An Innovation for 1,000,000,000 people
Learnings from designing for many people
Choices are important. I strongly believe our choices define who we are. Also who we will become. Since my final year at Hogeschool Rotterdam (Bachelor ‘Communication and Multimedia Design’) is at hand, I was in search of choosing a minor to follow for 20 weeks.
Choosing a minor was about setting targets for the future for me. The main question in choosing for me was by asking myself the following question:
What will be my added value in business and society as a graduated designer?
I see kids (way younger than me) making insane graphics in Photoshop while I just craft ‘plain’ user interfaces (which is fine, but technique-wise you start feeling poor, I’ll be honest). I see people with no footprints in the designing landscape come up with the most brilliant concepts. I see people designing functional and esthetical user interfaces by just using their sense of logic and play, while they never had any design education in their entire life.
The added value of a multimedia designer in my opinion is in the attitude. That attitude is curiosity and being able to (quickly) make things tangible. I don’t know if you can train curiosity (I don’t think you can). But you can become very skilled in making things tangible by experience. Ideate, conceptualize, sketch, prototype and having the guts to ask for feedback even when it looks perfect to you. In the end we design for people. And if a designer’s innovations need to become successful, it must resonate with a certain human need. By using a pragmatic attitude we can succeed earlier.
The minor ‘Designful Innovation for One Billion People’ helps me gain more experience in making things tangible.
I made a choice. Let’s go.
This post is meant to do two things:
- Reflect on the things I have done and tell about what I have learned from it as a designer.
- Document my design process along the way of making a meaningful innovation for one billion (you heard that right) people. This process is documented with the book 101 Design Methods: A Structured Approach for Driving Innovation in Your Organization by Vijay Kumar. This is the model he uses:
Meeting new and familiar
03 september 2014 — Important is the environment that designers wander in when they do design. That was one of the first lessons Saskia gave our class on the introduction day of the minor. We have our own room for five days a week, which means we can customize it a bit in order to all become more inspired.
But we also had introductions. These were a little different than usual for me, though. Ruth, my other lecturer, made us fill in a digital form that asked questions like ‘What is the most innovative thing you’ve ever done?’ and ‘What’s the most exciting trip you ever did?’. These were questions that shined a different light on all of the participants in this minor. What made it extra special was that others would visualize the answers and share this with the rest of the class (which was somewhat hilarious sometimes).
Coolhunting in Rotterdam
04 september 2014 — It seems you can detect patterns that can spark innovation if you start to look different at your city. Marina Meeuwisse gave some lessons to us this thursday about coolhunting — which is basically (in my humble opinion) looking differently and being more sensitive to things you’d normally ignore in the public domain.
So, during eleven ‘o clock we went out into Rotterdam to photograph things that seemed interesting. It seemed to be a lot like the cognitive dissonance assignment I once did two years ago for ‘Media & Creativiteit’.
What have I learned? What is hard? I have learned to look different. How to look different do you say? Yes. Different. Different in the way that you don’t look at the everyday things like you would normally do. But seek what makes them special. I think I have learned a bit better how to look different at the same things.
The future of cities
08 september 2014 — For our third assignment, we needed to choose a trend. Earlier on, we received an email with possible trends to choose from, such as healthcare, food and future of cities. I chose future of cities, and the assignment was to give a short presentation of three minutes about your chosen trend. I made a slide in which I highlighted the interesting things I thought of within the domain of this trend.
After that, we did further research on a given trend. This trend was also the future of cities, and I did this together with Erwin Hofman. We further investigated the future of cities by mapping human needs from Maslov’s piramid. We watched a few relevant TED-Talks to gain more knowledge about how for example food played a role in the development of urban areas. We filled in the piramid as far as we could. The results were presented on sheets of paper to our fellow classmates.
Placemaking is the way to go
09 september 2014 — Today was my free day from college, but I decided to put some work in making the classroom a bit more fancy. My classmate Erwin picked me up at 8:30 in the morning by car to deliver a microwave (which was a leftover in the attic of my apartment) to school. I rearranged some furniture and made it all a bit more cleaned up. Awesome it became.
Trip to Antwerpen
10 september 2014 — Luckily this day was a sunny day. We went to Antwerpen to get a more feeling about multiple cultures. Developing this feeling is important, because one billion people WILL involve multiple cultures. This is still hard for me to imagine, since I’ve gained a lot of experience as a designer about making products and services for smaller target groups.
In the morning we moved to the South centre of Antwerpen where we did an energizer to get the spirit going. This was needed, because we went on a trip through the city. Antwerpen is known for its multiple cultures that live there i.e. Jews, Russians, French people, Portugese and so on. Ruth (one of the lecturers) gave us all a map which showed the route that would take us along all these different cultures.
But we didn’t just go on a trip to see cultures. We needed to pick one of our founded trends from the Coolhunting assignment, and make photographs that confirmed the trend. We did this in groups of two. So, together with Maarten, I went on a trip throughout Antwerpen.
After the city field trip, we visited MAS (Museum Aan de Stroom). Before we went inside, we did some energizers and small assignments. The museum had various expositions from display of power to the way death is interpreted in various cultures.
Coolhunting revisited
11 september 2014 — Today Marina gaves us a lecture about psychology. The main focus of her lecture was to develop a better understanding of how humans make decisions in their everyday lives. What followed was an explanation of Freud’s model of personality structure.
After the lecture in psychology, we all gave presentations of our coolhunting results. Marina suggested that if other people could comment on your photo’s, you should use a certain structure to regulate a desired and meaningful way of commenting on your photos.
What really interested me was when Marina showed us a few scenes from a documentary by Adam Curtis: The Century of the Self. This documentary shows how the insights from Sigmund Freud’s psychoanalysis led to being used massively by companies all over the world to manipulate society in buying certain products and using certain services.
These scenes that Marina showed triggered me to ask if there was any material written on what the ethics should be in marketing (and perhaps in design, there’s not even a clear distinction between those two, though) in using these psychoanalytical insights. Marina told me I should read about Joseph Goebbels — how is widely known for being the minister of Propaganda during Nazi-Germany. He may be a fine example of triggering myself in creating a better vision of what is ethically acceptable and what not.
