DEEPSEA CHALLENGE: Engineering the Abyss
San Diegan Bruce Sutphen was the U.S. project manager for the DEEPSEA CHALLENGE. Bruce was part of the Sub Team, Lander Team, and Launch and Recovery Team. A physicist by education, Sutphen has 25 years in scaled modeling and project-management experience associated with Grand Prix Yachting (including Circumnavigation and America’s Cup campaigns). He has also worked on U.S. military and subsea robotics programs.
What was your role and responsibilities, as the U.S. Project Manager for the DEEPSEA CHALLENGE?
James Cameron and Ron Allum came up with the idea of the DEEPSEA CHALLENGER, originally called Deep Challenger in 2005. In April of 2011, Jim was looking for a project manager in the U.S. as the Australian based project was not progressing as fast as he needed to. The main issues was that he had commitments with 20th Century Fox to deliver the Avatar sequels. He had to have the expedition completed by September 1st of 2012. Somehow my CV ended up on his desk. My reputation to deliver projects on schedule-a significant take away from working on four America’s Cup campaigns where everything is time sensitive,if you fall behind the regatta is not going to wait for you-combined with my scale modeling experience made me a fairly attractive resource. Jim also felt that he was leaning on the Australian team too hard. To mitigate any further schedule creep, he thought a North American borne team working in parallel was the way to go. He drew a line in the sand, letting the Australians continue to work on what they already had in the hopper and then he made the US Team responsible for the critical path tasks that had yet to be started.
At first, there was no commercially available foam which was safe for a human occupied full ocean depth vehicle. We had to develop and synthesize a variant of foam suitable for the project. The Australians were already well under way on coming up with a solution to this problem. The pressure sphere, hatch and penetrator plate was also done in Australia, it was actually done and qualified in 2009. The pressure hull is an alloyed steel sphere where the pilot cockpit is, it is the only 1ATM habitat in the vehicle, everything else is at ambient pressure. It was made from the same alloy that they used on the Trieste pressure hull, an alloyed steel initially developed in the 1940′s for large gun barrels.
Jim has a very high allegiance to the people and groups of people that helped him to become as successful as he has become. He holds very high regards for his special effect team. Bay area based Edge Innovations is part of this group that is incredibly creative when challenged. They are the world leader in animatronics. They did the killer whale for Free Willy, the dolphin for Flipper and the shark with laser beams for Austin Powers. Jim asked me to work with Walt Conti and Ty Boyce owners of Edge Innovations to develop the robotics for the vehicle. All the robotics and scale modeling were done in the States along with a lot of the composite development.
Is that why the landers were made by SCRIPPS, because of your connections in San Diego?
The lander was not even on the table when I first got involved in May of 2011. When we really started to pick up some speed, it became apparent to Jim that if he did not have another camera system down there it would be hard to get pictures of the sub. He needed additional resources to pick up samples along with another data acquisition system. That is when he turned to Kevin Hardy, who I was acquainted to from his outstanding work in deep ocean exploration. We pulled him in to create yet another chapter for the U.S. development team. Kevin had a lot of experience with autonomous units which he coined “landers”. Key to Kevin’s development was the mandate of incorporation of technology transfer from the sub itself. He used the same batteries, the same light, same camera, same foam. It was a very lean development using poltruded fiberglass frames and Vitrovex Sphere pressure housings. It resulted in a very elegant solution.
You talked previously about the similitude in between the America’s Cup and DEEPSEA CHALLENGE can you elaborate?
The way Jim approaches movie or a project, and the way the success of America’s Cup campaign works from a management standpoint are quite similar. The number one rule is to not try to bear the burden of all the non-recurring engineering; but instead align with the industry leading specialists and technologies and finally focus on integration. It is much more about having the go to resources, your magic Rolodex if you will. A commonality among these resources is the interest in researching all technologies that are available no matter the industry, and not feeling constrained by how those technologies are being applied in a given environment. What they do is that they take these technologies and pry them into the problems they have in front of them. I found the DEEPSEA CHALLENGE to be very similar to the America’s Cup in terms of the management scheme and problem solving methodology.
Working with Jim you have very defined leadership. It is a very lean, very efficient management system that get answers quickly and cost efficiently. I ended up going to some of my America’s Cup resources because I knew what they could do and how to effectively communicate the end goal to them. There were issues that they could not help me with, so I had to go to other resources. The U.S. team built a significant amount of the composite parts of the submarine. Some of them we had built in Compton in California by a company called Performance Composites. Their core business is building fiberglass parts for “Zambonis” and moulds and parts for the wind turbines industry. Before we approached them they had never built anything that went underwater. There was another part of the composite that was built by Hall Spars a mass mast manufacturer who has been involved with the fabrication and design of Grand Prix Yachting masts including Oracle’s wing designs used in the last two successful campaigns. We tapped into the top level resources and then what we were left with was a management integration exercise. My professional tenure lent itself well to what Jim was attempting to achieve. It worked! But the reason it worked is because we are quite similar in our belief in how to get something done quickly and effectively. I have also a very long allegiance to my resource pool and associated network. Why? Because they deliver.
