App.net and a Tale of Two Twitters
App.net’s biggest fan wonders why the people never came
App.net is alive, but with the layoffs of their employees and the founders taking jobs that pay them in actual currency, the hope is dead. The hope was that a group of People Who Care(tm) could fund a social network driven by the right things. Developers would get an API that would help making a social app easy. Users would get great applications driven by design, and not advertising. Those users would pay developers for their apps, and pay App.net for their plumbing.
App.net started as a blog post in response to Twitter dramatically changing their public API. The 3rd-Party Twitter clients that helped grow that service, like Twitterrific (which defined the word “tweet”) and Tweetbot, were left in the cold. John Gruber described Twitter clients as a UI playground. The BEST of iOS design was founded on Twitter plumbing. Hell, Loren Brichter PATENTED pull to refresh from Tweetie. It felt like Twitter just didn’t care.
For a time, that UI playground moved to App.net. App.net’s service quickly exceeded what you could do with Twitter’s API and great apps like Felix and Riposte pushed microblogging UI forward. The Microblogging API allowed great features like out-of-band links. The Files API allowed you to have control over where things like pictures were stored. The Private Messages APIs from App.net allowed you to send URLs to people without an error message.
These services worked and they still work. But, the people never came.
Get Sam Davies’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
John Gruber and Marco Arment have a discussion on the most recent episode of The Talk Show about why App.net didn’t get traction. To summarize, they argue App.net was not different enough and that Twitter was was not evil enough.
This is echoed by Friend of the Internet, Casey Liss. In an email to me, he states:
While I disagree with Twitter’s policies, a couple things have worked in their favor:
• Twitter has been less ridiculous (or perhaps, quieter) with their poor policy choices since the tipping point that led to ADN happened.
• Twitter is the system of record for “microblogging”. This is where the people are. Talking to yourself isn’t fun.
There are actually two Twitters. There is Tweetbot Twitter and the Twitter for Everyone Else. Tweetbot Twitter preserves the purity of the timeline. It has no ads. It has mute filters. It’s what people in “the know” use. But, it’s frozen in time. As long as microblogging remains exactly what it was in 2012, it’ll keep working, but anything new Twitter builds is reserved for Everyone Else.
The Twitter for Everyone Else is annoying. There are ads. The timeline isn’t necessarily in order. John Gruber couldn’t figure out how to turn off annoying notifications. But, the Notifications view is a useful summary of who interacted with your stuff. The read state of DMs and Notifications sync between the native Twitter clients. Twitter cards are divisive, but I find them useful. Most of the stuff in Twitter for Everyone Else is crap, but there are a few diamonds there, and those diamonds will never be in Tweetbot.
I don’t know when, but there will probably probably a day of reckoning between The Nerds and Twitter. Either we nerds will join the Twitter for Everyone Else, or we’ll continue to use Tweetbot Twitter the way that some people still use Usenet.
App.net is still up and running. If everyone you cared about started using it this afternoon, you’d have a better experience than you have today on Twitter. But, that’d be like 8.4 million New Yorkers suddenly realizing New York City is a horrible place to live.