I learned that it is important you design your keynote in the right way if you want people to have an opinion about your photo. Just show them in a flash. Give them enough time afterwards to write down their view on the photo.
I learned more about how coolhunting works. Marina told me that it’s important to have a subject in mind before you start making photographs. Using a subject can help you detach from the world you live in. You do not want photos to be taken subjectively. You want to be without an opinion, and let the environment do the talking. For example: If I work photograph for the subject ‘work’, I can make pictures of working people. But two people sitting on a couch… Are they working? I don’t know. I should ask them. If the answer is yes, I could ask them if I could make a picture of it.
Guest lecture by Frank Bosboom
15 september 2014 — In the morning, we all made visualizations of what we thought of when thinking about one billion people. Me, Esther and Elga came to the conclusion that if you would consider all one billion people in your design process for just one second it would take about 32 (!) years to think of them all. This implies the enormous amount of people we are designing for during this program.
An important aspect in multinational surroundings is a look into the work of Geert Hofstede (1928). He developed what is known as Hofstede Dimensions. They consist of six elements that define the paradigm a country is in. The elements are:
- Power distance i.e. how equal are people in a society?
- Individualism i.e. how individual or how collectivistic is a society?
- Masculinity i.e. how much does competition and success drive people in society?
- Uncertainty avoidance i.e. how much people avoid uncertainties in a society?
- Pragmatism i.e. how people in a society deal with the present and the future?
- Indulgance i.e. how well do people control their impulses in society?
During midday Frank Bosboom came along to share his experiences with us. We prepared questions to ask him. I was particularly interested in his international experience, since he might have tips that could help when designing for one billion people.
Reflecting this back later on the day, I felt like it was too early that Frank Bosboom came along. It was hard for me to ask good questions that really helped me further into the creative process; only because I’ve just started. I did take Frank’s advice and looked into Philips Design online; it is full of awesome papers about subjects such as Design Thinking.
Cultural probes
17 september 2014—This morning we started a working exercise on trends. We made teams of four to five persons each and picked a trend. We picked the trends ‘D.I.Y. (Do It Yourself)’ and ‘IoT (Internet of Things)’. Our assignment was to visualize how this trend would manifest itself in the year 2040. The image on the left here below is the result of this. I did this again in a different team setup, now the trend was education (and how this of course would look like in the future). The right image down here displays the result.
We presented these sheets that showed our visions for the future. We discussed them briefly. After that, everyone was given proper time to make preparations by filling in the cultural probe. Filling in this cultural probe was an assignment of which the data in it would be used in a guest lecture by Floor Borgonjen who works at Philips Design as a design manager.
Floor gave us a lecture in design research. A lot of her presentation was already known to me from the lectures by Bas Leurs about Service Design and methods that float around this discipline. Nonetheless, Floor presented a few case studies in which qualitative design research was used such as observations, cultural probes and generative (creative) sessions.
During the sketching assignment with the various trends I noticed how my fellow team members were talking more than they were doing (i.e. sketching with markers on the sheet). I think it’s okay to shortly discuss what you’re going to sketch on a huge sheet of paper. You want everybody to be happy with the end result, and so on. I gave myself the assignment — like I told at the beginning of this blog — to develop a more ‘designerly’ attitude. This attitude consists of quickly making things tangible i.e. thinking with your hands. I know I think a lot, and with exercises like this I really force myself to create something as quickly as possible instead of drowning myself in discussing what is best to put on paper.
And I think I really succeeded. I was really proud that I got so fast in putting sketches on paper. I strongly have the idea I’m becoming better in thinking with hands (IDEO’s David Kelley punchline).
Trends and moodboards
18 september 2014—Saskia gave us the assignment to all have moodboards made for three trends that we could present to each other during this morning. Saskia quickly gave us the chance to read Trendrede 2015, which is a manifest on what trends will become more important in the year(s) to come. After this, we layed down all of our made moodboards on the pingpong table and everyone told about their trends.
I was really impressed with Leonne’s moodboards. Not only was there an awesome style behind the design of the board, she also had a good story that made her choices in pictures and words very clear. See the image below. This really inspired me for future assignments with moodboards.
After doing trend presentations, we did another exercise like we did yesterday. We picked a trend, and would fill in the Consumer Trend Canvas, which is based of Business Model Canvas by Alexander Osterwalder. Our assignment was to fill in this model. I did this together with Jean and Esther. We filled in the model and because Jean was in a meeting with Marina, I created a visual together with Esther how this would manifest itself in the future. Of course, at the end of this exercise, all teams presented their work.
What’s still hard for me is to think about smaller trends within one bigger trend. Disruptive services such as AirBNB and Uber are part of a trend I’d like to call ‘Power to the People’. People i.e. the masses are a vital part in the service. This completely redefines the structures of power. Not only hierarchically in a company or between people in society, but also between company and people in society. Society gets way more power because the service is created by themselves in some way. That fascinates me. But to understand it better, I must find a way to define a smaller trend in this bigger whole.
In my previous feedback moment of Wednesday, I noted my notice for thinking more with my hands. Today I did this again, and I must say Esther has been a great team member. We really builded on each other’s ideas and it was extremely fun to do this. Thank you Esther.
Design Driven Innovation by Verganti
22 september 2014 — Today we worked on understanding two articles about innovation. The first paper was by Roberto Verganti called Design, Meanings and Radical Innovation: A Meta-model and a Research Agenda. The second paper was written by both Roberto Verganti and Donald Norman (well known for the ‘Design of Everyday Things’ and ‘Emotional Design’) called Incremental and Radical Innovation: Design Research versus Technology and Meaning Change. The things I learned from these papers about innovation will be written down below here briefly.
There is a way to radically innovate without using the user-centered design method. Verganti finds various firms that innovate without this approach, such as Alessi, Artemide, Apple and Bang & Olufson. In plain language, it’s about creating a network of people who share your vision or want to solve the same problem(s). These people are also called interpreters.
