Sitemap
Nicholas Pappageorge

Nicholas Pappageorge

Expert generalist. Analyzing robotics, IoT, and a lot more @CBInsights

Review of “Deep Economy” by Bill Mckibben

The famed eco-economist says buying local is the remedy

3 min readJul 15, 2014

Wal-Mart is killing jobs. Americans import Danish sugar cookies, while Danes import American sugar cookies. And farmers no longer say hello to their neighbors.

Get Nicholas Pappageorge’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

It is not by some perverted swing of history that these shortcomings and idiosyncrasies of globalized life came about, posits Bill McKibben in his book Deep Economy. Rather, it is a direct result of our endless obsession with economic growth. Under this ubiquitous growth mantra, our economy developed and propelled us into a “world of More,” all at the expense of the environment. And, shockingly, it has made us less happy, less wealthy, and more culturally divided.

McKibben’s book:

McKibben frames the problem in that we are a society in need of repair, both in terms of our economic ideals and our worldviews. In his book of only five chapters, he delivers a satisfying and complete solution to this multifaceted problem: bring back the localized economy.

McKibben recognizes why as a people we gravitate toward economic growth: it’s what has worked for us. It is not an inherently dishonest goal—he recognizes that poorer nations do need to be developed—instead, his main qualm is simply that our country’s example of development may actually be a cautionary tale. One powerful statistic: “Unabated climate change could make us 20 percent poorer by century’s end, which would be a bigger economic dent than WWI, WWII, and the Great Depression combined,” (25). By this, we are putting are putting an incomprehensible burden on our physical world and in the process defeating our original goal of prosperity.

Deep Economy is a fast read, with hardly a dull sentence. At times, however, it can be overwhelming to comprehend all of the issues and lenses through which McKibben applies this thesis. He employs just about every contemporary issue overheard in a public policy or environmental science class and relates it back to the ills of growth. Deep Economy delves into everything from unfair coffee trade, to wealth inequality and obesity, and surprisingly offers the same simple solution: more localized trade. At first it seems like a one-solution-fits-all idea, but after enough reiteration, community-based economies truly seem like an inspiring, realistic, and often delicious alternative.

McKibben goes into a tad too much detail in the profile of his local economy around Middlebury, Vermont, that he explored during his self-challenge of going a whole winter consuming only locally grown foods. He spent the better part of a chapter describing everything from the fresh produce his neighbor grows, all the way down to the craft beer made (of course) just down the road from his post at Middlebury College. His world seems like a utopian ideal of food choice, no doubt a result of living in rural Vermont. It’s the only place where the books slipped in interest and realism (since 80% of Americans live in an urban area), and for a moment it felt like an extended advertisement by the Vermont Chamber of Commerce. Somehow, though, he brings this full circle by explaining that it isn’t very hard for communities to mold themselves into ones like this, and that everyone gains, even socially, by doing so.

Bringing things “full circle” is exactly where Deep Economy succeeds. McKibben’s heavily fact-based approach always returns to this notion that our economy is truly what we want it to be. After all, he notes, we were never really concerned about economic growth until after WWII. Why can’t this be our time to mobilize against our all-around damaging system? It’s a fresh and inspiring spin on environmentalism, economics, and culture, making it a must-read for hard-nosed economists as well as for anyone remotely conscious of the environment.

--

--

Nicholas Pappageorge
Nicholas Pappageorge

Written by Nicholas Pappageorge

Expert generalist. Analyzing robotics, IoT, and a lot more @CBInsights