From Revolution to Evolution
There is something quite puzzling in the engineering and development of DEEPSEA CHALLENGER. How do you develop such a complex deepsea vehicle complete with life support without much data from these incredible depth?
It is the same question you could ask about how do you develop an America’s Cup boat that is doing 26 knots upwind one week and the next it is going 30 in the same conditions. How do you do that? The way you accomplish this is you take people in your team that do not get bogged down by the preconceived data; but instead focus their attention on evaluating new data sets. With the new data sets, they quickly work on new methodologies to further characterize the perceived constraint and develop through or around it. It is a fascinating and very rewarding process.
“How can we get technology to understand and survey the ocean in a very constructive way? Making data coherent, and reducing it into a functional conclusion/discussion to the end user is incredibly important. This is really the importance of what Marinexplore is all about. You guys are the facilitators of the future wave of understanding.”
I am a physicist, but I love composite technology. Carbon fiber is an incredibly efficient material when used properly. And that is when used in and about 1 atmosphere. However, I found carbon fiber laminates to behave quite differently in a 1,100 Bar ambient environment. That was something I really had to get my head around. My assumptions were no longer correct, what happens to carbon matrix, the toughened epoxy matrix at depth is rather unique. The bulk modulus of the Carbon is significantly higher than the toughened epoxy matrix holding it together. Oddly enough, at FOD (full ocean depth) we actually observed that the carbon start pulverizing the matrix. Take this through several cycles and you end up with something that is not the same thing that you started with.
Get nico danan’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Our composite research lead us to a polyester fiber because of its similar bulk modulus to the matrix and the fact that it was readily available. The cloth fiber that we ended up using is most commonly used when building seawalls. In the end it is all about understanding all the different ingredients you have in front of you and then getting creative on how to elegantly solve the problem. The importance of properly identifying the problem and the elements can never be understated. That is when you get a revolution, and evolution in designs. If you completely rely on something that has been done historically while adding new data to it you will not be able to evolve and revolutionize the design. You will just refine the design. What is really interesting is the way that Jim pulls people together from so many different industries, with so many different experiences. You end up getting people that are not constrained by existing technologies in a given industry. In this case it ended up being the manned submersible industry. Everyone on the team is fully aware that the ultimate solution of today is prehistoric in 10 years time. If not tomorrow!
Helix Submarine Dive Trajectory
What was the biggest technical challenge?
One significant issue we had is that the vehicle would tumble. The initial CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics) showed that it would tumble in both descent and ascent. It was spending more than 50% of its time rolling at +/- 15 degrees. This rapid oscillation would have been incredibly uncomfortable for the pilot riding for two hours down and 70 minutes up. If you look at the back of the vehicle, you will see these two stabilizer fins that folds up inside the vehicle, they are made out of 7000 series aluminum and our syntactic foam. They were designed to be neutrally buoyant in their moment, as soon as there was fluid flow across them, one would fold in, and the other one would deploy and vice versa. By incorporating a bias, via camber in these fins, we were able to mitigate the vehicle’s line of flight, by ascending and descending in a helical trajectory. It would do 1 3/4 revolution per minute, on a 25 to 30 meter diameter circumference of this helix.
We also had a data transfer challenge. The only way to transfer data through water is using acoustics or sound, the speed of sound travel depends on the density. For this reason, you would have significant signal attenuation or degradation if the Mother Ship is not directly above the vehicle when at full ocean depth. Because we were able to do that, just going helical down not with a line of flight, we were able to get higher data rates than expected even allowing true voice data back from Jim although it took a little over 14 seconds for one to get the answer to a question. At first we did not think it was possible with the equipment when we were developing it in cooperation with Nautronics/L3 Technologies. As we were able to mitigate the attenuation, the deflection and refraction of those acoustic signals, we got a higher a bandwidth that we originally calculated or expected.
All throughout the issues and challenges, Jim made sure everybody was in the know. Everyone had to disclose everything, all their issues and problems: full transparency. That way when a person or group did not have the resources to solve issues, we could draw from other specialists on the team.
Stealth at Sea: M80 Stiletto
You were involved in the development of stealth craft, the Stiletto for the Office of Secretary of Defense. What kind of engineering challenges did you encounter there?