The User-Centered Design approach (praised by IDEO and others) concentrates on the needs and wants of people. If you can give people what they desire, you can innovate. Surely, you can innovate. But it will be an improvement on the product and within the frames of the previous solutions. In other words, an incremental innovation. You cannot radically innovate if you use the User-Centered Design approach. Radically innovating requires a change of frame — a change of paradigm. When asking people what they want, you stay inside the current paradigm, thus never do anything radically different.
The difference between incremental and radical innovation gave some kind of a discussion in class. When is something radical? When is something incremental? We quickly became aware that most things around us are incremental innovations; solutions within the frame of solutions before this. Verganti and Norman make the following distinction between the two:
- Incremental innovation: Improvements within a given frame of solutions (“doing better what we already do”);
- Radical innovation: A change of frame (“doing what we did not do before”).
Something else in the development of radical innovation is that meanings of things change. A famous example within the tabacco industry can be that during the 30's the cigarette became a trophy of independance for women by using a smart marketing trick. This alone cannot simply evoke radical innovation, we also see that technology plays an important role in this. The above model gives clear insight that over time the meaning of video games change — but that’s not all that changes. Technology facilitates the making of faster processors and gesture control within interfaces. This gives new perspective to products, and thus can give birth to products that are radically different from anything else in the current market.
During the end of the day Saskia asked us to make our first Interpreters network and visualize this. So I did. The results will follow.
Lines and Lanes: A lecture by Vanessa de Groot
23 september 2014 — I was late this morning, but still on time. Vanessa de Groot, our guest lecturer today, was already here. She worked and lived for three years in China, so she could tell give me more insight in designing in a cross cultural environment. She gave one hell of an introduction and a whole lot of tips when going to Shanghai which was all very inspiring.
But the main assignment was given to us around one o’ clock. We teamed in groups of three people and got ourselves a design problem. Zazzle wanted to bring personafied watches as give-away presents to the Chinese market. The problem there is that giving a clock in China to someone is rude. Clocks are associated with death. We ended up in doing a pressure cooker for this mini project: We had exactly two hours to come up with a solution, visualize and pitch our idea(s).
Maarten and Esther were my teammates. I previously worked with Esther, which worked out quite well. And this time it worked out fine as well! We quickly created concepts with the three of us. I structured visuals for the presentation, Maarten visualized the watch concept and Esther came up with nice concepts and visualizations for the presentation.
What I really learned from this small pressure cooker is that once again the combination of people that you work with is very important. Maarten was holding back and thinking too much. I said ‘Let’s just do this.’. And what I meant with that was that we should not think too much. But create. And it worked for me and Esther.
The seven sins of memory
24 september 2014 — Marina was here today to once again teach us a thing or two about psychology. Today’s class was about memory and its seven sins. They are as followed:
- Transience; the idea that your long-term memories become obscured as more and more time passes by.
- Absent-mindedness; you forgot something because your attention slackened during the encoding of new information.
- Blocking; it becomes hard to retrieve already stored information. The most well-known example in Holland is “Het ligt op het puntje van mijn tong” phenomenon.
- Misattribution; you link a retrieved memory to the wrong time or the wrong person.
- Suggestibility; disruption in the memory after suggestions. The manner of how a question is asked, when it is asked and how many times the memory is saved can disrupt the memory.
- Bias; distortion of memories through attitudes, convictions and opinions.
- Persistence; you can’t seem to forget undesirable memories.
What’s really interesting in ethic terms is suggestibility. Scientists have done experiments in the last four decades if they could ‘plant’ a new memory inside of someone’s head. And the weird thing is: It’s possible.
For today’s class we also needed to bring a designer that is an inspiration to us. We would all present this in front of the class and talk about the psychology of the design we chose.
I choose Bach and the first page of his (in my opinion) musical masterpiece BWV 582: Passacaglia and Fugue in C Minor. What was the psychology behind this design? We philosophized somewhat about it and came with the following principles which I could use for my concept later on:
- A universal language that not everybody understands.
- Music is based on emotions.
I really want to dig deeper in this abstractive knowledge and add it to my skills as a designer. In the future of this blog, I will link every sin to a particular situation that takes it to a more concrete form instead of staying abstract.
Internationalism and commercials
29 september 2014 — We focused on some models that can better define how a culture functions. With Elga and Esther I did some exercises about how to apply the models to different commercials. The models were as followed:
The Lewis model helps you in placing cultures in a certain domain. The model defines three types of extremes: Linear-active, reactive and multi-active. They will be explained here below:
- Linear-active; these groups have a culture in which people plan, schedule, organize, do one thing at a time. A large part of Europe can be found here. For example Norway, the Netherlands and Denmark.
- Reactive; these are cultures that prioritize courtesy and respect, listening quietly and calmly to their interlocutors and reacting carefully to proposals of other people. Chinese, Japanese and Finns are among the group of reactives.
- Multi-active; there are also cultures in which people do many things at once, planning their priorities not according to a time schedule, but according to the relative thrill or importance that each appointment brings with it. Italians, Latin Americans and Arabs are members of this group.
The Pyramid of Maslow is a psychological model that doesn’t represent human needs throughout the entire world. Although, this is what Pinto thinks. According to Pinto, the Pyramid of Maslow is only appliable to Western individuals. Many other parts of the world have a different view on what’s important (for example, Chinese people live more collectively than individually), which creates a new pyramid of basic needs. This is called the Pyramid of Pinto.
The Pyramid of Pinto focusses more on the needs of an individual from a collective perspective. Of course, primary needs such as food stay the same as in the West. We are all still humans. But being accepted by the group, having a good name within the group and claiming honour are levels in the pyramid you won’t find in an individualistic society. Preferably, I would like to think of China when I look at Pinto’s pyramid.
