Court
Last year I emerged from the Old Bailey, having spent a long time there as a juror. As you can imagine, all the cases heard within its confines are serious. Very serious. And the case that myself and 11 strangers (initially at least) were selected for was no exception. It was at times gruelling and bewildering.
But I’m not going to commit all the details of the defendant and the charges against him to the written page. No, that simply would be wrong.
Take me to the pub and I may tell you over a pint of IPA. If you’re buying that is.
What I’m going to rattle on about is what I learned within those venerated walls and how it can be applied to our industry: advertising.
The two worlds couldn’t be further apart. But ultimately they rely on a group of interconnected people getting to place and solution where everyone is happy. In advertising it’s a creative, strategist, account person and client getting to a piece of communication that elicits a desired response. In the justice system it’s 12 random souls deciding whether someone is guilty or not.
So what struck me about my time at the Central Criminal Court of England and Wales?
Respect.
That’s the first major thing that I took from my time at the Old Bailey; the way that everything was conducted with respect. The way that everyone was given a fair hearing. The way a quiet voice had as much say as a loud one. And that is crucially important; it shouldn’t be how someone tells you their opinion, but what their opinion is, how it’s shaped and formed. The quiet person’s outlook can be just as valid, if not more so; they can be considered, contemplative, an observer taking in all sides of the argument.
The loudest voice is simply that: the loudest. The one with more confidence, a person who thinks their viewpoint simply must be right, because it’s theirs. But perhaps they don’t fully listen and therefore they don’t fully understand all the points that lay in front of them.
Get Andy McAnaney’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Yeah, and? What’s this got to do with the digital 6-sheets? Well, simply put, I don’t think there’s enough respect when discussing strategy and creative. I think there’s a lot of people trying to tell you their opinions, but simply not enough listening. We could do with more a little bit more of that.
Too Much Information
At times, the mass of information (photos, written statements, expert reports, spoken testimony) was overwhelming. Trying to separate truth from untruth, the significant from the insignificant was an onerous task.
It was the valuable times away from the deliberation room, the absence of pressure and focus that allowed facts to sink in, opinions to be formed and a bigger picture to be revealed.
Even though we don’t need to be, people in our line of work seem to be tied to our desks. We have distill so much information and sometimes we can just try and force it too much, squeeze out the ideas. Perhaps we just need to get out of the office, go walking those mean streets a bit more and let the unconscious get to work on those problems, don’t let ourselves get dragged down by the detail and see the bigger picture.
Time
Nothing. Was. Rushed. At. All.
Even though we took our time in our deliberations, at no point did we feel pressured to make a decision. Everything was calm and considered. If we had been put under duress to speed up, I’m not sure we would have come to the same conclusions. We could have overlooked important information; been unsure of our position and made a leap in the dark. The time afforded to us, ensured the decision we collectively made was the right one.
Precious few projects we work on have to be concepted, created and pushed out the door in double quick time (sure, some do but these are an exception). So why don’t we get, or more importantly build-in, the time to truly digest the masses of info we receive? To make sure we come up with the right solution rather than just a solution? If people were more respectful of the process and why time gives better solutions (up to a point) then maybe the work would be better.
Most People Are Good People
In a post-Trump, post-Brexit, post-truth time it’s easy to get down-hearted about the world. Especially if you’ve been party to the details of something particularly hard going. However my time at the Old Bailey, although rather surreal, was weirdly a positive experience. The people I met were a good bunch, thoughtful and interesting. It seems the justice system isn’t full of crooks, liars and ne’er-do-wells.
If only we could say same about the ad industry.







