Sitemap

The Sopranos and the Bible.

13 min readAug 28, 2014

(Warning: Contains spoilers.)

Recently I started to work my way through all six seasons of the HBO Mafia TV smash The Sopranos. Winning five Golden Globes and with ratings peaking at almost 12.5 million viewers, this show was popular with the public and critics alike. I am currently midway through the fourth season and am gripped.

For anyone who has never seen it, it revolves around New Jersey mob boss Tony Soprano and his crew. It features some very talented actors — many of whom were relatively unknown beforehand. The backbone of the dramatic talent is undoubtedly the late James Gandolfini as the protagonist. Bruce Springsteen fans will also be surprised to see E Street Band veteran Steve Van Zandt as Tony’s consigliere Silvio Dante. Steve shows that he is arguably as good an actor as he is a guitarist and songwriter.

Not only does the show have great actors but it is also tremendously well written. One of the show’s strengths is that it does not fall into the trap of making the characters one dimensional. No one in the show is portrayed either a “goodie” or a “baddie” as was traditionally the case in T.V. shows like “Bonanza” or “The Waltons”. The Waltons mindset from Fifties middle America would have us portray the Mafia guys as unsympathetic characters who are beyond redemption because they make their money from illegal activity and often resort to violence while the people who making an honest buck as say a restaurateur or police officer would be shown as beyond reproach. A Waltonesque mentality would also have Tony and his friends get their comeuppance while the other guys live happily ever after.

The problem is that we need to be honest with ourselves and realise that real life is not like that. No one in this world will ever reach sinless perfection and even the worst of the worst have some redeeming features. If we are honest we also know that in real life even the people we hold in the highest regard are not immune from tragedy or injustice and we often see others of questionable character not only get away with their misdemeanours but actually prospering. The Sopranos is so compelling because it continually challenges us with storylines where pretty much all of the characters face ethical dilemmas, especially Tony. The surprising thing is that often they do not do what you would expect of them, and again no one exemplifies this better than Tony.

Tony makes money from a range of criminal activities such as phone card fraud, extortion and controlling trade unions. He is a serial philanderer and has a fierce temper. He also shows strong prejudices towards non-Italians, for example he forbids his daughter Meadow to continue dating her mixed-race Jewish boyfriend. Yet he often shows a softer side. He is deeply upset when a family of ducks living in his pool disappear and is shown all doe-eyed at the side of racehorse Pie-Oh-My when she gets sick. He has serious guilt pangs when his mistress Gloria Trillo commits suicide and is flabbergasted when his school fails to punish his son A.J. for trashing the school trophy cabinet.

The response of those outside Tony’s inner circle of his friends, family and crew members towards him is varied. Often we see the likes of the media and the FBI demonising Tony and his crew as a plague on society that needs to be dealt with by imprisonment. Another response we see is from respectable members of society such as Dr. Cusamano’s golf buddies who look down their noses at him or Richard La Penna who resorts to activism through the Italian Anti-Defamation League. Finally we see people like Father Intintola and psychiatrist Jennifer Melfi who want to cure Tony. All these attitudes reflect some kind of sense that these people are better than Tony yet the storylines continually challenge these ideas. Indeed we often see some of these pillars of the community behaving as badly as the Mafia guys.

In series one Father Intintola habitually visits married women while they are on their own (such as Carmela Soprano). He pretends that he is there to offer Carmela spiritual counsel and because of their shared love of movies. It soon emerges that he is really there to eat her food and receive emotional validation by engaging in quite blatant flirtation. He even admits to Carmela that he has sexual feelings for her yet is constantly preaching about how Tony must change.

Another example is Tony’s sister Janice. She is the character who is most visibly interested in spirituality having dallied with Buddhism and Christianity and often talks about her personal growth. This same Janice is a serious sexual predator and frequently uses emotional blackmail against her brother Tony for her material benefit. She also writes a Contemporary Christian Music album with the primary reason for this being that she realises it is a very lucrative market. Her dubious moral character, especially her avarice and jealousy is displayed when Russian nurse Svetlana inherits Janice’s mum’s valuable vinyl collection. In reaction to this, Janice steals Svetlana’s prosthetic leg to blackmail her. I can’t see Jesus or the Buddha endorsing any of those actions!

Even old people are not exempt from this continual examination of the integrity of those outside the Mob with one of the most manipulative characters of all being Tony’s mother Livia. She plays upon her brother-in-law Corrado’s disillusionment at not being made boss to try to get him to have her own son Tony killed. She also does all she can to belittle both Tony and Janice and then when they bite back she turns on the waterworks in an apparent fit of pique at their lack of appreciation for her hard work as a mother.