Important in using these models is that they represent a big group of people. As Saskia mentioned in class, a kind of sterotyped figure roles out of the models when you look at a specific culture. To me, it matters a lot to develop this ‘stereotype’ more to feel more aware of cross-cultural aspects that I can use later on in my ideation for one billion people.
Two days in Brussels: Part I
01 October 2014 — At quarter past ten, my class arrived at the Central Station in Brussels. The first thing we did was visit the Magritte Museum. The reason we visited an exposition consisting of work from René Magritte was because I am making my first steps into ideation — by reframing.
Magritte’s work is mostly surrealistic, and uses a lot of perspectives that can be used in reframing as well. They are as followed:
- Scale; bring two objects together. Change their relative scale.
- Clash; bring two seemingly utterly unrelated objects together.
- Repeat/no repeat; create differences in the similar and vice versa.
- Emotions; heighten or lessen the emotional impact of your object.
- Variations; try different variations on a theme.
- Transformation; change objects in an unusual way.
After the Magritte Museum, we went to an exposition called ‘Design Bestsellers’. Here, famous Belgium designers and their bestseller designs were exposed. It was quite inspirational.
Two days in Brussels: Part II
02 October 2014 — Today was a day with lots of walking. I’m just going to post some pictures that showed the neighborhood we’ve visited (it’s called Molenbeek) and the centre of Brussels.
I really feel like I’ve learned more about other cultures this week. Since I feel I know a little bit more about different cultures, I feel more confidient in the creative process. Also, the reframing techniques that I learned through the work of René Magritte is really a valuable asset in my further work.
Simon Sinek and the golden circle
Today, we discussed the golden circle theory by Simon Sinek. I was already familiar for some time with Sinek’s theory. I think it is a very good model. But since I already knew it, this was a nice opportunity to look more critically at the golden circle.
Afterwards, we had a little discussion about the golden circle theory. My conclusion is — also based on ‘The Cult of Sharing’ — that models such as this need careful consideration when implemented. This is because it can also be used (effectively) for wrong (political) purposes. People tend to move towards the belief they also believe. We must weigh the ‘trueness’ of our own views and beliefs and use them —keeping the ethical delineation for ourselves and how it could serve society. Simply because your impact can be enormous.
Also, Saskia told us that once we get our ‘Why’ more clearly, we can better orchestrate our design process. I’ve been searching for long, but I think I found a very nice entrance through my current chosen trend: The sharing economy. I’m going to work on it for the next few weeks to make my ‘Why’ more clearer. Most importantly, Saskia told me during the end of the day to dig deeper into the trend — do not only look at products and services such as Airbnb and Uber. Look at patterns beneath it — a sense of belonging and being part of a community are strong factors in the sharing economy. Dig deeper!
A workshop in visual sketching
07 October 2014 — Today Bruno gave us a workshop in visual sketching. I was afraid this was going to be a refinement of what I was taught by Bas Leurs once, but to my suprise it was extremely informative.
Bruno told us about this sketching style called ‘Egyptian style sketching’. The basis of this is that you don’t sketch from a realistic perspective, but everything in the style that Egyptians painted themselves on walls. When designing an experience, structure got lost in my sketches in the past. This ‘new’ sketching style really helped me during this workshop to refine my sketching skills and communicate my ideas better towards others. Thanks a lot Bruno!
Brainstorming session #1
08 October 2014 — Today we had class from Ruth and it was all about doing. Doing. DOING. Start sketching. Start brainstorming. I formed a group with Esther and Elga, and the first few brainstorms were hilarious.
In the beginning we came up with a lot of funny ideas. We combined the date application Tinder with an amnesty of 3,000 rejected asylum seekers.
Unfortunately, once Ruth asked us to move towards three ideas distilled from the previous brainstorms, my brain melted. I couldn’t find anything that sparked my mind in working out a certain combination of ideas. In the end, three pretty basic ideas.
Afterwards, everyone generated three ideas from the brainstorm. Everyone posted them on the walls in our classroom, and short presentations were held for one idea you thought was the best.
I was really worn out once this day was over. I didn’t feel like I had made a step forward in my concepting process — maybe it was too early on. I am still searching for a nice starting point but my feelings say that I need to research somewhat more before I can go into conceptualizing. I need to gain more knowledge, so I have more confidence further on in my design process.
Other than that, the workshop did inspire me in thinking more about a concrete route where my design process wil take me. It’s good that some pressure comes along with this — we only have 14 weeks left to design something for one billion people…
Introduction to the FabLab
09 October 2014 —This morning I had a short talk with Marina Meeuwisse. We briefly discussed how I feel during this minor and if there are any aspects to my way of working or thinking that could be changed to be settled better within the minor. I think this conversation was very useful, because it forced me to look at myself in a different way. This felt like an enrichment towards my personal development.
Afterwards, we had a meeting with Leo Remijn at the FabLab. Leo told us what function of the FabLab is and what kind of stuff you can do here. He also gave an introduction in looking at technological trends — which is very relevant for searching for interpreters. One model in particular was very interesting to me, called the Hype Cycle.
An important sidenote is that the Hype Cycle comes before Rogers’ Adoption Curve. If a subject within the above model ‘survives’ this cycle, it will become a mere trend — and should be adapted by Early adopters and innovators. These are of course the two early groups in Rogers’ Adoption curve.
Disruptive thinking and more interpreters
13 October 2014 — During this Monday morning, Saskia briefly explained the term ‘disruptive thinking’ — which is coined by frog’s Luke Williams. We also watched a short lecture by John Kolko about reframing. He uses this model in the lecture:
You can reframe from three different angles; environment, perspective and embodiment. You’ll see that once you change one thing, it comes with some implications that can change the current product into something quite surprising.
We started doing some exercise with this model. We started reframing the Google Glass — which was quite a hard thing to do. First, we needed to define what the Google Glass is so we had a basis from which we could reframe. It was rather hard, because the Google Glass has more than one function. We quickly discovered that it is very handy to narrow down to one specific thing or function. It makes reframing way more easy. Something that I should keep in mind the next time I’m going to reframe.