It was during George W. Bush first term, he and Donald Rumsfeld came up with this idea. They created the Office of Forced Transformation. The Office of the Secretary of Defense was attempting to do exactly what Jim was doing with DEEPSEA CHALLENGE, creating a lean and efficient developing task force. That boat was actually owned by the Office of the Secretary of Defense. It was not immediatly admired or appreciated by the Office of Naval Research. It goes against what their mandate is. They are all about developing projects and technologies internally. When we worked on the Stiletto, we were a little group, very lean. We signed a $6.2 million contract with the U.S. Government and one year later they were sitting on an 88 foot and 40 and half foot wide, insurgence craft. Weighting 50 tonne Ligh Ship and almost 80 fully loaded cruising in excess of 50 knots. The U.S. Army used it a lot. The Department of Homeland Security has used it as well. The Army used in a collaborative effort with the Colombian army to go after waterborne transportation of narcotics like drug submarines. The M80 Stiletto was built as a technology demonstrator with a life expectancy of 3 to 5 years. I have recently learned that the Navy has just extended its service life for another additional 5 years on top of the 7 years. It has more carbon fiber than one of these America’s cup boat, this craft is about 25 metric tons of carbon. We could sure use a couple more government projects that are as cost effective.
What are the necessary technologies needed to become stealth at sea?
Here is the issue, the Navy had built stealth boats before, they were invisible to radar as long as they sit still. As soon as they start propagating through the water they generate a significant wake, an easily detectable radar signature. You can even pick that up from a satellite imagery. As soon as they moved they were sticking out like a sore thumb. The Stiletto was developed from a failed America’s Cup experiment by team Stars & Stripes. They had figured out how to create a wake less boat. It was not useful to the America’s Cup team, but a reallocation and application of the technology created a boat that redirected its wave train back underneath the boat, canceling it out via destructive interference.
No Ego in Team Work
It seems you always find yourself in a similar type of environment that often lead to success what is the secret?
There is no ego in those type of team environment, people just want to participate into something that is bigger than themselves. First and foremost we are all friends and teammates. It is an incredible collective effort. When you get into these groups, the team almost want to make mistakes as when making mistakes they learn more. It is like a good entrepreneur. They want to make the mistakes to learn. That being said, if somebody else is going to stick their hand in the fire, they would rather learn from somebody else getting burnt to figure out that the fire is hot right? It always comes back to the open mindedness. There are a lot of different ways to do something. There is also the understanding that tomorrow it is going to get done better than it is today. They have adopted the whole attitude about revolution and evolution of design, instead of refinement. If you dwell on the failure you are going to have a hard time.
There is a classic thing I learn in my first America’s Cup, fortunately for me my first experience in the America’s Cup was a good one because we won. In that campaign, there was a saying :
“Assume nothing, blame no one, do something”
You have managed an expedition where you put a man on the deepest place on earth, what will you invest yourself into next?
It has become daunting to me personally how little utilized and understood our deep oceans are. Altogether we did 13 dives with the DEEPSEA CHALLENGER, it is like skydiving over a Nebraskan cornfield and say “Now I understand what America is about!”. You really have no idea, you are missing all the diversity and complexity of such a huge country. What has piqued my curiosity are the new technologies: AUVs, ROVs and manned vehicles capable of exploring this earth biggest resource. It is fascinating to me for several reasons: first, so we stop abusing the ocean, and second so we can utilize the ocean correctly. My wife and I have two daughters an 11 year old and a 7 year old, last year I went to my 11 year old class and gave a presentation that Jim presented to the American Geophysics Union, last November. When I got in there the teacher told me “This should be 30 to 40 minutes, because the kids attention span is quite limited”. I showed a 25 min movie clip and then they had non stop questions for an hour and 5 min until they had used up all the allotted time and their recess. Today these kids are getting this wealth of knowledge built into their fundamental youth experiences of what is happening right now via all types of media right at their finger tips. My generation did not have that luxury. We had the luxury of following explorers like Jacques Cousteau and astronauts in libraries and periodically on television. Now we have a new breed of explorers like James Cameron with an aim to educate through a visual immersion sharing their expeditions to investigate the unexplored.
So for all of us involved, the next step is drawing from the experiences on the DEEPSEA CHALLENGE and building upon to grow new technologies to be able to apply them for next explorations. Jim has done 85 dives and somewhere in between eight and twelve expeditions. I do not believe that he will ever stop exploring, but for now, he has to go back to his day job. When he has completed his movie obligations, I expect that he will have a new and wild exploration project that he will pursue. His core, as an explorer combined with his incredible imagination fits perfectly well with technology developments. The gained skill sets of the people involved in a project like this are part of the incredible legacy left behind the DEEPSEA CHALLENGE. It is like a quantum leap.
Story originally published on Planet OS Blog http://blog.planetos.com/deepsea-challenge-engineering-the-abyss/










