and child soldiers, represents humanity’s horrific potential for evil. It makes me consider the terrifying notion that humanity is not fundamentally good. The existence of the term “war crimes”, legally enshrined in international law, suggests as much. According to the International Criminal Court, genocide, sexual slavery, the enlistment of child soldiers, and torture are all considered war crimes.
When I finally did interview Anita Tijoux for the newspaper, I learned that her parents were also tortured during the dictatorship. Likewise the parents of several of my professors.
The realization that torture had touched people who surrounded me — who had helped me, who had taught me — was disturbing. Call it gringo guilt. Perhaps that guilt is unfounded, and I confess it might be, but instinctively I felt that I share in the responsibility for the suffering my new community has endured, and continues to bear.
And the suffering others beyond Chile have faced at the hands of the U.S. military. The People’s military. Suffering dictated by the upper echelons of executive power as a matter of policy. Waterboarding. Electric shocks. Sexual humiliation. By the People’s military.
The People’s torturers.
It’s true that other factors contributed to the overthrow of Salvador Allende in 1973, like a weakening economy and violent radical leftist groups. But it’s dangerously irresponsible to understate the power of the United States government to strong-arm history toward its best interest. Like by trying to prevent the spread of communism at all costs.
Michelle Bachelet was elected as president, for the second time, while I lived in Santiago. Forty years earlier and just days after the coup, the military junta tortured and killed her father. The Chile she inherited this time is one aching for social change; it was her promise to deliver on the demands of one momentous movement that arguably won her the election. In 2011, tens of thousands of students marched in the streets of Santiago demanding access to free and quality higher education. The movement has since grown and organized remarkably well, becoming easily the loudest cry for change in the nation. Underpinning the students’ concrete demands is a relentless desire for a Chile that is equal and fair. This is no surprise. Chile has some of the highest levels of inequality in the developed world.
Still, this long country, squeezed between the Andes and the Pacific and stretching nearly the entire length of the continent, is the economic envy of Latin America. Success w/r/t the economy, generally speaking, is considered to be a result of neoliberal policies implemented during General Augusto Pinochet’s regime, which led to huge waves of privatization and a frenzy of direct foreign investment. Neoliberalism, as it’s known, is a market-based economic system advocated by Milton Friedman and his Latin American associates trained in University of Chicago orthodoxy, a brand of capitalism that many argue narrow mindedly promotes the complete uprooting of government intrusion in the economy.
The Chicago Boys, as these economists came to be known, were the result of a U.S. State Department policy launched in the 1950s, which sponsored Chilean students to study economics at the University of Chicago. The goal was to train a generation of young Chileans “who would become the intellectual leaders in economic affairs in Chile.” These students came from Chile’s Catholic University, a conservative school where I studied last year. The project successfully indoctrinated some of Chile’s brightest in neoliberal ideology in an alarming performance of “intellectual imperialism,” as Naomi Klein described it.
In 1970, the Marxist Salvador Allende was elected president. In other words, the State Department project didn’t work. President Richard Nixon was not pleased. Fearing a Communist takeover in Latin America, he ordered the CIA to “make the [Chilean] economy scream.” That meant creating conditions suitable enough (or, miserable enough) in Santiago and the rest of Chile to justify the forced removal of then-President Salvador Allende.
Indignant and indifferent to democratic principles, the Chicago Boys ultimately worked hand in hand with the Chilean military general to upend Allende’s socialist economy and install a new, unregulated marketplace. The brute force of Pinochet’s military, accompanied by the intellectual support of the Chicago Boys and the financial backing of the CIA, gave birth to a new Chile — one where a pure free-market capitalism could thrive, and where any dissent would be silenced by exile, torture, and murder.
Anita’s parents. Tito Fernández. My professors. This man next to me on the bus?
Across the country students, workers, journalists and intellectuals attribute the nation’s crippling inequality to the Friedman-inspired reforms introduced as an experiment in the 70s. That experiment is hailed by some as a “miracle.”
In May, a young man threw himself from the 25th floor of South America’s tallest skyscraper, which is home to Santiago’s largest shopping mall. The building is seen by some as the fruits of capitalist success in the country; others consider it a symbol of consumerism and excess — yes, a Chilean disease, too. This recent suicide only emboldened proponents of the latter view.
Many people in Chile have come to reject the idea that markets can adequately supply certain social goods like education. Hence the student movement. In their characteristically lively marches, the students commonly evoke, in signs and songs, the idea that education is a human right, and that it should be provided and protected by the state. In a country once doused in the poison of human rights abuses like torture and disappearances, this claim is not made lightly.
Expectations for Bachelet to deliver on campaign promises are high, and Chile’s economy is starting to slow. The student movement, however, shows no signs of cooling. I have no doubts that these young people will continue to march and shout and sing until they get what they want: a more equal Chile. Their biggest challenge now is a tax reform bill being debated in the Chilean parliament, which, if passed, could fund their ambitious demands for free, quality university education.
As for me, I need to make sense enough of the lessons I learned in South America to do something worthwhile with them. I suppose I will strive to be skeptical of power and of selective democracy. To be an advocate for checks and balances and a well-informed populace, maybe the best weapons against state-sponsored torture and other abuses of power. I will be more curious. I will continue to learn about the extent and harm, and even the good, of my government’s influence abroad, and at home.
I will try to write compellingly about what matters to me, what I think should matter to you, and what perhaps matters to others not uniquely positioned to speak out for themselves.
I will remember Tito Fernández. That his torturers asked for his autograph before they committed their abhorrent crime. That moral people are capable of unthinkable evil, and that much of this evil has gone unpunished.
I will try not to drown along the way.
*A warm thanks to Dad and Mom, Ms. Goessl, and Miles Parnegg for their unfailing support and wisdom.