I also talked with Saskia about how I am going to tackle a big assignment at the end of this quarter. The assignment is about showing your interpreters network, choosing a concept direction and mapping out your ideation phase. Saskia gave me some extra insights in how to find interpreters and how to use Verganti’s model for design driven innovation. I need to connect with more people who seemingly have nothing to do with sharing — which is my starting point for concept development. So I’ll start searching and visualizing right away.
Prototyping with Bjørn van Raaij
15 October 2014 — Today, we had some class in prototyping which was given by Bjørn and Ruth. Our first assignment of today’s class was to write down three assumptions that could be tested through rapid prototyping.
At the end, we needed to choose one concept and create a package for it by using a shoebox. Down below my version of the shoebox.
<picture of Earthism>
I wanted to create something that is shareable and also will connect a lot of people with each other. I looked at the marketing strategies of sharing economy companies such as Airbnb. It occurred to me that by creating a community that has a certain belief and you create the opposite of it, you can strengthen the community even more. For example: The fact that Apple exists besides Microsoft, makes Microsoft try harder in being the best. One cannot be without the other. I tried to create this same effect by introducing a different life force somewhere in space such as aliens. The fact that there are certain things that bind us and we have a reason to unite because there is a big group that does not believe us can make the world (maybe) a better place.
Oh and by the way, I heard this great quote today. You can see design tools as a Swiss knife — it can be used in many different ways.
Certain kinds of capital
16 October 2014 — Marina gave us another lecture. She explained a sociological concept created by Pierre Bourdieu, a French sociologist. Basically, there are three types of capitalism that Bourdieu speaks of:
- Economic capital; the amount of money one has.
- Cultural capital; the amount of knowledge one has.
- Social capital; the amount of social contact one has.
Marina showed us pictures and we needed to think of different ways to think about the different kinds of capital that appear in it. Through this, we ended up in doing exercises on reading pictures.
Next week, I’ll be leaving to Shanghai. Saskia advised me to use my time in Shanghai well, also in terms of my innovation process for this minor. Since I’m designing for other cultures, setting out cultural probes among Chinese people in Shanghai seems like a good idea. I made work of it right away.
[some pictures of the probes, outside and inside]
From 21st of October until the 1st of November I went to Shanghai to work on designing trustful relationship in Chinese healthcare, a project by Philips Design.
Up until I came back from Shanghai, I experienced most classes as in gaining mostly knowledge about how to move through the innovation process.
I have been looking for some time to find a certain structure in my work over the last few weeks. I grew restless over the overlapping issues such as creating an interpreters network, pick a trend and to not know what to do with it on a concrete level. It confused me. For the sake of keeping things structured, from here on I will map all activity relevant to the creative process. The activities will be structured by the earlier mentioned model Vijay Kumar uses in his book 101 Design Methods: A Structured Approach for Driving Innovation in Your Organization.
Extracting insights from cultural probes
03 November 2014 — In Shanghai, I managed to find 5 Chinese students at the Donghua University to fill in the cultural probes I designed. Unfortunately, when cultural probes are filled in, you still need to make sense of the data that’s in it. I had no time to do any interview in real life with any of my participants. So I added a few of them on WeChat (it’s like Chinese Whatsapp) and on Skype. This way I could ask them questions about the things they filled in so I could understand their deeper motivations.
After some Skype sessions, I had gained a clearer view of how to interpret the data inside the probes. So I started to extract insights from the probes. I still put my insights on the capture card format I got from my teacher two years ago during design research class (Thank you, Bas).
I was stunned by how detailed some participants filled in the probes. When I opened a few probes and scanned them, they felt so rich. It feels incredibly awesome to almost see this deeper layer of the human become tangible. I am definitely going to do this kind of design research in the future. A good point in finding out what was good and bad about the design of this cultural probe is to ask my participants, so I can improve myself in the future.
Making an intent statement
07 November 2014 — Although I started doing some design research, the only thing I know up until now is that I chose the trend ‘The Sharing Economy’. But what is my goal? What is my intent? I decided to make myself an intent statement.
In the past few years, I’ve always been very interested in tackling wicked problems in society with the help of design. I see design as a tool that can shape the world into a better place. Right now, all I had was ‘The Sharing Economy’. I wanted something in which ‘The Sharing Economy’ could have positive impact on a wicked problem somewhere in the world. So I asked myself the question:
How can the sharing economy make air polluted areas in China more livable for humans?
I think this is a nice starting point from which I can further go into the innovation process. Although I still have a hard time to think this is actually a really good intent statement. Intent statements are more about choosing a certain opportunity to innovate. I don’t know if I did this correct.
Sorting insights
07 November 2014 — Today, I printed all my insights on A5-papers and sticked them all on the wall inside our classroom. I wanted to discover patterns in the insights that I had found. The results were as followed:
The following themes arose from sorting the insights:
- Sharing is about trust
- Sharing something will increase the value of that which is shared
- Not letting other people miss things
- Rules for sharing
- Letting others know what you’re about
Doing desk research
08 November 2014 —To get a better grip on the context of this design project, I made a list of topics on which I wanted to know more.
- Air pollution in China
- Preserving heat
- Sharing economy in China
- Smartphone usage in China
- Urbanization in China
I started googling. I was putting my articles into tables divided by topics. In this way, I would have an easy overview of the different topics I’ve been researching, the hyperlinks to the articles and a short summary of each article to determine if a hyperlink is relevant enough to open.
Get Nick van den Tol’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Doing desk research has been very helpful. I seriously feel like I have a better understanding of the context of this design project.
Start ideation
09 November 2014 — Now that I’d got to know people, stated a design challenge and know more about the context of my design problem, I had enough input to start crafting my first concepts for this project. For next Monday, I needed at least three reasonable concepts. I will present them down here in formats I used to display my concepts:
On safari: Day 1
11 November 2014 — Today, I started on a week long exams for this minor. I will do 20 assignments in total. I will explain briefly what the assignments will be like.
