Research
Ask (interviews)
Interview Questions/ Prompts
- Walk me through “snack time.”
- Are there snacks that took especially long to finish?
- Tell me about any concerns you had about the snacks you handed out.
- Tell me about a time when snacks that the kids got evoked a strong reaction.
- What did kids usually do with their wrappers?
- Tell me about the packaging the snacks usually came in.
- Can you tell me about any times kids didn’t want to dispose of their wrappers/packages and kept them?
Lindsey
For my first interview, I reached out to a friend of mine who had a roommate who recently spent 6 months nannying in Germany. Lindsey, the roommate, graciously agreed to discuss the two boys she took care of. They were 4 and 7 years old. Taking care of these children for so long on a regular basis, she was bound to have some solid snacking experiences. Plus, perhaps she could provide an interesting cultural perspective.
Snack time for the boys was always after he got home from school. They were only allowed to eat at the dinner table, and were fed primarily healthy, non-processed food. Eggs, cut fruit, miniature meat wraps, cereal, and yogurt were popular. Most snacks required some minimal preparation.
“They liked things they could help prepare”
Lindsey noted that they were far more enthusiastic about eating a plate of cut fruit if they helped chop the pieces, as opposed to just being handed the prepped food.
When asked about foods that took especially long to eat, she pointed out that string cheese took forever. The boys would often leave half-eaten cheese sticks on the table. Despite the fact that they loved mozzarella, Lindsey guessed this happened because the cheese was filling and the boys probably lost interest.
Candy, strangely enough, was the snack that lasted by far the longest. Candy was given as a treat or reward. Much like giving out candy on Halloween, there was a large basket of “fun sized” candies that the boys could pick from. The treats ranged from chocolates to cookies to Haribo gummies. Typically, the boys slowly nibbled away at their treats in order to make them last as long as possible.
“You didn’t want to be the one at the end that didn’t have any more, and you had to watch the other one eat.”
On the flip side, little cups of yogurt were the shortest lasting snacks. They could easily scoop it into their mouths, they didn’t have to chew it, and it was one of their favorite snacks. This was one of the very few snacks they had with unique packaging. The boys were especially fond of these yogurts because they had a small game or puzzle printed on the container. However, their interaction with the package was extremely passive.
“They usually just stared at it while they ate”
They might trace a maze with their fingers, or make a comment that they solved the puzzle, but with any more involvement it’s likely that they would not have enough attention to keep eating.
“Either they were staring at the package while they ate, or they’d eat and play.”
While Lindsey recognized there seemed to be distinct “play” and “eat” modes, there were also cases of play being infused with the snacking. Sometimes the boys would goof around with their string cheese, such as peeling out a bunch of strings to look like tentacles or just slapping each other with the sticks. On occasions when they got ice cream treats (like popsicles), there were times when the boys kept the sticks and brought it to their rooms. The sticks perhaps were used for their frequent crafting, or maybe utilized with their Lego’s. Crafting never got old for them, so that could be why a popsicle stick was so intriguing.
Bananas were especially difficult to open for the younger boy.
“Sometimes he’d really want to do it by himself, but then he couldn’t and get frustrated, then give it back to me to peel.”
Aside from these interactions with the food packaging, Lindsey said the boys left their wrappers and containers on the table. After all, snack time here was a mostly mundane experience, and the boys wanted to go play.
Alanna
Next, I reached out to my neighbor Teddy who had a roommate frequently involved with taking care of children. Alanna has spent two summers nannying 11 and 9 year old boys. In addition to that, she is currently working at a primary after-school program for her third year. A viewpoint on snacking from both outside and within the home sounded well rounded.
The boys being nannied during the summer essentially snacked on whatever the wanted, whenever they wanted. They had anything from hot dogs to raspberries. Junk food was a favorite among them.
“They’d get really excited when you gave them crap food.”
Soda and ice cream were rare delicacies to their young palettes. Carbonated beverages were given to them roughly once a month. Discussing snack packaging after eating, Alanna stated how bad they were at throwing them away. Eating food mostly from plastic wrappers, they would normally crumple them up and leave them everywhere. Alanna did, however, point out one interesting idle interaction with a paper plate:
“I’m just picturing David watching TV, folding his paper plate”
The after school program was much more structured with snack time. The kids would eat during the first 20 minutes that they were there. Snacks were provided by the program, or donated by a local organic “hippie company.” Milk and cheerios were always available, while fruits and yogurt cups would also rotate through. The organic company made weekly drops of various fruits and vegetables in bulk tubs, as well as loaves of bread. Most kids were initially grossed out by the veggies, but many enjoyed the flavor after trying them. Dates were especially popular.
The kids didn’t have any packaging to deal with, since all the snacks were stored in bulk containers. They had reusable bowls, cups, plates, and utensils. After eating, Alanna noted that:
“Kids always played with their silverware…they’re like little tools, they keep playing with them”
Pretty much all ages (K-8th grade) “played” with their utensils: tapping and poking things, clinging them together, putting them in their mouths. This was casually done while talking to friends. Alanna also remembered that many of the younger kids liked suctioning cups to their mouths.
