FAQ: Natural Vines Movement
How we keep the magic of Vine
Q. What’s with this Natural Vines movement?
A. Limitation is what makes Vine magical. It forces us to think creative in analog way. It forces us to avoid any digital instant solution. Without this principal, Vine is just another social video services.
Q. What’s wrong with CGI Vine?
A. CGI artists think Vine is perfect for showing CGI magic. Why? Because it’s forbidden to use external CGI software on Vine. But once people hack it & put their CGI video on Vine, viewers are like “WHOA! HOW DID YOU DO THAT?” At least for now.
Do we still ask “How did the moviemaker do that?” when we’re watching Pacific Rim on theater? No. Because we know it’s CGI.
Just like magician on stage, people whisper to each other ‘How did he do that?’ because it’s not possible doing that magic WITHOUT SKILL.
As Dennis Muren from Industrial Light & Magic says “CGI special effects are not special anymore.”
Get Pinot’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Q. What is Natural Vines?
A. Vine that follows all these conditions:
- The material was done inside the app, with its standard tools & features.
- The material was not done with editing software outside Vine.
- The material was not done with special effects, CGI, 3D software outside Vine.
- The material was not hacked into the Vine app.
Q. What if I shot the outside video from TV, computer, iPad screen?
A. It’s considered as natural if following some of these conditions:
- The outside material is only the part of the story, not as the main story from 0-sec to 6-sec.
- The outside material is only the elements of the story, among other elements & environments.
- The outside material interacts with the story & other characters/elements.
Q. Is it natural if we use prerendered CGI & 3D objects in TV, computer, iPad screen?
A. Same answer above.
Q. Is it natural if we use prerendered CGI & 3D objects in other medium like projector or printed paper?
A. Same answer above.
Q. What if I use the outside audio like music from TV, computer, iPad speaker?
A. Music — like any other audio elements on Vine — is considered as natural elements, as long as not hacked into the Vine app. We know it’s hard to make a seamless music, but we consider it as a challenge, hence the part of the Vine art.