Assignment #1
Describe at least three myths of innovation based on Scott Berkun’s book called ‘The Myths of Innovation’. For each myth of innovation, I needed to explain how it can help me as an innovator.
Assignment #2
The second assignment was a group assignment. We needed to reorganize our classroom to make it more preferable for being creative. One of the leading elements in this were a vision we formulated at the beginning of this minor and the book ‘Making Space’ by Scott Doorley and Scott Witthoft.
Assignment #3
This was an individual assignment. I needed to formulate disruptive hypotheses based on the writings of Luke Williams (frog). I formulated a question in the beginning of this:
How can we disrupt the competitive landscape of heating systems in China by delivering an unexpected solution?
Next, I designed disruptive hypotheses on this. Things that came out of this:
- Invert a cliché. What if households provided house heating for coal plants? (interaction)
- Invert another cliché. What if heating is not consumed inside buildings? (product)
- Deny a cliché. What if you would never pay for house heating? (price)
- Deny another cliché. What if people don’t need heating during cold winter days? (product)
- Scale a cliché. What if only one household needed to be provided with heating throughout whole China? (product)
Assignment #4
Next, we needed to write our insights down once more time, but only the nine that were the most interesting.
Assignment #5
For this assignment, I needed to find new interpreters. 3 of them. So I did. For the sake of privacy, I will not mention their names here.
Assignment #6
The last assignment of today was feedback each others blogs. Mine was received quite positively. I think I should define more clearly which part of the design process I’m in when I’m posting new things, so I’ll work on it.
On safari: Day 2
12 November 2014 — The second day of exam safari. I was wondering what the assignment would be like. I’ll post them once again down here.
Assignment #7
Saskia showed us a video of David Kelley in building creative confidence. You can watch it also, here. Kelley names an important psychologist, Albert Bandura. We needed to write an essay of 350 words about his theory on self-efficacy.
Assignment #8
Next, I needed to formulate six facts about my target group. Mine were:
- Chinese people use humour to deal with bad air pollution
- Chinese people can’t read the road signs very well during the fog
- Chinese people share mostly with familiar people, ranging from
family, friends and classmates - Chinese people want to share the good and positive things
- Chinese people think sharing has to do something with love
- When Chinese people share something, the shared thing becomes
more valuable to them
Assignment #9
For this next assignment, I needed to download the Human-centered Design Kit by IDEO. It is a very cool document, you should check it out here. We did some exercises on interviewing and observing people. After that, together with Lydia, I went outside to interview some people.
The results of the interviews needed to be presented in a visual.
Assignment #10
This was about writing down which design methods you’ve used from Vijay Kumar’s book. Easy peasy.
Assignment #11
This assignment was about writing which psychological theories from the lectures you would like to use in the future for this project.
- I will make use of the psychological insight that someone’s
identity can be extracted from brands. My product/service has to
be branded in some way, in order to let it be attractive to people
to extract their identity from. You can see examples of identity in
Adam Curtis’ The Century of the Self, where women start smoking
out of independancy and people can buy clothes that makes them
feel special. - I will be using the psychological theory of social capital. Since
it involves a large group of people using something, I want to find
out if there is something within this theory that I can use to create
some sort of community. - I will make use of telling the narrative of a picture. We exercised
this once in class, but I think when I have done more observations
and made photos of it, it can be very handy in helping me watch
with judging, but also in interpreting photos.
Assignment #12
This was a personal assignment. I needed to choose five pictures that I made during my minor that were good moments.
On safari: Day 3
13 November 2014 — Day three. Let’s go.
Assignment #13
I had around two hours to refine my existing three concepts. I will post them here soon.
Assignment #14
This next assignment was a group assignment. We had to plot our concepts in a matrix. How radical is your innovation and for how many people will it be meaningful?
Assignment #15
Another group assignment. We needed to create energizers with at least six people that did not participate in this minor. Movie will up soon.
Assignment #16, #17 & #18
I needed to refine three earlier assignments from this exam safari. I made minor changes.
On safari: Day 4
14 November 2014 — The last day. One more time!
Assignment #19
Give each other feedback on each other’s concepts. So we did it.
Assignment #20
This was a fun closer. Leo Remijn came along and showed us cool stuff you can do with Arduino, Rasperry Pi and Makey Makey. We had a lot of fun experimenting. Thanks Leo.
Reflection on the safari
To be honest, I am glad we did this. It really forced me to make choices. I acknowledge I kind of paralyzed because of the chaos that is provided by the creative process. But I feel urged to master this. To be continued…
During the weekend, I decided to already work out one concept to a more plausible level. The result is down here:
What is the status?
17 November 2014 — Today, we inventoried where everybody was in his creative process. We discussed the concepts briefly, but most of all we discussed the interpreter’s network.
Two concepts left
18 November 2014 — During this day, Saskia asked us to form groups of two people. These groups will discuss their concepts and rate them. I did this together with Jean. The concept that would get the lowest rating would be removed. You would have two concepts left after this. The concepts that I had left were ‘The Chinese Happiness Scale’ and ‘Share a Laugh’.
One concept left
20 November 2014 — Today we made a list of the things we still need to do, because prototyping will start next Wednesday. I made a list of interpreters I would like to add to my network and the research topics that I want to know more about.
Besides the list, we did some exercises in eventually having one concept left. We did an exercise in which we displayed which things were in the concept and which were not (see picture below) viewed from the perspective of different jobs that exist now and that will exist in 2030.
We also made a quick overview of what were good and bad moments in the journey for the different stakeholders.
In the end, I only had one concept left. This was of course ‘Share a Laugh’ — I already worked it out much further, but I also was enriched by the different things we did to choose and strengthen our concepts.
Personas, scenario’s and storyboards
24 November 2014 —Saskia told us to prepare a low-fidelity prototype to test onWednesday. I will need personas, scenarios and a low-fidelity prototype to make this happen. So I started working on these things right away.
I learned how to set up a prototyping session properly. Thanks to the making of good personas and scenarios that give depth to a testing session, I now understand better how personas and scenarios should be like.