The thing about the Sopranos that may surprise a lot of people, especially church folks, is that this continually highlighting of the moral complexity of human beings is right there in glaring detail in the Bible. This is seen both in what it teaches and the stories it tells. Often the Sopranos begins with the announcer giving us a “heads up” about the strong language, drug use, sexual scenes or graphic violence in the show but surprisingly most people don’t realise that a TV series based on a lot of Bible stories would need to be prefaced by similar warnings. I believe that one of the most appalling tragedies of Christianity has been its tendency to “Waltonise” Bible stories when kids are in Sunday School (probably with the best of intentions) but often this mentality persists right throughout the generations and has horrible consequences.

One of the earliest “goodies” in the Bible is Noah. The biblical account says “Noah was a righteous man, blameless among the people of his time, and he walked faithfully with God.” When everyone else had got so corrupted that God felt the need to start again from scratch, He decides Noah and his family will be the ones to be given the fresh start.

Noah shows a great deal of faith and courage. The story tells us that there had never been a flood before and most serious scholars tell us that he was living in the middle of a desert — or at least in a place miles away from any body of water deep enough to make such a massive vessel viable. This means he had to be pretty single-minded to build a huge boat there because I am sure people would have written him off as a total crackpot.

Noah’s faith is rewarded and all those who thought he should be consigned to a padded cell get a nasty shock. Sure enough the flood comes, Noah his family and the animals are rescued and all the “baddies” are drowned. Then we have a rainbow and a promise that God will never flood the earth again - a fairytale ending.

This is usually where most church folk leave Noah but it’s not where the Bible leaves him. Not long after he leaves the ark he gets full on pie-eyed and is lying buck-naked in his tent. Not what most people, especially respectable church folks, would class as someone who was righteous, blameless and walking faithfully with God. Could it be that because this part of Noah’s story has been censored that people in church can be so judgemental of one of their own who gets caught intoxicated?

You may say that the example of Noah is pretty lightweight. What’s so bad about someone getting legless once in their life? My point is that the failure of many churches to drive this element of the story home, whether that be unintentional or deliberate, feeds the narcissism and delusion of the self-righteous hypocrites who feel “holier than thou”. It also leaves anyone who is conscious of not being perfect feeling that church is no place for them.

Get Mike A. Romeo’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

For an argument to be valid we cannot base a premise on a “one off”. OK, you say, Noah had a blip but all the rest of the Bible characters were spiritual supermen who never put a foot wrong. Baloney!

Jacob, who became Israel, and the father of the twelve tribes deceived his blind father to make him the principal benefactor of Isaac’s will over his older brother Esau. As a father, Jacob was so partisan towards his son Joseph that his other brothers conspired to kill their brother. Not exactly a model parent. We also see this borne out in another incident involving his only dauther Dinah. When her honour is besmirched by the pagan Shechem he sat on his backside and did nothing about it. This last event happened after Jacob had wrestled with an angel in what can only be described as a major supernatural experience. Many church people would have you think that after such an experience of God, even your burps will smell sanctified! How wrong can people be!

Another example is Moses, the mighty man who delivers the Israelites from slavery. This is the guy that inspired a lot of the civil rights protestors in the U.S.A. He goes into hiding because he was a murderer running from the authorities. He is not Mister Courageous either. When God asks him to lead the people out of Egypt, he dreams up every excuse possible, even saying he wasn’t cut out for public speaking. This was a guy who could potentially have been top dog in Pharoah’s palace and would have been highly educated!

What about the great King David? The Sunday school version is the plucky young kid who slays the 9 foot Goliath with a stone and a sling and plays the harp to soothe the black moods of the morbidly depressed King Saul. Even later on as teenagers you might be lucky enough to hear the slightly more edgy story about when he is in hiding from the paranoid Saul who is out to bump him off. What tends to happen even with this story is another sanitised version. Man churches emphasise David’s nobility, highlighting the fact that when he has the chance to kill Saul he spares him. Even this gets sugar-coated because implication of the Jewish text is that David caught Saul going to the toilet!

David is described as a man after God’s own heart. He wrote most of the Bible’s hymn book the Psalms but he usurped his duty as commander-in-chief of the army when they were off fighting the Philistines. Not only that but during this time he started to indulge in a bit of voyeurism on a married woman as she had her bath. This escalates into a full-blown affair to such an extent that he has her husband left exposed in a dangerous combat zone so he gets killed. Think Barak Obama, supposedly off at some high profile meeting during the conflict in Afghanistan when he is really cavorting with the wife of one of the top U.S. Marines. The President then sends this stand-up guy into a Taliban hideout with his buddies only for them to deliberately cut and run so this All American hero gets decapitated and a YouTube video is sent to his mum. Definitely not a U-Rated movie there!

What about Jonah? The Sunday School Jonah was told to preach to the nasty Ninevites to stop being so bad because if they didn’t God would wipe them out. Who would want to preach that? You and I would have got on a boat and gone the other way just like Jonah did if we had to do that too, right? The real Jonah didn’t want to go to Nineveh because he didn’t want God to be merciful to non-Jews. He wanted God to wipe them out!