Anna
For my third interview, I turned to my roommate from freshman year. His older sister just graduated from the U last December. Anna has student taught in 4 different elementary schools for 3 years, and has been a substitute in about half the public elementary schools in the twin cities since her graduation. These schools ranged from new, polished buildings to inner city facilities. The diverse demographic she saw should bring a solid insight on kids and snacking.
In the private schools Anna taught at, snack time was a flexible and relaxed ordeal. There were two time slots that kids could choose to eat their snack. The kids would circle up on the floor and eat. The schools didn’t provide food, so kids brought many different foods from home. Some brought carrots, mac n’ cheese, chips and guacamole, or even sushi. Drinkable apple sauce packets were especially popular.
With all these homemade snacks, kids brought many reusable containers. Thermoses were common, as well as small sectioned containers for neatly organizing snacks. Anna said the kids especially enjoyed these organizers and complimented each other on theirs. The thermoses had colorful and playful patterns and prints, but the kids showed no particular interest in them:
“It was just another boring adult kitchen thing to them.”
Snack time at the public schools was much more organized. Snack time was in a predetermined time slot. Everyone usually sat in a circle (with or without assigned seating), got hand sanitizer, and the snacks were distributed. Usually a timer was set, or the teacher read a story during the snack. The school provided all snacks. Some schools had typical snacks like apples or goldfish, and others had a deal with a local organic food supplier (similar to Alanna’s after-school program). This supplier would send individually wrapped fruit and vegetable slices. Some would be more common (apples, oranges) while others were much more strange and obscure (like korabi or jicama).
Anna reflected that while it was cool for kids to be trying these new things, it may have been more important that they get something they actually like and get more nutrients from. Some kids wouldn’t like the korabi, give it to someone else, and another kid would get upset after seeing someone get two when they only got one.
When asked about snacks that took especially long to eat, Anna immediately thought of oranges.
“Anything you need to peel is difficult.”
Many kids would be unable to peel them, some would rip them in half or smash them. Peels would go everywhere, and orange juice would make everything sticky. This would cause cleanup time to be extra long. Thermoses also complicated snack time, as many kids weren’t strong enough to open or close them.
Get Max McGee’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Most veggies came in unexciting clear plastic wrappers. After the snack was taken out of the bag, most kids would set the wrapper on the floor in front of them until it was time to throw them away.
Thinking about packaging that kids wanted to keep, Anna brought up the fact that some kids would cut out pictures and characters from mini cereal boxes. Boxes were probably the most playful, interactive snack packaging available: kids would look at the pictures, stack boxes, and keep them to decorate their desk. This got old fast, however, and kids would discard the box somewhere.
Observation
For my observation, I considered what the beginning of the kid snacking experience was: parents buying the food. Without the parents actually getting the snack, the snack experience can’t happen. With this in mind, I decided to observe families as they shopped through a nearby Cub foods.
I arrived at 6 pm, grabbed a basket with some groceries, and began drifting about. The first parent with children I noticed went down to the cereal aisle, grabbed a bag of malt o meal fruit loops, and cruised right back out.
A girl expressed sudden excitement to her mother over a certain Ben and Jerry’s flavor. They do a great job of using puns and pop culture references to create silly and memorable flavors of ice cream. The girl probably saw a flavor that struck a personal chord with her; either a uniquely favorite flavor or a reference that amused her.
A young girl wandering the frozen dinner aisle was drawn to the“Kid’s Cuisine” boxes. These boxes are adorned with pretty much every color of the rainbow, playful bubble letters, and a grinning penguin character. This colorful box design was clearly doing its job well.
Back in the cereal aisle, a mother was walking with her son as he picked out any cereal he wanted (he ended up getting strawberry frosted mini wheats). The mother did not appear to be concerned with nutrition.
A mother rolled straight to the frozen food aisle, grabbed the most conveniently placed box of corn dogs, stared at the front for several seconds, then put it in the cart. She looked short on time.
Another mother in the yogurt section was looking at Greek yogurt as her son got extremely enthusiastic about a box of new glow-in-the-dark star wars Gogurt. Almost exactly like the previously observed mother, she grabbed the box, stared at the front cover briefly, and threw it in the cart.
Most parents I observed were not in the center aisles of the store. If they were, they came swooping in and out, returning to the refrigerated perimeter. This is probably because people need to buy perishable food more often because, well, it perishes. Dry goods can be purchased and stored in much larger quantities, so those purchases are probably less frequent. Parents seemed rushed, and looked as if they knew exactly what they wanted, bouncing from item to item and only getting what they came for.
I returned on a Sunday at 2:00 in the afternoon.
Arriving at the store, there were noticeably more cars there than my previous trip. I was hoping for this, as a larger crowd means that there are likely to be more families there.
In the dairy section, I noticed that kids would like to reach into the egg cooler as their parents would grab a carton. When I saw it this second day, I was reminded that I saw this during my first visit too. Perhaps the egg cartons are enticing to the kids. The fact that they reveal 12 tiny pods may be more interesting than a simple box that can’t be seen into.