Low-fidelity prototyping
25 November 2014 — Today we were going to test our prototypes. I made the following low-fidelity prototype:
My low-fidelity prototype is substitute for the situation in which my concept will or can be used and for the main interaction that happens with the actual application.
The application ‘Xixi’ can only be used when air pollution is above a certain level according to the Air Quality Index API (which will be connected to the application).
The scenarios I made are designed according to the user insight that most Chinese people stay inside their homes (or another building) when the air is very polluted.
I prototyped this environment by placing a wall between the two people that will interact. In my opinion, this represents the disconnection with the physical appearance of a person.
The interaction between the users of this application will be through screens. But the core interaction — giving positive energy to users who request this — is prototyped.
I used envelopes with cards in it that represent the interaction. The cards have fill-in forms, so they can be filled in according to how a persona would act to it. What will be filled in is somewhat specified in the personas.
A new concept with drones
26 November 2014 — During the morning, we did some practical things. We inventoried what we wanted to see and do for our Barcelona field trip that will be in happening in two weeks. Together with Leonne and Myrte, I made a list of the things we wanted to see and do.
We also made some time in creating a brand around our minor so we can show this in Barcelona to the Spanish universities. We did this quick and dirty. We also created a nice slogan and a concept draft for a wrapper around the Dopper (Dutch Design bottles).
Later during the day, I looked at my current concept and my results from the prototyping session. I wasn’t satisfied, I felt like there was a lot of things that I still needed to work on. Together with Anne, I did a new ideation session for my concept.
In the evening, I created a new concept based on the ideation session earlier that day. The following concept came out of this:
During the concept development of ‘Share a Laugh’, I focused a lot on positive energy and the role that emotions would play in creating this positive energy collectively.
The shift in concept development and focussing more on the sharing part of tangible stuff during air pollution felt like a quite radical shift. But it gives me a better feeling of potential success if worked out well. I think a feeling of trust in the design process is essential in convincing presentations to make sure the design finds a spot in the real world.
When you are working for a client you cannot do this. In the future, I will need to make sure that publications and desk research are also stated on statement cards so I can show where it came from.
Design Ethics
01 December 2014 — Charlie Mulholland gave a presentation on design and ethics. He showed some very nice models made by the Technical University in Delft. It was very interesting.
Furthermore, I conducted research with Myrte and Leonne on where to go in Barcelona. Saskia asked us all to prepare a trip based on your chosen subject. Our subject is ‘Emotional Technologies’.
More lab
02 December 2014 —Today Leo Remijn came along to tell us a little bit more about Arduino and smart objects. He explained a more technical side. But before we went into that, Anne and Lydia giving a short presentation about a few lectures they attended.
After that, Leo came along. He did his explanation about the technical side of Arduino. Our assignment was to start building something ourselves made by this technology.
Afterwards, the idea was to come up with ideas for using this technology. So together in groups of three people we brainstormed and we all wrote down our ideas on sticky notes. We discussed all the ideas together.
Then we got back to our groups, picked our best ideas (we could all pick one from each other) so that we ended up with three concepts. These three concepts will visualized and presented in front of class.
We chose a final concept and made a list of stuff we needed to make it. We will be really making this concept!
Psychology out of the Hague
03 December 2014 — Another guest lecture was on the program for this afternoon. This time it was about NLP (Neuro Linguistic Programming).
Barcelona preparations
08 December 2014 — We quickly made the last preparations for Barcelona during this last day. Together with Leonne and Myrte I created a walk based around the theme ‘Emotional Technology’. We printed these. Furthermore, some people designed nice signs for Doppers (Dutch Design Drinking Bottles). Let’s get going!
Walking and prototyping
10 December 2014 — I arrived in Barcelona the day before, but it was a day of relaxation. Today at 12 o’ clock, the official program started. We did the walking tour based on the theme ‘Emotional Technology’.
After we did the walk, we thought of improvements so that other people could experience it even better. The points of feedback were:
- Include the address of the bicycle rental shop.
- Adjust the route for cycling through Barcelona to cycle-friendly roads. Cycle-friendly roads are parts of the road where one can cycle separated from where the cars drive.
- At the exposition ‘Smart Flexibility’, people should see more other stuff. Especially, because the ‘Smart Flexibility’ exposition officialy ended in November. There are lots of other expositions to visit there. The museum officially opened last Sunday.
- Lastly and more in general, I think for future walks we should incorporate more technological stuff. The walk contains too much art now.
During the evening, we went to Bau University. Here I had my first session of feedbacking and prototyping with Spanish design students.
The results of these sessions will be summed up in the next day.
Bau University and Elisava
11 December 2014 —During our visit to Bau — a design school in the more Southern part of Barcelona — we had the opportunity to do an energizer with all the Spanish students.
The energizer we did was a walking game. All people stand in a circle and one person is counting. During every count, all people make one step. The fun part is that you can change tempos.
In my time at Bau, I had the opportunity to meet a total of three groups of first year design students. During the classes I had with them, I used this opportunity to test my prototype with them.
The prototype session was to fill in a request in needing a certain product. The first participant would make a title, a short description of their request, what category the product, the amount and what the maximum price to be paid should be.
Once the form was filled in, the second participant would be asked some questions by me such as: ‘Do you think — based on the price — this is a reasonable request?’.
What I noticed during all the sessions was that I missed forms for the amount (in kilograms, perhaps). Also, the forms had a title that said ‘What price will you ask?’. This is wrong from the perspective of the participant making the request, so I changed it to ‘What maximum price do you want to pay?’.
Next, most participants had a hard time in coming up titles and short descriptions. It was hard for them to understand the context in which they should be written. I should make this more clear.
Next, I asked the second participant about the asked price that the first participant filled in. The second participants told me that there should be more profit in it for them — having a sense of helping people is not enough, they want to earn extra money.
After this, we also had a tour around the Elisava Design School (which is a very nice building by the way). At the end of the guided tour at Elisava, we went on pitching for Jorge Rodriguez Nieto. He is a teacher at Elisava.