These are only some examples of biblical “goodies” who are shown to be deeply flawed. What about the other side of the coin?

When the Israelites get caught in Jericho in the midst of the battle who rescues them? Some nice Jewish church lady with a carpenter as a husband and 2.3 kids? No! A Gentile hooker! And she gets included in Jesus’ family tree!

When Jesus is to be born who do the angels get to come to His bedside? The local rabbis and the guy who donates the most money to the synagogue every year? No! A bunch of shepherds who were considered about as honest as a room full of politicians and three pagan astrologers.

When Jesus wants to tell a story about what it means to love your neighbour, he leaves His audience dumbfounded as neither the priest nor the Levite rescue the man brutally beaten and robbed but instead a Samaritan. Think a Yazidi rescuing a member of ISIS, a member of the Ardoyne Residents Group rescuing an Orangeman, a black slave rescuing a KKK member.

Who is the person who Jesus commends as being one of the most spiritual guys he has ever met? A Roman soldier who was part of the occupying forces of the time. Can you imagine Jerusalem’s top rabbi commending some Nazi soldier or a leading member of Hamas for his profound spirituality? Not only that but Jesus also has Simon the Zealot and two tax collectors as disciples. Think some sort of crack Mossad agent alongside some Israeli extorting money from his neighbours to give to Hamas or the Nazis and you are not far away from the shocking truth of these stories.

Moving aside from the stories in the Bible to some of the theological statements it makes we see again that this Waltonised Sunday School version of the Bible is nowhere to be seen. This is the book that says that “the heart is desperately wicked and deceitful above all things, who can know it?” It declares that there is no one righteous.

Even Jesus, the nice bearded Caucasian man in children’s Bibles who healed the sick, Jesus the guy who people of all faiths and none admire for feeding the poor and befriending the outcast, Jesus who preached the Golden Rule, Jesus who preached turning the other cheek, Jesus who preached loving enemies, Jesus who told us to visit the sick and the guy in prison did not have this ridiculously facile “goodie/baddie” view of human nature. The same Jesus who did and said all these things said “ For out of the heart come evil thoughts—murder, adultery, sexual immorality, theft, false testimony, slander.”

We have the apostle Paul in his magnum opus the book of Romans state the following in chapter 7 “ I do not understand what I do. For what I want to do I do not do, but what I hate I do… I know that good itself does not dwell in me… For I have the desire to do what is good, but I cannot carry it out. For I do not do the good I want to do, but the evil I do not want to do — this I keep on doing.” Who would have thought that Tony Soprano and the apostle Paul would have so much in common?

Earlier I referred to how the Sopranos puts paid to the myth that “cheaters never prosper” and that if you do the right thing, it all works out in the end. One of the most harrowing scenes in the show is when Dr. Jennifer Melfi is raped on the stairway of an underground car park. This is a dedicated psychiatrist who spends 4 years doing all she can to reform the ultimate recidivist Tony Soprano and is deeply committed to the welfare of all her patients. She is also a devoted mother. In the world of the Waltons, this is not the type of person this should happen to, or if it does someone will catch the perpetrator and he will get his just desserts. Not so in the Sopranos. Even though the police identify the rapist, they cannot bring him to justice, as investigative incompetence compromises the evidence and the case falls apart. In stark contrast, we see Tony continually evade the law by bumping off informants, letting his uncle take the rap for him and bribing policemen. Surely the Bible is not like this thoroughly injust world of the Sopranos? It says that good people are blessed and bad people are punished, right? Wrong again!

The upright Joseph who refuses to sleep with his boss’s wife gets accused of rape and is thrown in jail. The Psalmist Asaph also reflects his disillusionment with this aspect of life when he says:

“ This is what the wicked are like — always free of care, they go on amassing wealth. Surely in vain I have kept my heart pure and have washed my hands in innocence. All day long I have been afflicted, and every morning brings new punishments.” To put it in plain language he says “What’s the point of being honest, when the cheats and liars make all the money while it all goes belly up for me and I feel miserable?”

Whether you believe it to be an inspired, infallible spiritual text, a sophisticated piece of religious fiction with some literary value or even a dangerous book of delusions which fuel harmful prejudices there is something that cannot be denied. If you read the Bible with an objective eye you cannot fail to see that it is anything but insipid and one dimensional in its portrayal of human nature. It is way more Sopranos than it is the Waltons. Maybe if more church people grasped that those who are self-righteous would get off their high horses and those who feel like they can no longer go because they have blown it would not leave never to return. You may also find comfort in the stories of people frustrated by honesty not being rewarded while those who cut corners flourish. Let’s be honest. The Bible says you are more like Tony Soprano than you care to realise.

Mike A. Romeo
Mike A. Romeo

Written by Mike A. Romeo

A lover of books, movies and travel.