Despite the relatively high traffic here, the aisles containing kid’s snacks seemed to have the least amount of people there. There was an aisle that was half bread, half “lunchbox” foods: peanut butter, jelly, small packs of crackers, Capri Sun packs, fruit cups, and pudding cups. For my hour and a half of observing the store this day, I noticed only one person shopping for snacks from this aisle. I could only assume she was a mother, and she was looking at a box of Quaker oat/ yogurt sandwich cookies. She looked at the nutrition facts carefully, grabbed a box of mini Oreo bags, compared them briefly, and chose the Quaker cookies. Nutrition was obviously important in this decision. She may have considered the Oreos for a potential price difference, but the nutrition facts were the last items on the boxes she observed.
In the aisles in the center of the store, a commonly recurring cart maneuver for families was the “grab-the-item-off-the-shelf-and-whip-the-cart-around-and-leave-the-aisle” move. Families were doing u-turns all throughout the central aisles and leaving. To me, this suggests that families typically don’t have time to slowly peruse all the aisles; there are only points of needed items throughout the store and everything else is a distraction.
That doesn’t mean all parents I saw looked rushed, however. One mother and daughter were in the store for quite some time, and slowly made their ways through all the aisles. They stopped by the granola bars, and the girl was allowed to pick out a box. She carefully looked over a small group of Quaker oat bars before settling on her desired flavor and placing it in the cart. The girl seemed quite interested in being able to pick something out herself, which reminded me of how other kids acted when they were allowed to select a box of cereal. However legitimate this “freedom” may be for the kids, it looks like they enjoyed going through the motions of what they see adults do.
In the same snack bar section, a little boy was grabbing for a box of gushers. His mother stood behind him. She looked the box of Fiber One fruit snacks next to it. She mentioned something about it (exactly what, I’m not sure, they were speaking Spanish), grabbed it for a couple seconds, then put it back and let her son grab the gushers. The less unhealthy alternative to gushers must have drawn her in. Perhaps she let her son get gushers because his diet already is sufficient in fiber, or that fruit snacks with fiber aren’t going to make a significant nutritional impact regardless.
Later, I saw that same young boy walking about holding a bag of marshmallows with both hands, almost feeling it. I remember enjoying holding marshmallow bags when I was young. They were soft and fluffy and fun to handle. My favorite part was being able to push my face against the bag and smell the faint sweetness that permeated the material. I imagine that sensory experience appealed to the boy as well.
Experience
I chose to recreate a snack time scenario from one of the public elementary schools that Anna taught at. I corralled my roommates to the living room, ran through as the pretend teacher distributing snacks, then I swapped places with one of the guys and we repeated the situation.
The teacher would sit everyone down on the carpet. Next, each student would receive a squirt of hand sanitizer. The students then held out their hands and got a small handful of goldfish crackers. They were allowed to eat once everyone got the snack. A small egg timer was set for 5 minutes, after which everyone should have their snack eaten and cleaned up.
Distributing the snacks felt like nothing new to me, except for the fact that I had to walk through every single step of the process with them. I’ve worked in food service plenty of times before, but I felt very in charge in this simulation.
Playing the role of the student, I found sitting down on the floor to be rather calming. I just had to ride out whatever the teacher had us do. I did start to get impatient very quickly, however. Being served the goldfish, it was a great feeling to have the crackers poured into my hands. Sitting on the floor with goldfish in both hands, I felt like I couldn’t do anything but focus on eating and talking to the people near me. I also became more conscious than usual of how many goldfish my neighbors had in their hands versus mine.
Storyboard
Public school snack time story board
Major Insights
- Cleanup is an important and final part in the snacking experience; after cleanup, the experience is over (interviews)
- Kids can often have a tendency to not throw their garbage from snacking away(interviews)
- Parents are busy and don’t spend much time browsing for kids snacks when shopping (observation)
- Kids interactions with snack containers while eating don’t extend beyond idle manipulations and observations (Lindsey, Alanna)
- Kids don’t like seeing their peers with things they themselves don’t have (Anna, Lindsey)
- Packaging that is difficult for children to open can frustrate them (Anna, Lindsey)
- It’s difficult for younger children to multitask while snacking: most, all, or no attention is given to eating the food (Lindsey, Anna, experience)
- Children do not interact with most common plastic snack wrappers after food is removed from them (Interviews)
- Snack time can be a mundane experience in small groups (Lindsey)
- Kids tend to get excited for “treats;” food that they are only occasionally allowed to have, and is almost always unhealthy (Lindsey, Alanna, observation)
Problem Statements
- Many parents shopping at Cub Foods need a way to quickly and efficiently find snacks for their kids because they don’t have time to scour the grocery store.
- Kids need something to idly manipulate during snacking because it makes the snack experience more engaging.
- Anna, a substitute teacher for elementary schools around the twin cities, needs a way to encourage children to throw away their food containers because cleanup time cuts down on time allocated for learning and other activities.







