Sitemap

Growing up on the Internet

Anonymity, reality, and unexpected permanence

5 min readFeb 14, 2014

--

Many of us have probably done a cleanse of our online presence, trying to eliminate the evidence of the silly behaviors of our younger selves. Last night, as I was talking with my roommate about his efforts to clean up his online identity, the gravity of the fact that we were among the first people to grow up on a non-anonymous Internet hit me.

This post is an attempt to recall my very own Internet narrative, so it’s pretty high-level and not especially groundbreaking (many others have written about the trends I mention in depth), but for me it’s a starting point for picking things apart further.

Identity Play as an Anonymous Youth

My first dives into Internet life happened in middle school. I spent hours communicating with people via Yahoo chat rooms, web forums, and LiveJournal about the niche interests that no one in my IRL world seemed to share.

I built websites and communities under a pseudonym, warned by parents and teachers that if I revealed any hint of my real identity, I would be kidnapped. My first boyfriends were online. They thought I was seventeen and had no idea what I looked like. For all I knew, they were just playing around too. The Internet enabled me to create multiple identities and experiment with emphasizing different fragments of my sense of self freely.

As MMORPGs entered the picture, it was even easier to keep track of these identities. I primarily played the super-cute Ragnarok Online on a private server with a forum and IRC channel fostering a close-knit community.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Old Ragnarok drawings.

Most of my characters were known to belong to the same person, but it was also easy to create a new character that no one knew was me. I could be a boy for a day. I could tell people that I was from another state. I could lie about my age. While such fraudulent identity building might at a glimpse seem sneaky, it played a huge role in becoming comfortable with all aspects of who I was, and who I am.

Get Alyce Currier’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Eventually, I began to reveal parts of my real identity online. On both Ragnarok Online and Livejournal, my real first name, Alyce, slipped out. I don’t remember where it happened first. My closest online friends began to call me Alyce, and I began to refer to my closest online friends by their real names, too, across multiple channels.

Inevitably, we began to reveal more and more details about our real lives. There was one year when I couldn’t tell people it was my birthday, because I was worried that the lie my younger self had told about her age to establish more legitimacy in the community would be revealed. I eventually posted one of my first selfies in a thread on the forum. There was no turning back from there.

Selfie from the early years.

High School on MySpace and Facebook

MySpace entered its prime when I was in high school. Although I didn’t have many friends in my local community, I reluctantly created a profile where I mostly interacted with my Stop & Shop coworkers. Suddenly, being online was about fitting in instead of experimenting. My online behaviors were directly tied to the place I had to return to day after day, so I had to play the game in a way that had never felt necessary before.

MySpace replicated social life in some ways, but in other ways, it broke down the social boundaries that were more rigidly drawn in the hallways of Dennis-Yarmouth Regional High School. I remember feeling confused after jocks complimented my selfies, because those people had never spoken to me in class, and they probably never would. AIM became more connected to real life than ever before, and crushes and drama played out via chat windows and away messages instead of interpersonal communication.

Again, the Internet offered a space where we were comfortable with experimentation. But this time, that experimentation was tied to our real identities, on permanent record.

I am both sad and grateful that MySpace changed gears and made all of that old data a lot harder to track down. Facebook, on the other hand, continues to maintain a record of every social interaction I had on their platform since 2005. In 2005, I was 16 years old. I was dating my first IRL boyfriends, I was starting to have more IRL friends, and instead of our interactions being sacred little rituals that we could look back on fondly and privately, many of them are on public record.

Shared Paranoia and Shared Acceptance

People my age, who grew up with this permanent record of our online social interaction, are entering adulthood, and most of us have learned what we want from our online identities and how to achieve those goals.

What worries me is that for many, this has led to highly-curated online identities devoid of authenticity or personality, driven by paranoia. While I fully support efforts towards more privacy online and educating people about how not to make major faux pas in building online identity, too often, these efforts strip our online interactions of the whimsy that made the early Internet so powerful.

Accountability is a hard thing to define on the Internet. Things like past relationships, life mistakes, or awkward interactions that would otherwise blur into memory remain intact in virtual time capsules. We can effortlessly re-explore any sensitive moment in our own lives, or in someone else’s. Every one of us has done something we were embarrassed about before, whether it’s an offhanded comment or a weepy breakdown at a party.

An online overreaction is much easier to revisit than one that happened in real life, and for better or worse, the memories are all the more vivid. In our social and professional lives alike, I hope that we can reach a more forgiving, welcoming place, where no single online misstep can ruin anyone’s potential.

--

--

Alyce Currier
Alyce Currier

Written by Alyce Currier

A uniform gelatinous blob. Content strategist @formlabs, DJ @lycheefrut.