Sitemap

Referendumb

5 min readJun 20, 2016

--

Recent EU referendum polls show a swing back towards the Remain side of the argument. The pound has picked up against the dollar, following the murder of Jo Cox MP by Far-Right maniac: polls straddling the tragedy show a decrease in the lead of Leave by 6 percentage points.

Yet the polls still show public opinion divided. The turn in the polls represents a return to the pre-30th May situation, after which point for 17 days the Leave side maintained a steady gap in the polls.

For Remainers, it’s welcome news. Referendum-day swings to the status quo are well-documented, so neck-and-neck polls are a good sign. For Leavers, it must be frustrating.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Credit to Matthew Smith for the graphic. Information taking from ‘How history hits Brexit for six’ by Peter Kellner.

I sympathise with this frustration (and that’s about it). Populists that spout obviously-wrong or debunked statistics and churn public emotion to their advantage had managed to turn people. The murder of an admirable and tireless public servant appears to have turned the result the other way. How fickle is human emotion!

Referenda in Europe

Referenda are arguably the most democratic exercise possible. They permit electorates to take direct control over government policy.

A system that routinely uses referenda to decide government policy is called a direct democracy. Populist parties like UKIP advocate direct democracy; there is an entire bloc in the European Parliament dedicated to it. Switzerland’s political system operates on this basis, whereby referenda are supreme over the national parliament.

Switzerland

Direct democracy can seriously complicate matters however. Switzerland held a referendum on immigration quotas on the 4th February 2014, abrogating the EU–Swiss free movement agreement. Twelve days after its passage into its constitution, Switzerland was relegated to ‘Third Country Status’ on a number of EU science projects. Eventually, the country was granted partial-association to Horizon 2020 on 22nd October 2014. Yet to this day complete association has still not been granted, and Switzerland has had to pick up the costs.

On 26th April 2016, Switzerland ratified the extension of the EU–Swiss free movement agreement to Croatia, an agreement initially declined in February 2014 following the immigration referendum.

Greece

In less direct democracies, referenda have also made for particularly poor politicking. Greece, a country burdened with debilitating foreign debt, faces a debt crisis unequalled in Europe since the 1950s World War II. For years she faced deep fiscal contraction referred to as austerity. In July 2015, a repayment was due to the IMF, but the SYRIZA-led government had run out of money.

In the run up to the payment, European finance ministers held meetings to deliberate the terms of a memorandum that would inject the country with liquidity and keep it afloat. Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras, his government decidedly on the back foot, scheduled a referendum for the 5th July 2015 on whether to accept the terms.

The result was a resounding No. Yet it would mean nothing. The memorandum had expired, and Greece had to accept even harsher terms to secure the bailout. Tsipras promptly called for snap elections, calling it a referendum on his government’s performance. Eurosceptics from SYRIZA left, hoping the result would free them from Europe. SYRIZA was returned to Parliament, one seat short of an absolute majority, to oversee the implementation of a memorandum they had negotiated.

Netherlands

Get Michael Kenning’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

My final example is Netherlands. The EU–Ukraine treaty is in the process of being ratified by EU member states. Ukraine is a country dealing with a proxy war with Russia in the east and economic decline, and the hope is that this treaty will help.

It has recently been held up in the Netherlands. Under the Advisory Referendum Act of 1st July 2015, the Dutch government will declare a referendum on an issue if enough requests are received. These conditions were satisfied regarding the Ukraine–EU treaty, and so a referendum was declared.

It was rejected. The parties campaigning for a No vote in the referendum were by-and-large eurosceptic, with little concern for the wellbeing of a fellow European country. Right-wing parties across Europe viewed it through such a lens. When Nigel Farage, leader of the UKIP, called the Dutch referendum the ‘hors-d’oeuvre’ to Britain’s EU referendum.

Calling Referenda into Question

Representative democracy—at least in Britain—isn’t given the praise it deserves. At election time, the electorate considers the merit of each party according to their own individual principles and interests. Compromise is inevitable as voters are faced with parties espousing broad programmatic policies. You may like one party’s environmental policies, but how do you fancy them with defence? or even the economy? Besides, what would be their chances of winning? The attention paid to the voting intentions of our friends or wider society is a positive thing.

A completely different attitude is taken in referenda. In Switzerland, an anti-immigration party sought a referendum that would abolish free movement into Switzerland and undermine existing treaties with the EU. It damaged science in the country, and the government picked up the cost anyway. Eventually the Swiss government saw it in the country’s interest to broaden free movement anyway.

A referendum was used by SYRIZA in Greece to mobilise popular outrage against a bailout that was no longer valid. The Greeks voted No and no sooner got a worse deal.

In the Netherlands, referendum law places a serious obstacle to the proper functioning of government. Those mobilised for the No vote were not concerned about Ukraine or the merits of the EU–Ukraine treaty.

In each case, the referenda had consequences reaching far beyond the scope of the question. Switzerland and Greece found themselves in a worse position than before, whereas the Netherlands hurt Ukraine. The Greek and Swiss publics could hardly be expected to know the outcome of their referenda, whilst the Dutch didn’t care.

On the other hand, when the Republic of Ireland was asked whether gay marriage should be legalised, the scope of the issue was clear practically, and resulted in very specific and limited institutional changes.

Whereas parliamentary systems encourage compromise, referenda encourage majoritarianism. Moreover, referenda are far more prone to induce people to analyse interests according to their personal interests rather than the public good.

Referenda present significant political problems too. If the result of a referendum is difficult to carry through, it seriously damages the legitimacy of the incumbent government.

In contrast to referenda, political parties acting on manifesto promises have greater freedom to fail. If they fail, it is a trust issue rather than a legal issue, and limits the damage to the party itself, not the state. In a western democracy, you can change the party at the next election, but not the state.

The Future of Direct Democracy

The laws on referendums vary across European countries. In Italy, it is unconstitutional to hold referenda on international treaties. Greece’s constitution, despite the memorandum referendum, forbids referenda on financial matters. Belgium bans referenda altogether, and the Netherlands permit referendums on anything with enough public support.

There is such a thing as too much democracy. If every policy decision a government made was made subject to referendum, decision-making would grind to a halt, and the state would lose its legitimacy.

Though all-out bans on referenda are not desirable. Where issues, the solutions to which are clearly defined, cannot satisfactorily be settled in representative chambers, referendums are a good way to reach a resolution. Where political outrage at institutions becomes intractable, elections should do the job, as a failed referendum would transfer the anger from party to state.

Where the consequence of a referendum are uncertain, demagogues take up the baton on both sides.

--

--

Michael Kenning
Michael Kenning

Written by Michael Kenning

PhD student, glossophile, philomath, philologue. Strict on bad grammar, strict on the causes of bad grammar.