I prepared the first four lines of my pitch very well, but I failed in executing them right. I became frustrated with the fact that the beginning failed, so my pitch became a kind of improvisation. Too bad, but it teached me to just keep a main structure (write down keywords perhaps) for pitches.
The general feedback I will take with me is that I should become more clearer in what I’m trying to solve, for whom and why I do it. This is not presented well enough in the pitch. I will work on this, so I can show later during this week in my little conversation with Ruth if I went in the right direction.
Discussing the psychology assignment
15 December 2014—Because everyone was having a hard time figuring out how to deal with the psychology assignment we got from Marina, we used today’s class to figure out what to do.
The assignment covers the three layers of Simon Sinek’s Golden Circle. Each assignment covers a part of it: The why, the how and the what. Knowing this made it easier for me to start with this assignment.
We did a small exercise in this by all pronouncing our why, how we are going to fulfill the why and what psychological theories could be used in this. I think it was very helpful.
Talk with Saskia
16 December 2014—Today I had a quick talk with Saskia about where I’m at with my project. She asked me to tell what my plans were for the weeks to come.
My plan is to design two touchpoints of the ecosystem that I designed: Those are the application of the service and the drone will be designed as well. The application can be build as a high-fidelity prototype in Flinto, the drone is still a matter to think more about. It can be build from Lego or perhaps just for real by renting one from the lab downstairs at this university.
Talk with Ruth
17 December 2014 — Ruth and I also had a conversation today about my concept. She wanted to know if I specified my concept enough and if I could tell about it shortly to see if it is logical and understandable.
Duo talk with Marina and Karman
18 December 2014—On this day, there was a duo talk planned with Marina and two students. I did this talk together with Karman. Marina started the conversation with a question: “What is your why?”. I told her my ‘why’ that being healthy is important. Marina told me that this was too easy — a good why is defined by the ambiguity in it. It is widely interpretable and can therefore attract a wide range of people.
Marina also mentioned the universal human rights and if they were incorporated into our design(s). She said it is wise to check this out.
Afterwards, Alyssa gave a workshop about painting. She brought materials so we could try this out ourselves, and it was fun. The result will be shown down here.
Current state of prototypes
04 January 2015 — During my two-week holiday, I decided to start working on my high-fidelity prototype for the application as well for the drone.
You can check out the current version of my application here. If the link only provides one screen, let me know. I will send you an e-mail that gives you total access to see it. Feedback is welcome.
Preparing for the Dragon’s Den
05 January 2015 — Next Wednesday is my new chance to pitch my concept. Luckily we exercised this throughout the entire lesson today. Afterwards, I practiced my pitch with Sam a little bit more.
I also thought of a good name for my design now. It’s going to be called airCommerce. I created a logo for this:
Visuals and a business model
06 January 2015 — I created some accompanying visuals for my pitch tomorrow. Little quick and dirty on the drone here.
I also worked on the business model. I will share it with you later, once it’s done! Furthermore, I did some pitch training together with Sam. Video’s below:
Pitches at De Bakkerij
07 January 2015 — Pitch day! Lots of fun, lots of learnings…
In contrast to my last pitch at Elisava, this one went a lot better. I am satisfied, because there is a better energy level in this pitch. I feel like I am slowly learning to put more emotion into my story. For the next time I will pitch, I will try even harder. Thanks everyone for the feedback!
A visit at Laurenskerk
09 January 2015— A few weeks ago I had contact through mail with a possible new interpreter, so I visited her at the Laurenskerk in Rotterdam. We discussed the possibility of her testing my prototype. I also managed to visit her friend this Tuesday for the testing as well. She works at Lines and Lanes, the company from Vanessa that gave us a lecture! A mere coincidence.
Quantified stress
12 January 2015 — Results from Arduino!
Test session at Lines and Lanes
13 January 2015 —
Academieplein and Schiekade
14 January 2015 — In the morning we discussed with the entire class what was left to do for the promotion of this minor. After that, together with some other students, I had a feedback meeting with Ruth at Schiekade.
The one thing with which I struggled most was the fact that Lulu told me yesterday that the micro-entrepreneurship might not work properly the way I imagined it. This gave me doubts about what to do with my value proposition. Ruth told me it could be good without it. And it’s not a problem if it’s not perfect at the end of this period. Just try to get as far as you can.
Later during the day, I had a meeting with Joey. He is an Industrial Design student at Academieplein and we made a little deal that I would help him design something visually, he would help me with a 3D model of a drone and some usability testing. You can view the testing down below here.
Business modeling and psychology
15 January 2015 —
I finished filling in the Business Model Canvas by Osterwalder. To create a better value proposition, I used some Empathy Mapping (right picture).
Psychology and design principles
16 January 2015 —
17 January 2015 —
The final one pager
18 January 2015 —
Interesting articles
Benjamin, W. (1936). The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction
Bohlmeijer, L. (2014). Waarom ondernemers de nieuwe wereldverbeteraars zijn
Bulajewski, M. (2014) The Cult of Sharing
Carney, S. (2014). Design Thinking is Dead. Long Live Design Thinking.
Crook, J. (2014) Be Smarter Than That, Uber Users
Curtis, A. (2002). The Century of the Self: Hapiness Machines
Curtis, A. (2002). The Century of the Self: The Engineering of Consent
Curtis, A. (2002). The Century of the Self: Eight People Sipping Wine in Kettering
Fabricant, R. (2014). The Rapidly Disappearing Business of Design
Freud, S. (1899). The Interpretation of Dreams
frog Design (2014). Tech Trends Report 2014
Lawson, S. (2014). The Trouble with Design Thinking
Leberecht, T. (2009). A New Era of Meaning
Leech, J. (2012). Psychology for Designers: A blog accompanying the pocket ebook by Joe Leech
Meeuwisse, M. (2008). Fotografie als dialect
Roberts, A. (2014). Why Public Sector Needs Service Design
Smith, E. (2013). Meaning is Healthier Than Happiness
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948)










